Mick Hunt
Debutant
- Jul 8, 2016
- 58
- 96
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
No chance in the ****ing world, Grimes is a free agent so you can get him for free, and we do not need a Green...
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2016 Trade Hypotheticals (Opposition supporters post here)
- Thread starter Squizz89
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No chance in the ****ing world, Grimes is a free agent so you can get him for free, and we do not need a Green...
dlanod
Moderator
- Sep 14, 2006
- 53,849
- 85,771
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- GWS; CCMariners; NQCowboys; Ravens
- Moderator
- #77
It's truly disgusting how different people have different opinions on players and dare to express them! I hereby declare it to cease now, and will immediately ban anyone who disagrees with any of my opinions!
Dont worry he was already hounded down for that haha. Grimes could come for free. Greens value has dropped this season. Was looking ok until this year. Melbourne dont need a green. Not sure who he will go to.
Len S
Club Legend
- Jun 29, 2015
- 1,592
- 1,682
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Difference between denigration and genuine ,commentary,especially where young players,and debut players are concerned ...immoderate .
POBT
Brownlow Medallist
Of all the people to complain about player criticism.....
theteamtobeat
Premiership Player
2016 Off-Season
Major List problems:
*Lack of 1st round talent
*Lack off players that run both ways or apply any defensive pressure
*Quality key talls and running half backs
*Quality young ruckmen
*Mature AFL ready body that can win contested ball
Trade 1
Adeliade: Josh Green
Brisbane: Cam Ellis Yolmen
Trade 2
Geelong: Lewis Taylor, 2017 4th Round Pick
Brisbane: Pick 33, 38
Trade 3 - Three-way trade
St Kilda: Caleb Marchbank, Jack Steele
Brisbane: Pick 8-10 (St Kilda), Pick 7, 15, 17 , 53 (GWS)
GWS: Pick 2, 20, 28, 2017 3rd Round Pick (Brisbane), 33, 38 (Geelong - Lewis Taylor)
IN:
1. Pick 7: Ben Ainsworth or Andrew McGrath or Jack Scrimshaw
2. Pick 10: Daniel Venables
3. Pick 15: Josh Rotham
4. Pick 17: Tim English
5. Pick 47 + 53: Jacob Allison
6. Pick 56: Declan Watson
7. Cam Ellis Yolmen
OUT:
1. Daniel Merrett
2. Trent West
3. Justin Clarke
4. Josh McGuinness
5. Josh Watts
6. Josh Green
7. Lewis Taylor
Major List problems:
*Lack of 1st round talent
*Lack off players that run both ways or apply any defensive pressure
*Quality key talls and running half backs
*Quality young ruckmen
*Mature AFL ready body that can win contested ball
Trade 1
Adeliade: Josh Green
Brisbane: Cam Ellis Yolmen
Trade 2
Geelong: Lewis Taylor, 2017 4th Round Pick
Brisbane: Pick 33, 38
Trade 3 - Three-way trade
St Kilda: Caleb Marchbank, Jack Steele
Brisbane: Pick 8-10 (St Kilda), Pick 7, 15, 17 , 53 (GWS)
GWS: Pick 2, 20, 28, 2017 3rd Round Pick (Brisbane), 33, 38 (Geelong - Lewis Taylor)
IN:
1. Pick 7: Ben Ainsworth or Andrew McGrath or Jack Scrimshaw
2. Pick 10: Daniel Venables
3. Pick 15: Josh Rotham
4. Pick 17: Tim English
5. Pick 47 + 53: Jacob Allison
6. Pick 56: Declan Watson
7. Cam Ellis Yolmen
OUT:
1. Daniel Merrett
2. Trent West
3. Justin Clarke
4. Josh McGuinness
5. Josh Watts
6. Josh Green
7. Lewis Taylor
don't mind the look of that, love venables and ainsworth as ins. how about we get a little bolder and trade out one of rocky/pearce and a swaping around of later pciks so we can get in one of McGluggage/SPS/Brodie/McGrath as well?
theteamtobeat
Premiership Player
If you want to get one of those players then I guess you trade out Rocky or Hanley, but I reckon we can't afford to lose any of our senior players. Hence this is the best strategy I can come up with where we retain our senior group and also bring in elite talent through the doors. I do understand why you would want to trade Rocky or Hanley for one of those player you listed.
Not bad I must admit. Would like to think we would still end up with a top 5 pick though
Fatcat08
Cool and Footbally
Veteran
Lions Board Service Medal
Brisbane Lions - Mitch Robinson Player Sponsor 2016
Brisbane Lions - 2013 Elliot Yeo Player Sponsor
Brisbane Lions - 2013 Daniel Rich Player Sponsor
Brisbane Lions - Callum Bartlett 2012 Player Sponsor
Brisbane Lions - Ryan Harwood 2011 Player Sponsor
Brisbane Lions - Todd Banfield 2010 Player Sponsor
Of all the teams that need a small forward Adelaide is not one of them. Green would be the 4th or 5th best small forward in that side
Also that's not a 3 way trade, it's two separate trades really. The media lives to string them together but for a 3 way trade something of ours would have to go to the saints
Also that's not a 3 way trade, it's two separate trades really. The media lives to string them together but for a 3 way trade something of ours would have to go to the saints
This is seriously good - the best and most reasonable I have seen yet. None of this trade Rocky/Hanley shit. With not a great deal of difference between the top 10-12 picks, getting Ainsworth and English would be great.
Wonder if Tomlinson could be used in the monster trade???
And hopefully a few less injuries!
So would I don't get me wrong, but as I posted on another thread, if the right offer came along we would have to look at it.
Trade Hypotheticals
1. Picks 2 & 20 (points 3429) for picks 5 & 8 (GC) (points 3429) - points exactly the same.
Trade L. Taylor to Geel for picks 33 & 2017 2nd rounder
On-trade picks 27 & 33 (points 1266) to GC for picks 22 & 41 (points 1257)
Draft picks: 5, 8, 22, 41, 47, 56, ..
OR
2. Picks 2 & 27 (points 3220) to GWS for Tomlinson and picks 7 & 17 (points 2669) - Basically getting Tomlinson for 551 pts (pick 34).
Then on-trade 17 & 47 (points 1341) to NTH for Green, picks 11 and 29 (points 1942).
Trade L. Taylor to Geel for picks 33 & 2017 2nd rounder
Draft picks: 7, 11, 20, 29, 33, 56, ..
1. Picks 2 & 20 (points 3429) for picks 5 & 8 (GC) (points 3429) - points exactly the same.
Trade L. Taylor to Geel for picks 33 & 2017 2nd rounder
On-trade picks 27 & 33 (points 1266) to GC for picks 22 & 41 (points 1257)
Draft picks: 5, 8, 22, 41, 47, 56, ..
OR
2. Picks 2 & 27 (points 3220) to GWS for Tomlinson and picks 7 & 17 (points 2669) - Basically getting Tomlinson for 551 pts (pick 34).
Then on-trade 17 & 47 (points 1341) to NTH for Green, picks 11 and 29 (points 1942).
Trade L. Taylor to Geel for picks 33 & 2017 2nd rounder
Draft picks: 7, 11, 20, 29, 33, 56, ..
- Jul 20, 2016
- 4,701
- 8,283
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
So we would give up 11, 29 for 17, 47 and green from Bris?
yep the risk if we trade out our pick 2 is we give up on SPS who is likely to go in the top 3. while this years draft is very even i still see a group of 3-4 as the standout non-academy players ie.Brodie, Petrevski-Seton, McGluggage and maybe Ainsworth. although some phantom drafters have SPS around the 4-9 range in their rankings.
Yeah my mistake there
11 & 29 for 17, 47 & Green.
If Green leaves the only teams he should go to are Carlton, Rich OR Nth.
Also I don't think 11 for 17 & 47 alone (although the points are similar) would benefit NTH.
To nab a player like Tomlinson (doubt he'd be on the table, but we can always hope) and still have #7, #11, #20, #29, #33, #56...that's a good position to be in. #7 could nab a McGrath/Ainsworth (or SPS if he slid but that'd be a very slim chance), and #11 could pick up another one of those guys who you could throw a blanket over from #5 onwards to #15. #20 could get us Parfitt/Witherden/Simpkin.
Unlikely now that Rolls or Allison will get picked early, so we could have three live picks before any academy matching takes place.
Any hey if the rumours are true and Rocky goes for #9 + later picks/steak knives St.K player, then pushing back into the top 5-8 could be an option with a package deal of #11 + player wanting to leave and/or #29/33 and try and get back into the top 5-8. Ultimately leaving us with #7, #9 and #?0-8? in the top 10 and still a pick of #20 to nab a quality player of the likes of Parfitt/Witherden/Simpkin etc etc. Plus surplus later picks to cover academy bids.
This draft is looking tremendously good for the first 15-20 picks or so and I believe this could very well be a super-draft of sorts in years to come.
Our first for rockliff ? so about pick 14-18 ?
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
That won't do I am afraid.
You're offering picks 14 through 18?
How much are you expecting to get for him ?
Similar threads
