2013 Player/s X versus Y

[freoman87]

moloney and goodes by far


bartel v m.wright v walker

 

[freoman87]

moloney and goodes by far


bartel v m.wright v walker

or do i make one of the 3 a rookie and upgrade daw or currie to a prem ruck

 

[juniorboy9]

Wines or Whitfield?
Rowe or Spangher or kerridge or lee?

 

[Jozzy]

Wines or Whitfield?
Rowe or Spangher or kerridge or lee?

Both should play most games but Wines is just much bigger and more ready made so i'd go with Wines.

Rowe, had the best NAB cup out of the four and should start round one.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Here's my dilemma fellas. A quick reason why you would pick who would be great.


Goldstien vs Bellchambers vs Leuenburger

Rockcliff vs Zorko

And

J.Selwood vs J.Kennedy (Swans)


Cheers guys in advance.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Go with the ones you think you'll have a better chance at trading out at some point.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Go with the ones you think you'll have a better chance at trading out at some point.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Relax mate.

Ok. Bellchambers, Bombers number 1 and has had a decent pre-season. Leuenberger has a bit of an injury cloud over him and Goldstein hasn't shown anything this pre-season. Although, they both could quite easily end up showing everyone up by playing Round 1 and doing very well.

Rockliff, i think he has more in him than Zorko. Not by much though.

Kennedy, a machine at stoppages and has a brilliant DT/SC ratio.

 

[Strahany]

Just on Goldstein, I'm pretty sure he scored 70 something SC points from about 50% game time against Hawthorn on the weekend.

I hate to be the person that bumps their own request, but this is a pretty risky move and I'd like to know what people think of it:

Buddy + Mid Rookie (already have O'Meara, Crouch, Viney and Wines) or N.Riewoldt + Kane Lucas

Reason I'm considering option 2 is because St Kilda have a good early draw, in terms of Riewoldt's scoring history vs these teams, whilst Buddy has a bit of a tough one. The aim is for Buddy to drop in price, Riewoldt to rise, and make a straight swap in round 4/5/6.

 

[toxic]

Just on Goldstein, I'm pretty sure he scored 70 something SC points from about 50% game time against Hawthorn on the weekend.

I hate to be the person that bumps their own request, but this is a pretty risky move and I'd like to know what people think of it:

Lucas - has never delivered (granted he might average 80 odd) but so will a decent rookie at 100K cheaper, Buddy is buddy - on a bad day he scores 90 - on a great day he scores 130+ N Roo has dodgy knees and has been a great SC option in the PAST, however I reckon his best days are well behind him

 

[Jair]

Varcoe 268.900 or Byrnes 230.100 in the forward line?

 

[toxic]

Varcoe 268.900 or Byrnes 230.100 in the forward line?

Varcoe much better JS

 

[Jiska]

Goldstien vs Bellchambers vs Leuenburger
Rockcliff vs Zorko
J.Selwood vs J.Kennedy (Swans)

Leuenburger if fit, cash cow. Goldstein if not, just don't rate Bellchambers.
I've spent all weekend tossing this one up and settled with Zorko, just based on gut feeling. Looks to be constantly in the right position, fitter than last year and has a fire in the belly. Flip of the coin decision, wouldn't be surprised if Rockliff burnt me.
Selwood, just because he has more history behind him and based on the domination aspect that the Cats have at Skilled; sounds ridiculous I know, but I feel the psychology factor plays a part. Another flip of the coin, could go either way.

 

[Goats]

Lewis Vs Dusty Vs Walker?

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Who would you take out of Watson, JPk, Swan or Danger?

Good to see lots more variety this year. Contrary to the other responses on this, JPK is the only one of those 4 in my team.

 

[Jozzy]

Lewis Vs Dusty Vs Walker?

I would narrow it down to just Lewis and Martin, Dustin burnt a lot of people last season but he's had a pretty solid pre-season and Hardwick told all us fantasy footy coaches to put him in, add a touch of bias and i would have to say Martin.

 

[dogsontherise]

tossing up between heppell and hartlett?

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

tossing up between heppell and hartlett?

Toss a coin. hepps maybe because he isn't made of porcelain

 

[Jiska]

Goddard or Gibbs??

 

[Goats]

Goddard or Gibbs??

I'd find it hard not to have both. But if I had to choose I'd pick Gibbs, I think he will be the higher scorer and likely to earn more than Goddard - I think Goddard would be a better upgrade target.

Delidio at M5 Vs. Franklin at F1?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Goddard or Gibbs??

goddard

 

[Jordie_tackles]

I'd find it hard not to have both. But if I had to choose I'd pick Gibbs, I think he will be the higher scorer and likely to earn more than Goddard - I think Goddard would be a better upgrade target.

Delidio at M5 Vs. Franklin at F1?

Delidio will play more, Franklin has the cieling and will outscore other forwards when he plays, really both will be in their best positions at years end....so you want both eventually

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Wines and Bellchambers

Rookie and Goldstein, with Currie as back up if dropped

or 1 Million of 2 rucks

 

[Jozzy]

Goddard or Gibbs??

Goddard, all though i recommend you try putting both in your team.

 

[Jiska]

Goddard, all though i recommend you try putting both in your team.

I have Gibbs, Duffield, Pearce and Heppell. Four premiums is enough, can't justify having five of them. Duffield, Pearce and Heppell are all locks for me as I think they'll all have breakout seasons, or substantially increase. If I take Gibbs, i'll look at upgrading someone else to Goddard down the track, or vice versa. I think Goddard will be tagged more heavily than at St Kilda and Gibbs has more improvement, so I'm leaning towards Gibbs rather than Goddard.