List Mgmt. 2016 NAB AFL Trade Period

[HBF]

Not sure why we aren't chasing a Marley Williams. Reckon he would be a good replacement for Touhy and get the small forward role.

Pass.
No dickheads thanks.

 

[HARKER]

Wrong. We won't be screwed. We will give up the Geelong 1st, a 4th and get Marchbank, Pickett and a second round pick back

That's much better.

Anything around the 30 mark is still value here.

 

[ferrisb]

Would be nice. I'm a bit worried about his awareness after Usblaine Bolthorst chased him down from 100 meters away at the Scg late in the season

Found my username if I ever start up a new account!

 

[Navara79]

Im nervous about what today brings. I have the same feeling as i would have when im sitting at the MCG just before the first bounce in Rd1.
I need to get a life!

 

[onesilop]

Im sorry but how is Geelong trading another first round draft pick?

Dont clubs have to have 2 first round selections in a 4 year period?

2015 - Dangerfield trade
2016 - Henderson trade
2017 - Touhy trade

Surely the only way it works is if they start counting the 4 year rolling period from 2016 I.e the Dangerfield pick was a free hit!

In the past it was possible for a club to trade out their first rounder every year, the new rules make that next to impossible.

 

[kingkingston]

So... by that example, Pickett, a former pick 4 in 2014, should also be costing us a mid to late first rounder. And Ahern should have cost North a late first rounder because he was a pick 7 in 2014...

If an injury plagued Ahern can go for pick 69 and GWS are chasing picks 45 and 55 and are sending pick 58 back our way (apparently) for Pickett, then Marchbank, in spite of his required tag, should only cost a mid second round... considering that he is just as injury plagued as Ahern and Pickett.

you can't just rate it on other players, that is what i find it amusing how some fans do that. Marchbank will be better than those players and will be apart of our awesome defence set up for years to come. It is why GWS rate him highly and want a fair deal.

 

[Canyouhearthedrums]

Exactly. People want to imagine some conspiracy because they want more for him....or that we are idiots. Occkams razor says they want more for him because he is better.

I trust sos not to pay overs, we're not desperate for tall defenders.

 

[GordonBlue]

Go back to Woolwhich COYS

21 : 164 : 04 : 51 : 22
Yrs Days Hrs Mins Secs

 

[LanceRomance]

Exactly. People want to imagine some conspiracy because they want more for him....or that we are idiots. Occkams razor says they want more for him because he is better.

I trust sos not to pay overs, we're not desperate for tall defenders.

Who is occkhamss?

 

[Jatz]

Not sure where else to put this but Bartel to Carlton on the cards.

 

[HARKER]

The one thing I'm particularly glad about for now, is that we didn't let go of our #5.

Marchbank & Pickett are coming and to have added Stewart & McKenna/Barrett/Corr etc. in order to let go of the #5, would have come back to bite hard.

 

[Canyouhearthedrums]

Who is occkhamss?

Occam's razor is a principle of problem solving or deduction that basically says that the simplest or most obvious explanation is invariably the correct one

 

[HARKER]

Occam's razor is a principle of problem solving or deduction that basically says that the simplest or most obvious explanation is invariably the correct one

I think Lance was just having a shot at your spelling.

I don't particularly agree with Occam's principle in the way it is interpreted in the modern day, any more. Man is so tricky.

 

[Dravid's in]

Wrong. We won't be screwed. We will give up the Geelong 1st, a 4th and get Marchbank, Pickett and a second round pick back

So basically the picks have all cancelled themselves out (give or take some spots) ie trading to GWS a 1st and 4th that were never ours and trading a second rounder out and back in, meaning we've straight swapped Tuohy for Marchbank, Pickett and Smedts as well as blocking Adelaide's bargaining power.

Nice work.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Deadline day predicition...

Adelaide trade Lyons to GCS for 26
Carlton trade Gibbs for 13 + 26
Carlton trade Geelong 2017 1st to GWS for Pickett + Marchbank

End of trade period
Carlton lose Gibbs, Touhy, + 2017 2nd round pick
Carlton Gain 13, 26, Pickett + Marchbank.

It also would not surprise me if we traded something to get 1 of GCS top 10 picks..

 

[LanceRomance]

Did Xavier richards just nominate us?

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Not sure where else to put this but Bartel to Carlton on the cards.

Goes against what somebody else posted somewhere earlier.
Apparently Bartel himself said that he isn't really interested in the coaching side, but more list management side of things.

 

[Kramer1]

Wrong. We won't be screwed. We will give up the Geelong 1st, a 4th and get Marchbank, Pickett and a second round pick back

I love it when you talk specific to me EP.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

longest.. day.. ever....

 

[Canyouhearthedrums]

I think Lance was just having a shot at your spelling.

I don't particularly agree with Occam's principle in the way it is interpreted in the modern day, any more. Man is so tricky.

The guy it's named after spelt it with a k. True story

 

[Salt Lake Cities]

Wrong. We won't be screwed. We will give up the Geelong 1st, a 4th and get Marchbank, Pickett and a second round pick back

Now that would be winning!!

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

'We're a long way off'
Nerves of steel from SOS.

 

[Jimmae]

SOS just on trade radio, not direct quotes but this is what he conveyed:

SOS: Been in discussion with Crows, not satisfied so far.

Reporter: Would proceeds from Lyons trade do it?

SOS: Unsure, but long way off at present.

Reporter: How much more than #13 is required?

SOS: A lot more.

 

[gotheJUDD]

 

[HARKER]

'We're a long way off'
Nerves of steel from SOS.

No problem hanging onto Gibbs if he's happy to stay.
That's all that matters and that he can live away from his partner and kids. Going to be tough but it's his call.

#13 and a swap of next years first for our second would do it, but seems that won't come about now.