Position 2015 SuperCoach midfielders

[toxic]

What is everyones thoughts on jack stevens? 455k and was injured last season I think he has the potential to be a 10 mid especially if he gets the ablett rule of GC's first season: where teams won't tag him because they expect to beat st kilda anyway

CANNOT be a top 10 mid.

CANNOT.

however has great cash earning potential from his low base

 

[anfa18]

CANNOT be a top 10 mid.

CANNOT.

however has great cash earning potential from his low base

How much do you think he can make? Priced at 455k, he would need to average 105-110 to make 100k before the byes... If he can make that 100k by averaging 105-110, you might as well keep him as a bargain M8 for the season or at least upgrade him last.

 

[toxic]

How much do you think he can make? Priced at 455k, he would need to average 105-110 to make 100k before the byes... If he can make that 100k by averaging 105-110, you might as well keep him as a bargain M8 for the season or at least upgrade him last.

If he made it to 560k it'd be about what i expect

 

[HTPunter]

Big IF though.

Personally not keen on the 6 premiums idea (have had 4 + Lumumba at one stage though), but it's as big an 'if' as picking a random mid-pricer (Kolodjashnij, Ibbotson, Savage, Williams, Haynes, Bewick, Sutcliffe) and hoping they play 20+ games and average 85 minimum.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Back to the Pendles v Fyfe dilemma. Leaning towards Fyfe due to his potential, Pendles I expect to maintain 125.

Thoughts?

 

[KardiniaPark]

Back to the Pendles v Fyfe dilemma. Leaning towards Fyfe due to his potential, Pendles I expect to maintain 125.

Thoughts?

Need both.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Need both.

I'm also keen on JPK & Beams. One of the 4 has to go.

 

[toxic]

I'm also keen on JPK & Beams. One of the 4 has to go.

Beams gone.
easy choice

 

[KardiniaPark]

I'm also keen on JPK & Beams. One of the 4 has to go.

One of those two.

 

[Souup]

Is eski in your top 6 defenders?

I'd assume he'll be there abouts, but i can't see him averaging over 100 in a worse team with a lot more attention paid to him.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Beams gone.
easy choice

Beams will be better. The 76 GUN mids Sydney have will not help JPK. Beams and Rockliff will be playing kick to kick half the game

 

[SnappyHappy]

Beams gone.
easy choice

Leaves me with a midfield full of R12 byes is the only issue

 

[toxic]

I'd assume he'll be there abouts, but i can't see him averaging over 100 in a worse team with a lot more attention paid to him.

Cool.
i can't see him not being top 4 def.
but i agree he's overpriced atm

 

[Souup]

It is NAB Challenge, but Beams is an animal. Does whatever the hell he wants

 

[Da Breust]

Beams gone.
easy choice

What makes this choice so easy?

 

[Kadog]

Beams>JPK close call though

 

[Deliverance]

Believe me... I don't either. I'll explain the method to my madness - I'm more confident taking 6 premiums in than I am someone like Pittard, KK, Geary, Savage, Mayes, Shepherd or any of the other mid-pricers. One or more of those guys could end up keepers, but I don't want to enter that lottery. If they don't up their average by atleast 10ish points then they're not scoring enough to keep. And I don't want to play a rookie in defense because tbh, it seems like there are none except for Nathan Brown who seem likely to play more than 10 games over the season. I want to reduce the amount of rookies I need to select in the backline. It was bad enough with defensive rookies last year, and we had some to select from the start. And I don't want to have to gamble with a 200K-250K defender, when I can choose a 200K-250K midfielder who will score much better and has job security.

My defense = Simpson, Smith, Shaw, Hibberd Birchall, Newnes.

I'm quite confident all of them will average 90+. I can't see Simpson increasing his value so I think he may be my worst pick there, but I'd rather him average 5 points less and lose out on some value for money and still finish top 6 defenders (he's quite durable too which compensates for a drop in average IMO) than a mid-pricer who could completely bomb.

If Hibberd is banned, I'll have a good look at Hurn, Johnson, Kelly, Taylor and honestly, just anyone else that's 440K+ and pick who I think will finish top 6 defenders and play as close to 22 games as possible.

Have you gone weak in the mids or fwds to get the 6 premo backline? Or both?

 

[toxic]

What makes this choice so easy?

Beams is a judas prick.

To be serious i think jpk is a contested football beast we still haven't seen the best of and will end up 125+ av

 

[Deliverance]

Beams is a judas prick.

To be serious i think jpk is a contested football beast we still haven't seen the best of and will end up 125+ av

Beams is a jet, if he stays fit I could see him scoring about the same as JPK. I have both FWIW.
Plus Fyfe, I downgraded Ablett to Fyde cos everyone told me to.

 

[Souup]

Have you gone weak in the mids or fwds to get the 6 premo backline? Or both?

Forward line mostly. Midfield still has 4 premiums, 2 premium rucks. Forward line is 1 premium, 1 mid-pricer (Swan) and the rest are rookies.

 

[Krujan]

Beams is a judas prick.

To be serious i think jpk is a contested football beast we still haven't seen the best of and will end up 125+ av

Beams has averaged 123 before & only just turned 25 years old. He's in his prime right now. Could easily go 125+ this year.

 

[Jars458]

Fyfe too injury prone for mine. Rocky, Pendles, Selwood and Sidey for me ATM.

 

[MightyRoar]

Back to the Pendles v Fyfe dilemma. Leaning towards Fyfe due to his potential, Pendles I expect to maintain 125.

Thoughts?

Like KP said you need both....what's the makeup of the remainder of your midfield!!

 

[MightyRoar]

What is everyones thoughts on jack stevens? 455k and was injured last season I think he has the potential to be a 10 mid especially if he gets the ablett rule of GC's first season: where teams won't tag him because they expect to beat st kilda anyway

I was initially tossing up between him and Joey but for a little more you could go with someone like Mitchell, Swallow or even Crouch who in better sides should score more and won't have to worry bout a tag!!

 

[SnappyHappy]

Like KP said you need both....what's the makeup of the remainder of your midfield!!

Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Beams, JPK, Griffen, rookies - one of the premos has to go though