2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[JT_the_Man]

Cripps. I don't rate Juice particularly highly and don't see that changing.

Birchall, Bellchambers (forward line) and $100k left over.
Ibbotson, Roughead and little left over.

Which would be the better combo?

Ibbotson and Roughead.
Bennell or Griffen and Deledio or Goddard?

 

[Scott_Wolf]

Ibbotson and Roughead.
Bennell or Griffen and Deledio or Goddard?

Griffen and Deledio.


Hibberd & Geary
or
Lumumba & Higgins

 

[brentman]

Thoughts on a Boak for Swan trade? Supercoach Draft

 

[SnappyHappy]

Griffen and Deledio.


Hibberd & Geary
or
Lumumba & Higgins

Option 2.
Both very risky picks but I don't like Geary at all as an option

 

[SnappyHappy]

Wines v Watson

 

[JT_the_Man]

Wines v Watson

Watson

 

[karaoke]

Thoughts on a Boak for Swan trade? Supercoach Draft

No, Swan will do better this year than last, but Boak will pip him overall.

 

[richolovesgoal]

Hibberd, mid rookie, Swan
vs
Newnes, Griffin, fwd rookie

 

[jon0011]

griffen and bont or neale and swan?

 

[cardje]

Gaz, Salem Vs
S Mitchell, D Swan

 

[Ashton Agar]

griffen and bont or neale and swan?

Griffen and Bont.

Bont or Higgins up FWD?

 

[JT_the_Man]

griffen and bont or neale and swan?

Griffen and Bont

 

[cardje]

Griffen and Bont.

Bont or Higgins up FWD?

Higgins

 

[JT_the_Man]

Hibberd, mid rookie, Swan
vs
Newnes, Griffin, fwd rookie

Who are u thinking about with the rookies? I have no idea with this, I'd probs go with Newnes/Griffen.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Gaz, Salem Vs
S Mitchell, D Swan

I so badly want to say Mitchell and Swan, but I don't think you can't have Gaz so Gaz and Salem...

 

[JT_the_Man]

Griffen and Bont.

Bont or Higgins up FWD?

Bont

 

[jon0011]

Griffen and Bont.

Bont or Higgins up FWD?

higgins is always supercoach poison, ive been sucked in more than once, always teases never delivers

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Currently: Griffin + NVB + 30k (bank)

Proposed: Beams + viable downgrade rookie (currently have Anderson, CEY, Heney and Clem Smith.... so who?)

 

[JPod_31]

Wines v Watson

Jump on board the Wines bus!

Nic Nat v Belchambers (Extra 190k to upgrade someone)

Im stuck

 

[skilfulgun]

higgins is always supercoach poison, ive been sucked in more than once, always teases never delivers

Think this year in a better side he could potentially bump his average up to around 90, which could be OK for a def premium. A risk though given a new club, injury history etc.

Newnes vs. Adcock vs. Higgins vs. KK - Are the first three much more likely to average more than KK? Personally I rate them all as potentially averaging around the same, 80-90. Thoughts? At this stage I'm happy to take the risk with KK and use the cash elsewhere.

 

[Kardinial]

Higgins or Lumumba?

 

[Kardinial]

Nic Nat v Belchambers (Extra 190k to upgrade someone)

Nic Nat

 

[Mighty P]

I'm tossing up whether I should buy Jaksch (Carlton) and get rid of Hugh Goddard/Clancee Pearce. I want Pearce for his dual position, but know nothing about Goddard.

 

[jon0011]

Think this year in a better side he could potentially bump his average up to around 90, which could be OK for a def premium. A risk though given a new club, injury history etc.

Newnes vs. Adcock vs. Higgins vs. KK - Are the first three much more likely to average more than KK? Personally I rate them all as potentially averaging around the same, 80-90. Thoughts? At this stage I'm happy to take the risk with KK and use the cash elsewhere.

I think that adcock is one who seems to get injured often, newes is the pick for me with more midfield time. only thing to consider with kk is how he will handle another full AFL season and might get the dreaded 2nd year blues. cash elsewhere would be handy

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Wines v Watson

Tough one - Watson for me.

S.Mitchell and Hibberd (with 60K spare cash)
or
D.Beams and Lumumba