2013 Player/s X versus Y

[LaffertyDaniel]

Hi guys,

Interested to see what your opinion is (apologies if previously said).
Murphy vs Kennedy, Watts vs Grimes, Rockliff vs Johnson vs Martin (pick 2).

 

[LaffertyDaniel]

Ablett and Fyfe or Kennedy and Watson?

Depending on your side will determine which is pair is better. Would pick Kennedy and Watson purely because I believe Fyfe is not of the same ilk and is injury prone. If in need of a captain Ablett is clearly the number one choice, go Ablett and Fyfe.

Personally, I am steering clear of Fyfe because I have suffered before with him.

 

[Super Hans]

Hi guys,

Interested to see what your opinion is (apologies if previously said).
Murphy vs Kennedy, Watts vs Grimes, Rockliff vs Johnson vs Martin (pick 2).

Murphy, Grimes, Rockiff.


Mitchell vs Swallow?

 

[blueiris]

looking at the draws of Hawthorn and North. North Melbourne start with the better draw so starting with Andrew Swallow would be better and upgrading to Mitchell later in the year if you wanted to

 

[Super Hans]

looking at the draws of Hawthorn and North. North Melbourne start with the better draw so starting with Andrew Swallow would be better and upgrading to Mitchell later in the year if you wanted to

That was my thinking originally too, but then I saw Swallow seems to do better against good teams compared to bad ones.

e.g 134 against West Coast and then 78 against GWS.

 

[Kangaman 94]

Heppell & Pendlebury vs Broughton & Swan

 

[Super Hans]

Heppell & Pendlebury vs Broughton & Swan

Pendles and Hep.

Redden vs Mitchell?

Jacobs vs McEvoy?

 

[Kangaman 94]

Redden vs Mitchell?

Jacobs vs McEvoy?

Mitchell constant 100s every week

Hard to split the Jacobs vs McEvoy, would take Jacobs just on three things,
1) He plays without a back up
2) He doesnt require many possessions to churn out a score
3) With Hickey I can see McEvoy spending more time in the forward line this season

 

[Caramello Koalas]

Murphy and Mundy vs. Judd and Shuey?

 

[Kangaman 94]

Murphy and Mundy vs. Judd and Shuey?

Murphy and Mundy by a country mile

 

[Caramello Koalas]

Cox and Ball vs. Grimes and Johnson?

 

[toxic]

Cox and Ball vs. Grimes and Johnson?

of those 2 options ís Cox as a fwd or ruck? and i presume Johnson is Stevie not Michael

 

[Caramello Koalas]

of those 2 options ís Cox as a fwd or ruck? and i presume Johnson is Stevie not Michael

Cox as a forward, and yes Stevie Johnson, what do you think?

 

[Ed D]

Cox as a forward, and yes Stevie Johnson, what do you think?

**** and Balls.

 

[Kangaman 94]

selwood vs kennedy

 

[toxic]

Cox as a forward, and yes Stevie Johnson, what do you think?

Agreed cox, but I don't rate ball at all... sorry

 

[toxic]

selwood vs kennedy

Selwood of the Joel variety

 

[crystalbreathX]

hrovat vs leigh osbourne for bench spot probably.

 

[Strahany]

hrovat vs leigh osbourne for bench spot probably.

Probably Hrovat - should get a few games.

 

[Strahany]

Can't decide between Varcoe + Josh.J.Kennedy vs Siposs + Rookie (likely Josh Simpson) + ~$50k

 

[fishtopher]

Can't decide between Varcoe + Josh.J.Kennedy vs Siposs + Rookie (likely Josh Simpson) + ~$50k

Two rookies + 250k

Selwood & Goldstein or Fyfe & Maric

 

[Strahany]

Two rookies + 250k

Selwood & Goldstein or Fyfe & Maric

Selwood is more consistent than Fyfe and nowhere near as injury prone, and although Maric seems to have a solid lead on Goldstein, we've seen how well Goldstein performs when he is the number 1 ruck.

tl;dr - Selwood + Goldstein.

 

[toxic]

Two rookies + 250k

Selwood & Goldstein or Fyfe & Maric

fyfe & Maric - simply better

 

[1989]

Which four out of Bartel, Rioli, Rockliff, Martin and Zorko (as forwards)?

 

[GOAUS!]

Which four out of Bartel, Rioli, Rockliff, Martin and Zorko (as forwards)?

Tough choice between Martin and Zorko (to leave out) I reckon. Would probably leave out Martin, just.