2013 Player/s X versus Y

[froggy1976]

Thanks Toxic and OA

 

[Test Tickle]

no brainer out of those two - daisy by miles and miles

just thought Lewis might be the breast pick and a good POD thanks toxic

 

[freo grover]

Walker or Thomas? ....to replace Westhoff

 

[Unknown Identity]

I guess it comes down to Walker Vs Thomas + $100K

History suggest Thomas will average more at the end of the year, but Walkers been threatening to break out for a while, playing up the ground is definately improving his scores.. i guess take the in form player..

 

[Waspy79]

Who to ditch for Thomas - Neade (DP) or Macaffer

 

[ohh_v]

Neade v Mayes v Viney to start?

 

[DT_35]

Neade v Mayes v Viney to start?

Just wait until subs are named for the 2 earlier games tomorrow and then make a decision

 

[ohh_v]

Just wait until subs are named for the 2 earlier games tomorrow and then make a decision

But if all are named to start, and not sub, who would you pick?

 

[toxic]

Neade v Mayes v Viney to start?

I'd go Viney if that counts for anything

 

[Waspy79]

I'd ditch Macaffer he's a fair chance to be playing a tagging role again

Yeah I'm weighing that up but also want the extra $50K that Neade will bring to the table in a cull. I think Macaffer has a pretty secure role now but is not a MID/FWD. I'm also concerned that Neade will drop off as the season goes on and the Port fixture gets tougher.

AAAAAAARRRGGGHHHH!

 

[DT_35]

But if all are named to start, and not sub, who would you pick?

If they were all playing against the same team, I'd go Mayes comfortably. But Viney vs GC wouldn't be a bad option either.
I have the same problem only its Mayes vs Neade. Probably Mayes

 

[Obese Arachnid]

just thought Lewis might be the breast pick and a good POD thanks toxic

I think you have been looking at Toxic's avatar too much.

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Laird or Vlastuin, both they're JS is a bit suss but not sure which way to go

I'm going to have both locked in my team in 20 minutes.. If you have to choose one, Vlastuin

 

[gh172]

Need to downgrade to generate cash for next week. Heath to Laird or Dwyer to B Kennedy ?

 

[ohh_v]

Start Matt Jones or Viney?

Viney's been spudding it up quite a bit..

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Start Matt Jones or Viney?

Viney's been spudding it up quite a bit..

I sure hope you started Viney...

 

[GOAUS!]

I sure hope you started Viney...

Would have only cost him 19 points.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Would have only cost him 19 points.

That could mean a lot in league games, who knows? I lost to this guy in round 3 by 2 points

 

[GOAUS!]

That could mean a lot in league games, who knows? I lost to this guy in round 3 by 2 points

Well it's small change compared to say me picking Neade over MaCaffer on-field and Clarke instead of Laird. I know a few who had Neade instead of Kerridge.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Well it's small change compared to say me picking Neade over MaCaffer on-field and Clarke instead of Laird. I know a few who had Neade instead of Kerridge.

I had Neade instead of Mac, kinda hurting a little...

 

[Judd_Magic]

I had Neade instead of Dwyer or Macaffer.

Ouch!

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

I had Neade instead of Dwyer or Macaffer.

Ouch!

Same here and I traded out Dwyer before he blasted a 99.
Er...

 

[toxic]

Same here and I traded out Dwyer before he blasted a 99.
Er...

was still the right time to trade him out for me - someone with a high B/E needed to go, Bye bye Dwyer it was.
No regrets and thanked him for his services

 

[Zach Package]

Opinions needed, Bringing in a midfield premo this week, and nic nat next week or the week after, Do I go...

Swan @ 630k
Jelwood @ 570k
Watson @ 580k

 

[toxic]

Opinions needed, Bringing in a midfield premo this week, and nic nat next week or the week after, Do I go...

Swan @ 630k
Jelwood @ 570k
Watson @ 580k

All 3 will b good choices, jobe by a whisker from jelwood by a whisker from swan