2012 Player X v Player Y

[Spider Klein]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Robinson, Beams, D. Smith

vs

Chapman, Beams, Stanley

...then i promise I'll shut up and pull the shotgun

I think Smith has more chance of making money than Stanley so if Smith is on your bench I would go

Chapman, Beams and Smith and keep the extra money.

My assumption is to afford Robbo you must trade Stanley but can get Chappy with Smith. Why not cash in Stanley but still take the cheaper option then you bank a little extra for future.

Thats what I think based on Stanleys next 4 opponents. Haw, Car, WCE, Syd

 

[entourage]

Re: Player X v Player Y

You assume 100% correct Spider, thanks for both of your input, Beams, Chappy, Smith it is

 

[Big Cox 88]

Re: Player X v Player Y

zaharakis vs christensen, leaning towards christensen

 

[ShueytoGaff]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Zaha, easily

 

[tomemy]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Swan, Birchall or JPKennedy, Scotland

Any thoughts?

 

[ShueytoGaff]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Option 1 IMO.

 

[Big Cox 88]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Swan, Birchall or JPKennedy, Scotland

Any thoughts?

Swan and Birchall without even blinking an eye

 

[tomemy]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Cheers fellas

 

[Average]

Re: Player X v Player Y

who should I get rid of out of Clay Smith (WB) and Devon Greene (GWS)? Need to bring in another mid to cover Ablett. Greene should score better but Smith has a lot more money to make (but not sure when he will be back in action). Hmmmmm
Any help please?

 

[vaf1979]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Money not an issue : Chappy, Stevie j or Dangerfield?

Thanks

 

[ShueytoGaff]

Re: Player X v Player Y

who should I get rid of out of Clay Smith (WB) and Devon Greene (GWS)? Need to bring in another mid to cover Ablett. Greene should score better but Smith has a lot more money to make (but not sure when he will be back in action). Hmmmmm
Any help please?

Devon Greene?

And there's no need to put "(WB)" or "(GWS)", we know what team they play for...

 

[Lemma]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Tom Hawkins v Allen Christensen?

 

[we57st]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Tom Hawkins v Allen Christensen?

Tough one but i'd go Christensen as he's a DP and higher possession getter than Hawkins potentially. Hawkins is looking really good, but may go games where he is well held.

For me - Clancee Pearce or Ryan O'Keefe? Ie, go with the rising star or proven gun?

 

[James]

Re: Player X v Player Y

I've always had at least 2 of Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Boyd to put the big C on, but alas this year Ablett was my only proven reliable Captain to choose from.

Out of this lot I just can't see an obvious Captain choice for this week. Leaning towards Deledio or Hayes for a play it safe 100-110 option or Chappy, Robinson or Buddy as unique Captain options who may score big this week against weaker opposition teams or direct opponent.

Deledio
v
Goddard
v
Thompson
v
Hayes
v
Barlow
v
Ziebell
v
Cox
v
Sidebottom
v
Robinson
v
Franklin
v
Chapman
v
Goodes
v
N Riewoldt


Any constructive advice on Captain choice would be appreciated.

 

[pillager]

Re: Player X v Player Y

I've always had at least 2 of Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Boyd to put the big C on, but alas this year Ablett was my only proven reliable Captain to choose from.

Out of this lot I just can't see an obvious Captain choice for this week. Leaning towards Deledio or Hayes for a play it safe 100-110 option or Chappy, Robinson or Buddy as unique Captain options who may score big this week against weaker opposition teams or direct opponent.

Deledio
v
Goddard
v
Thompson
v
Hayes
v
Barlow
v
Ziebell
v
Cox
v
Sidebottom
v
Robinson
v
Franklin
v
Chapman
v
Goodes
v
N Riewoldt


Any constructive advice on Captain choice would be appreciated.

What happened to JPK?

 

[James]

Re: Player X v Player Y

What happened to JPK?

Waite, Fyfe, Treloar, Couch, Kruezer not playing is what happened.

Had to upgrade Kruezer to Cox and Fyfe to Robinson otherwise would cop a doughnut in the forwards or ruck if I traded Fyfe>JPK in the mids.

Having said that, if Devon Smith doesn't make the final teams I will cop a doughnut in the forwards regardless of who I trade in.

Any advice for Captain choice?

 

[ShueytoGaff]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Perhaps in the Captain's thread...

 

[James]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Perhaps in the Captain's thread...

I thought the Captain's thread was for 'who' you ARE going to name Captain, not who 'should' I name Captain? This thread seemed more appropriate as it's player A v B v C etc etc

 

[Becc73]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Ryder v McIntosh v Cox? (have Giles as 2nd ruck)
Franklin v Sidebottom v Chapman?

Help please.

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Ryder v McIntosh v Cox? (have Giles as 2nd ruck)
Franklin v Sidebottom v Chapman?

Help please.

Hmac for mine, Ryder wont score as well playing second ruck and Cox is the same so Hmac for price, You would have to go Buddy as well.

 

[The Spornstar]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Should I trade out Kreuzer or Mumford (or neither)? My other rucks are Giles and Redden.

 

[Becc73]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Hmac for mine, Ryder wont score as well playing second ruck and Cox is the same so Hmac for price, You would have to go Buddy as well.

Thanks for the advice, Dwight!!

 

[Jessbek]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Devon Greene?

And there's no need to put "(WB)" or "(GWS)", we know what team they play for...

Why write this? So what, the guys a DT noob.. dont need patronising BS

 

[blue_boys]

Re: Player X v Player Y

Sidebottom or Chapman + 27K