Draft Review 2015 - Redo the 2015 AFL Draft

[scott_the_man]

Who would your top 10 be if the draft was redone today?

1. Oliver
2. Weitering
3. Hipwood
4. Burton
5. Parish
6. Mills
7. Rioli
8. Milera
9. Hopper
10. Curnow

 

[Super Hans]

I'd take Burton over Rioli every day of the week.

 

[Great8]

I'd take Burton over Rioli every day of the week.

Same

 

[Mr_Plow]

Charlie > Schache.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Milera bit high, Gresham and Dunkley have done more than him.

 

[scott_the_man]

Milera bit high, Gresham and Dunkley have done more than him.

Fair point. Although he hasn't shown as much as those two yet I do think Milera will develop into a better player than the both of them. Just my opinion of course

 

[scott_the_man]

I'd take Burton over Rioli every day of the week.

I've got Rioli this high based on potential. Could potentially become one of the best players in the comp one day

 

[Burtman]

Hipwood is gonna be a gun but if ur going by what they've produced so far he's gotta drop abit

 

[scott_the_man]

Hipwood is gonna be a gun but if ur going by what they've produced so far he's gotta drop abit

That's interesting that you think he's dropped in value. From my view he has done a lot more than what was expected of him and has shown glimpses of brilliance regularly. It may just be my bias

 

[Burtman]

Nah I'm completely with u on that. He's the closest thing I've seen to a young buddy. But the other guys have been a lot more consistent than hipwood. Just doesn't have the strength or workrate yet to stay in the game for 4 quarters

 

[aussierulesrules]

Hipwood certainly has the best 4 disposal games of this draft crop!

 

[scott_the_man]

Would be intetested to see how other people would redo the top 10. Anyone want to have a crack?

 

[Hawka#10]

My top 10 would be
1. Weitering
2. Oliver
3. Burton
4. Mills
5. Hipwood
6. Parish
7. Rioli
8. Hopper
9. Curnow
10. Schache

 

[citizen-erased]

1-Oliver
2-mills
3-parish
4-burton
5-McDonald-tipungwuti
6-weitering
7-hipwood
8-hopper
9-Hartley
10-Silvagni

 

[adammania9]

1. Clayton Oliver
2. Jaconb Weitering
3. Ryan Burton
4. Darcy Parish
5. Jade Gresham
6. Callum Mills
7. Josh Dunkley
8. Eric Hipwood
9. Callum Ah Chee
10. Marcus Adams

So far. I expect Kennedy, Hopper, Milera, Clarke, Fiorini, Mathieson and Curnow to really challenge this.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Curnow would be selected top 10. The only reason he wasn't in 2015 was because of his drink driving incident.

Too much raw potential not too, and already has some decent games to his name.

 

[Foucault1989]

As a Carlton supporter I'm more than happy with Weitering over Oliver...short, medium and long term!

 

[Mr_Plow]

Curnow would be selected top 10. The only reason he wasn't in 2015 was because of his drink driving incident.

Too much raw potential not too, and already has some decent games to his name.

Charlie has been the pick of the key forwards so far.

Hipwood's numbers don't even come close.

 

[Rich01]

1. Oliver
2. Hipwood and Weitering (both will be very good long term and hard to split)
4. Burton
5. Mills
6. Parish
7. Hopper
8. Schache
9. Hopper
10. Kennedy

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Charlie has been the pick of the key forwards so far.

Hipwood's numbers don't even come close.

In a draft you must factor in potential too. If it was redone Hipwood goes high, he looks the goods.

It looks a great draft for KPP so far with Weitering, Hipwood, Schache, Curnow, Burton and Himmelberg all showing some good signs at AFL level.

Weidaman, Francis and the Mckay brothers are also obviously promising.

Adams as a mature ager must also be factored into discussion.

 

[Holy Rioli]

1. Weitering
2. Burton
3. Oliver (I know everyone here faps over him, and he has been excellent as a 2nd year player, but he's a less effective version of Tom Mitchell - check their metres gained and handballing % statistics to see what I mean and I think his ceiling will be about that of Tom Mitchell)
4. Hipwood
5. Parish
6. Hopper
7. Curnow
8. Kennedy
9. Schache
10. Mills

 

[bungalow_bill]

Who would your top 10 be if the draft was redone today?

1. Oliver
2. Weitering
3. Hipwood
4. Mills
5. Parish
6. Rioli
7. Burton
8. Milera
9. Schache
10. Hopper

Number nine with a bullet...

 

[Prochard123]

1-Oliver
2-mills
3-parish
4-burton
5-McDonald-tipungwuti
6-weitering
7-hipwood
8-hopper
9-Hartley
10-Silvagni

Parish over Weitering, yeah um no.

 

[Prochard123]

1. Weitering
2. Burton
3. Oliver (I know everyone here faps over him, and he has been excellent as a 2nd year player, but he's a less effective version of Tom Mitchell - check their metres gained and handballing % statistics to see what I mean and I think his ceiling will be about that of Tom Mitchell)
4. Hipwood
5. Parish
6. Hopper
7. Curnow
8. Kennedy
9. Schache
10. Mills

Re Oliver, you could say the same about Josh P Kennedy, Cunnington, Matt Crouch and just about every other pure inside mid. He crushed us in clearances a week ago. Oliver=3 burtons

 

[Holy Rioli]

Re Oliver, you could say the same about Josh P Kennedy, Cunnington, Matt Crouch and just about every other pure inside mid. He crushed us in clearances a week ago. Oliver=3 burtons

Yeah but you think De Goey is a far trade for Gunston as well. Oliver has been better so far, but I believe Burton has a better upside.