2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

[frozensage]

selwood this week + pendle next?

my mid

mitchell, jobe, bartel, swallow, magner, conig (clay, ledger)

645k in bank.

this week
swallow/ledger -> old mac/joel selwood

next week
clay/conig -> pendle/miles(??)

leaves me broke but my mid is looking better.

what you guys think?

 

[reddahaydn]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Can you wait any longer before upgrading coniglio? I find that culling your cash cows so early looks good now but you won't come home as hard.
If you can wait a bit longer that would be ideal.
THat being said not having pendles would be killing you.
apart from that the trades don't look to bad.

I'm looking at trading either kerridge or dickson out for Treloar.
Which one would you guys keep?
thats 3 trades done and I won't trade again till about round 8 where I start building my bank

 

[toxic]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Can you wait any longer before upgrading coniglio? I find that culling your cash cows so early looks good now but you won't come home as hard.
If you can wait a bit longer that would be ideal.
THat being said not having pendles would be killing you.
apart from that the trades don't look to bad.

I'm looking at trading either kerridge or dickson out for Treloar.
Which one would you guys keep?
thats 3 trades done and I won't trade again till about round 8 where I start building my bank

bye bye dickson

 

[nabmeg]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

carrazzo for geary or michael johnson? or anyone else around 490k? leaning to geary atm

backline: goddards, delidio, suckling, carrazzo, hargrave, bugg, ellis, smedts, spurr

 

[The_Koach]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Hey Guys

who out of A.Hall or C.Smith would you first get rid of

and on a completely different matter....

who out of J.McDonald and A.Treloar would you bring in first


EDIT- above post i would also be leaning towards Geary, although it may be purely because I haven't seen enough of Johnson here in Victoria

 

[Feerits Elf]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Who to trade - Shiel or Greene?

 

[MightyMark]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Hey Guys

who out of A.Hall or C.Smith would you first get rid of

and on a completely different matter....

who out of J.McDonald and A.Treloar would you bring in first


EDIT- above post i would also be leaning towards Geary, although it may be purely because I haven't seen enough of Johnson here in Victoria

I'd go Smith to JMac, Smith doesn;t look like he is going to be back any time soon, and JMac will get you more points than Treloar by the time you up/downgrade him.

Who to trade - Shiel or Greene?

Why trade either, both still have plenty of money to make. If I had to choose though, i'd offload Greene, Sheil seems to be playing a bigger role at the moment.

 

[thecatattack]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Mummy for Cox or Nic Nat?

 

[MightyMark]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Mummy for Cox or Nic Nat?

Cox is due, but NicNat seems to be the number 1 ruck at WC now. Chances are Cox's days of mammoth scores are over. The time of Nic Nat has begun

 

[Feerits Elf]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Why trade either, both still have plenty of money to make. If I had to choose though, i'd offload Greene, Sheil seems to be playing a bigger role at the moment.

Benching GAJ so I want to upgrade one to a premium mid, just unsure which one to trade out.

Would be nice to keep both until they max out as cows but there's no accounting for injuries. Other mid rookies are mcdonald and magner.

 

[MightyMark]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Benching GAJ so I want to upgrade one to a premium mid, just unsure which one to trade out.

Would be nice to keep both until they max out as cows but there's no accounting for injuries. Other mid rookies are mcdonald and magner.

Fair enough, its really 50/50, if Greene hadn't have gotten 50 on the weekend he would have the wood over Sheil, but I think Sheil is going to improve on a slow start. Purely opinion though, and honestly my opinion has been a little off this year

But if you wanna go by the numbers, stats dictate Greene is the better player.

 

[RWnBluey]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Mummy for Cox or Nic Nat?

Neither TBH. Better options out there

Ziebell vs Barlow?

 

[toxic]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Neither TBH. Better options out there

Ziebell vs Barlow?

Neither going to be top 12 mids, so wait if possible

 

[Feerits Elf]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Ziebell for unique pick.

I think I'll have to hang on to Greene, cheers MightyMark.

 

[tubes82]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Out of those 2 I'd go Barlow. If u can get a premium though

My big dilemma!

Mumford > kreuzer/Mcintosh/cox/nic nat??????????

 

[Warsaw]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Deciding on which two should make the team and which two should stay on the bench.

Lucas v Magner v Devon Smith v Treloar

Thinking Treloar and Magner. But also weary of Lucas having a good game Subi.

???

 

[toxic]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Out of those 2 I'd go Barlow. If u can get a premium though

My big dilemma!

Mumford > kreuzer/Mcintosh/cox/nic nat??????????

On current form and $$$$ hard to go past Hmac

 

[RWnBluey]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

Neither going to be top 12 mids, so wait if possible

You can't see value in Ziebell for M6 with Norths easy draw and GWS in rd 23?

 

[Feerits Elf]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

^ plus GC this week.

Boyd or Rockliff?

 

[toxic]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

You can't see value in Ziebell for M6 with Norths easy draw and GWS in rd 23?

I see limited value in him,but 20+ mids who'll average more. Guess it depends on cash and balance.

 

[toxic]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

^ plus GC this week.

Boyd or Rockliff?

Now that's tuff, I have rocky but like Boyds durability

 

[tubes82]

Re: selwood this week + pendle next?

On current form and $$$$ hard to go past Hmac

Thanks mate. Was just worried about the Goldstien factor. Think I might grab him but Kruezer looks promising. Think I need a few more beers!

 

[dlanod]

Mummy for Cox or Nic Nat?

Ha, my question too. I'm thinking Nic Nat if I feel I have to trade.

Neither TBH. Better options out there

Useful answer there. Like who?

 

[toxic]

Ha, my question too. I'm thinking Nic Nat if I feel I have to trade.



Useful answer there. Like who?

Kruezer, Hmac would be options.

 

[MightyMark]

Ha, my question too. I'm thinking Nic Nat if I feel I have to trade.



Useful answer there. Like who?

Ryder should feature in you considerations. Cant ignore his form this year.