Position 2017 Rucks

[Jcpdragonx]

All aboard the NANK/SANDI express with WITTS r3 cover/cash generation. Anyone else running this or have I gone mad???

All aboard!

Hopefully we can hold Witts throughout the byes as an extra player. Will be a great help.

 

[toxic]

i take everything toxic says with a grain of salt


and a shot of tequila
and a wedge of lime

I can guarantee i have Kreuzer as my R2 in dreamteam.

 

[3MM Superstar]

Every ruck will lose hitouts to Sandi

Kreuzer will be a top 6 ruck in 2017

From a Carlton supporter , I would never pick him in fantasy. Never

 

[The Lemon]

Why?

Because I am picking him

I am still unsure.

 

[Chaisa]

All aboard the NANK/SANDI express with WITTS r3 cover/cash generation. Anyone else running this or have I gone mad???

If Sandi goes down you can't flip Nank to the ruck line that easily no? Or are you going with both in the ruck?

 

[toxic]

From a Carlton supporter , I would never pick him in fantasy. Never

Because of his injury history?

 

[3MM Superstar]

Because of his injury history?

That and the fact that he only hit 100 in sc. last season in a fit year. I don't think he will ever get back to his pre knee injury form.
I hope I'm wrong but...

 

[Weiterbot23]

Kreuzer has looked really good in the 2 JLTs he played, def an interesting pod option. He played a good number of games last year, has had a good preseason, phillips is injured and shouldn't be back soon letting him play on ball all day.

I don't have him though.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Because I am picking him

I am still unsure.

may, want to, hope to, should, .......oh heck, i might or might not ......

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Kreuzer has looked really good in the 2 JLTs he played, def an interesting pod option. He played a good number of games last year, has had a good preseason, phillips is injured and shouldn't be back soon letting him play on ball all day.

I don't have him though.

You gave a great story to support choosing Kreuzer ......then said nah

 

[toxic]

Kreuzer has looked really good in the 2 JLTs he played, def an interesting pod option. He played a good number of games last year, has had a good preseason, phillips is injured and shouldn't be back soon letting him play on ball all day.

I don't have him though.

He beat Gawn.
It was JLT i know

He looks good

 

[WaynesWorld19]

All aboard the NANK/SANDI express with WITTS r3 cover/cash generation. Anyone else running this or have I gone mad???

 

[Saul good man]

If Sandi goes down you can't flip Nank to the ruck line that easily no? Or are you going with both in the ruck?

If Sandi goes down ill use Witts as 2nd ruck, n depending on length of injury keep sandi or trade. Hopefully after hes made a bit of $$$

 

[Saul good man]

If Sandi goes down you can't flip Nank to the ruck line that easily no? Or are you going with both in the ruck?

And yes both sandi n Nank as 1st n 2nd ruck.

 

[Saul good man]

I l

All aboard!

Hopefully we can hold Witts throughout the byes as an extra player. Will be a great help.

I like your style!! Be interesting how this season unfolds

 

[Riviat]

Nankilands is looking tempting so I can get another mid pricer in my mids due to lack of any decent rooks...... I went a few mid-pricers some years ago and ran out of trades before i got to the finals trying to upgrade them - I hate Sam Gray. I have ~3.5 in my side now which scares me as it is.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Nankilands is looking tempting so I can get another mid pricer in my mids due to lack of any decent rooks...... I went a few mid-pricers some years ago and ran out of trades before i got to the finals trying to upgrade them - I hate Sam Gray. I have ~3.5 in my side now which scares me as it is.

Think there are mid-pricers and fallen premiums

IMO Roughead, Beams, are fallen premiums .......Nankervis, Witts are the definition of mid-priced madness

Maybe a great decision .....may ruin your SC season ????

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

I'm going in with Gawn + Sandi with Witts on my bench. Then i have Strnadica as a floating donut in my fwdline so by round 9 Witts can be upgraded to a gun forward. Some people might say 217k is too much for a bench player but given that Witts provides cover and should make 150k by the time his bye rolls around, I think it is a decent investment. If Sandi or Gawn go down it'll make Witts even more valuable!

 

[Riviat]

Think there are mid-pricers and fallen premiums

IMO Roughead, Beams, are fallen premiums .......Nankervis, Witts are the definition of mid-priced madness

Maybe a great decision .....may ruin your SC season ????

Beams and Sandicalf are risky at the best of times and could go ping at any stage resulting in no money gained and if they did the injury during the game, no doubt would lose ~$30k depending on BE at the time. Almost as risky as a mid-pricer.

If i turned Gawn into Grundilands i could get JOM in my mids.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Beams and Sandicalf are risky at the best of times and could go ping at any stage resulting in no money gained and if they did the injury during the game, no doubt would lose ~$30k depending on BE at the time. Almost as risky as a mid-pricer.

Don't disagree .....but doubt most choosing Sandilands are viewing his as a keeper .....but i'd also be surprised if Nankervis is being viewed as a keeper ?

IMO out of the two, Sandilands has the higher scoring capacity, particularly given the abolition of 3rd man up ......i'll take his early season points, if that's all it is

 

[toxic]

Beams and Sandicalf are risky at the best of times and could go ping at any stage resulting in no money gained and if they did the injury during the game, no doubt would lose ~$30k depending on BE at the time. Almost as risky as a mid-pricer.

If i turned Gawn into Grundilands i could get JOM in my mids.

Do beams and sandi are risks but omeara isnt

I'm struggling with the message

 

[toxic]

Don't disagree .....but doubt most choosing Sandilands are viewing his as a keeper .....but i'd also be surprised if Nankervis is being viewed as a keeper ?

IMO out of the two, Sandilands has the higher scoring capacity, particularly given the abolition of 3rd man up ......i'll take his early season points, if that's all it is

Why wouldn't people be choosing Sandi as a keeper.
His scoring is ruck elite.

If he gets injured like 400 other players could he can be replaced.

I for one am picking him as a keeper.

In that if he has a one or two week injury I'll hold him.

 

[Riviat]

Do beams and sandi are risks but omeara isnt

I'm struggling with the message

Two thoughts in one post to save space. Consider the bottom line separate to the top

 

[Double the Fist]

Why wouldn't people be choosing Sandi as a keeper.
His scoring is ruck elite.

If he gets injured like 400 other players could he can be replaced.

I for one am picking him as a keeper.

In that if he has a one or two week injury I'll hold him.

Problem is, when Sandilands gets injured, its usually 25 weeks!

I just don't trust him anymore. His best is long Gawn! get it? Gawn/Gone?
















is this thing on? *tap tap

 

[toxic]

Problem is, when Sandilands gets injured, its usually 25 weeks!

I just don't trust him anymore. His best is long Gawn! get it? Gawn/Gone?
















is this thing on? *tap tap

If he gets a LTI he gets traded..like every other player

Still don't see the difference