2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[MightyDons4]

Two of Shaw, Hibberd and Gibson

Lewis vs Griffen

 

[Young Gun #6]

Two of Shaw, Hibberd and Gibson

Lewis vs Griffen

Shaw, hibberd and griffen.

 

[HTPunter]

Got 347,500 to spend on my D4. Backline is: Hodge, Johnson, Taylor, *******, B.Goodes, Saad (McIntosh, Hamling).

I can source 30k elsewhere, but would rather not. Bewick (344), Ibbotson (342), Geary (332), Pearce (278), Macmillan (270), Whitecross (198) have Brown (146) all been considered.

If I get the 30k, I have 380,400 to spend and I take a punt on one of Sutcliffe (377), Savage (371), Mayes (369), KK (367) or Vlastuin (363). Some of those options are better but it's still lucky dip. Plus I like my overall side less.

Thoughts?

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Got 347,500 to spend on my D4. Backline is: Hodge, Johnson, Taylor, *******, B.Goodes, Saad (McIntosh, Hamling).

I can source 30k elsewhere, but would rather not. Bewick (344), Ibbotson (342), Geary (332), Pearce (278), Macmillan (270), Whitecross (198) have Brown (146) all been considered.

If I get the 30k, I have 380,400 to spend and I take a punt on one of Sutcliffe (377), Savage (371), Mayes (369), KK (367) or Vlastuin (363). Some of those options are better but it's still lucky dip. Plus I like my overall side less.

Thoughts?

I'd take KK of the bunch, Geary and Ibbo aren't bad option.

 

[scaryness]

Judd vs sam mitchell? And do you think these represent a good stepping stone for a super premium? If not, who would you suggest?

Mitchell.

 

[MicCheck12]

Gibson or Taylor?

 

[Samples]

Gibson or Taylor?

Taylor imo.

Gibson's scores will probably drop when Birchall comes back into the side.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Watson v Dangerman

 

[MicCheck12]

If you were going to choose a ruckman under 440k who would it be?

Currently have Giles

 

[kananooks]

Watson v Dangerman

danger is nicely underpriced.. I'd go him.

Bartel vs Goddard?

 

[GOAUS!]

danger is nicely underpriced.. I'd go him.

Bartel vs Goddard?

Post verdict Goddard is tempting. Will probably switch actually.

 

[kananooks]

Post verdict Goddard is tempting. Will probably switch actually.

Goddard was a lock in everyone's team from day one. then the Tuesday deadline day came along and everyone jumped ship

 

[Kadog]

Jacobs Mumford Dangerfield Parker

Pick 1 ruckman 1 mid combo

 

[kananooks]

Jacobs Mumford Dangerfield Parker

Pick 1 ruckman 1 mid combo

mummy danger

 

[GOAUS!]

Goddard was a lock in everyone's team from day one. then the Tuesday deadline day came along and everyone jumped ship

Not for mine. Would cop a major tag if it went the wrong way.

 

[juddola]

Wines Vs Prestia

 

[juddola]

Gibson or Taylor?

I'm in the same boat....unsure.

 

[cyril4brownlow]

Wines Vs Prestia

Prestia. Seems to be the more unique pick and imo will score better.

Mitchell and Geary or 600k midfielder and B.Goodes

 

[cyril4brownlow]

Gibson or Taylor?

]
Hardest question on here imo. If i wasn't a hawks supporter i would probably go taylor but i am so gibson it is.

 

[GOAUS!]

Prestia. Seems to be the more unique pick and imo will score better.

Mitchell and Geary or 600k midfielder and B.Goodes

Super-Premo and Goodes.

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty. Pick 2.

 

[Lums23]

Buddy VS Goddard, This one is killing me??? History suggests Buddy will get suspended or do something stupid at some point. His chronic knee issue also concerns.

Goddard missed games last year too. He's getting on, I'd take buddy comfortably

 

[12Chill]

Taylor imo.

Gibson's scores will probably drop when Birchall comes back into the side.

What do you see Gibbo averaging?

 

[juddola]

Super-Premo and Goodes.

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty. Pick 2.

I would go Dusty.

 

[Samples]

What do you see Gibbo averaging?

80-85

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Jacobs Mumford Dangerfield Parker

Pick 1 ruckman 1 mid combo

Jacobs Parker

Wines Vs Prestia

Prestia for mine.

Super-Premo and Goodes.

Goddard vs Buddy vs Dusty. Pick 2.

Buddy and Martin