2016: Player X vs Y vs Z

[VSTone]

Mills + Simpkin or Wells + Dunkley .... 1 on ground 1 on bench?

 

[Fyfetheknife]

Gresham & Dunkley
vs
Hewett & Oliver

Ideally would like Oliver and one of the first two as both of them have better JS than Hewett, but that's impossible without downgrading one of my premo mids. So....what do I do?

 

[Wrenny]

Brad vs Matt Crouch?

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Brad vs Matt Crouch?

Matt - He's a ball magnet

 

[VSTone]

Brad vs Matt Crouch?

both

 

[Dan12]

Eric Mackenzie + premium defender (most likely Bartel) or Sheridan and Salem (or maybe Lonergan)?

 

[bootsmalicious]

Brad vs Matt Crouch?

brad for mine

 

[bootsmalicious]

Gawn and sidebottom or jacobs and adams

 

[snozulu]

simpkin or kennedy as m8

 

[box1]

Brad Crouch or Lachie Hunter? Feels like you can't go wrong with either but IDK

 

[guero]

simpkin or kennedy as m8

Simpkin has better JS and scoring potential IMO. In last NAB game he picked up possies all over the ground - mid role, fitness improving.

 

[guero]

Brad vs Matt Crouch?

Matt in AF. Brad could be managed?

 

[guero]

Gresham & Dunkley
vs
Hewett & Oliver

Ideally would like Oliver and one of the first two as both of them have better JS than Hewett, but that's impossible without downgrading one of my premo mids. So....what do I do?

Pass on Oliver, too expensive.

Gresh and Hewett.

 

[guero]

Mills + Simpkin or Wells + Dunkley .... 1 on ground 1 on bench?

Wells and Dunkley

 

[guero]

Gresham & Dunkley
vs
Hewett & Oliver

Ideally would like Oliver and one of the first two as both of them have better JS than Hewett, but that's impossible without downgrading one of my premo mids. So....what do I do?

So you go with Gresham (ball magnet) and Hewett (2nd to 3rd year player with good NEAFL numbers and ok JS)

 

[guero]

So you go with Gresham (ball magnet) and Hewett (2nd to 3rd year player with good NEAFL numbers and ok JS)

Sorry...drunk. Luckily with it enough to give you 2 same replies to your question!

 

[Corrupt_]

Harwood vs Ramsay

Harwoods JS is pretty bad, he's not the best player

 

[Fyfetheknife]

Sorry...drunk. Luckily with it enough to give you 2 same replies to your question!

Hahaha no worries! It's just like getting a second opinion

 

[Fyfetheknife]

Gawn and sidebottom or jacobs and adams

Gawn and Sidey

 

[BigVic]

Duryea + Robbo
or

Laird + Greene

 

[VSTone]

Duryea + Robbo
or

Laird + Greene

Laird & Greene on pre-season form... Robbo is terribly tempting

 

[bootsmalicious]

Harwood vs Ramsay

Harwoods JS is pretty bad, he's not the best player

harwood for mine, had a pretty good pre season

 

[bootsmalicious]

Gawn and Sidey

yeah I was thinking this option

 

[kaiserchief13]

3 of Mills, Hewett, Davis and Gresham.

Currently have Mills, Hewett and Davis. Thoughts?

 

[Fyfetheknife]

3 of Mills, Hewett, Davis and Gresham.

Currently have Mills, Hewett and Davis. Thoughts?

Hewett for Gresham imo