2017 trade hypothetical thread

[HeHateMe]

I like Pick 8 + pick 23 - 30 for Tomlinson & Smith.
Just need to convince Smith to change his preference. should be easy after today Essendon will have to make there priority's known.

Why would Smith stick around if he is deemed 2nd best i know i wouldn't.

 

[Joao]

3 way trade
Fremantle In: Travis Coyler
Essendon in: Jake Stringer pick 26
Bulldogs in: Hayden Crozier & pick 11

Pick 26 and pick 28 for Devin Smith

Future 2nd for Adam Saad

Or

Pick 11 for Adam Saad and pick 22

3 way trade
Fremantle in: Travis Coyler
Essendon in: Jake Stringer
Bulldogs in: pick 22 and Hayden Crozier

Pick 28 and future 2nd for Devon Smith





Fire away


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Don't think Freo would be interested in Colyer unless it was for a token pick (ie 50+). We have outside players covered. West Coast might.

 

[kane249]

Don't think Freo would be interested in Colyer unless it was for a token pick (ie 50+). We have outside players covered. West Coast might.

Colyer has pace but can't kick, pass.

 

[Vindicater]

I assume that no trades have happened due to Dodoro?

 

[JG22]

I assume that no trades have happened due to Dodoro?

yes

 

[Mitchell54]

Was it this quiet on the trade front this time last year?

 

[RUNVS]

All trades seem to be hypothetical this year.

 

[Mitchell54]

Have had an attempt at a 12 way trade.
Plz go easy as me as it is very beyond me to juggle fair value for all teams. Tell me what you think and I might change something if it's a constant theme by all supporters.

+ be free to try and make this into an 18 team trade

Brisbane in: Pick 3, Cameron, Hodge & 10
Brisbane out: Schache, Pick 1, 19 & 73
Carlton in: Pick 1, 29 & 45
Carlton out: Pick 3 & Gibbs
Essendon in: Stringer, Saad & Smith
Essendon out: Pick 11, 28 & Francis
Adelaide in: Gibbs, Francis, Pick 11 & 41
Adelaide out: Lever, Cameron, 34 & 53
Hawthorn in: Impey & 34
Hawthorn out: Hodge, Pick 32 & 42
Melbourne in: Lever, Pick 32, 73 & Balic
Melbourne out: Pick 10, 27, 45 & Watts
Port Adelaide in: Pick 43 & Watts
Port Adelaide out: Impey & 29
St Kilda in: Schache
St Kilda out: Pick 8 & 43
Bulldogs in: Pick 8 & 63
Bulldogs out: Stringer, Honeychurch & 26
GWS in: Pick 19 & Honeychurch
GWS out: Smith & 63
Gold Coast in: Pick 26
Gold Coast out: Saad
Fremantle in: pick 53
Fremantle out: Balic

 

[RUNVS]

Have had an attempt at a 12 way trade.
Plz go easy as me as it is very beyond me to juggle fair value for all teams. Tell me what you think and I might change something if it's a constant theme by all supporters.

+ be free to try and make this into an 18 team trade

Brisbane in: Pick 3, Cameron, Hodge & 10
Brisbane out: Schache, Pick 1, 19 & 73
Carlton in: Pick 1, 29 & 45
Carlton out: Pick 3 & Gibbs
Essendon in: Stringer, Saad & Smith
Essendon out: Pick 11, 28 & Francis
Adelaide in: Gibbs, Francis, Pick 11 & 41
Adelaide out: Lever, Cameron, 34 & 53
Hawthorn in: Impey & 34
Hawthorn out: Hodge, Pick 32 & 42
Melbourne in: Lever, Pick 32, 73 & Balic
Melbourne out: Pick 10, 27, 45 & Watts
Port Adelaide in: Pick 43 & Watts
Port Adelaide out: Impey & 29
St Kilda in: Schache
St Kilda out: Pick 8 & 43
Bulldogs in: Pick 8 & 63
Bulldogs out: Stringer, Honeychurch & 26
GWS in: Pick 19 & Honeychurch
GWS out: Smith & 63
Gold Coast in: Pick 26
Gold Coast out: Saad
Fremantle in: pick 53
Fremantle out: Balic

Sydney would be crazy not to get involved in that trade.

 

[Mitchell54]

Sydney would be crazy not to get involved in that trade.

Want to add a Sydney extension?

 

[gillo94]

We don't want Schache.

Collingwood will get Schache and get return of Picks too

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Have had an attempt at a 12 way trade.
Plz go easy as me as it is very beyond me to juggle fair value for all teams. Tell me what you think and I might change something if it's a constant theme by all supporters.

+ be free to try and make this into an 18 team trade

Brisbane in: Pick 3, Cameron, Hodge & 10
Brisbane out: Schache, Pick 1, 19 & 73
Carlton in: Pick 1, 29 & 45
Carlton out: Pick 3 & Gibbs
Essendon in: Stringer, Saad & Smith
Essendon out: Pick 11, 28 & Francis
Adelaide in: Gibbs, Francis, Pick 11 & 41
Adelaide out: Lever, Cameron, 34 & 53
Hawthorn in: Impey & 34
Hawthorn out: Hodge, Pick 32 & 42
Melbourne in: Lever, Pick 32, 73 & Balic
Melbourne out: Pick 10, 27, 45 & Watts
Port Adelaide in: Pick 43 & Watts
Port Adelaide out: Impey & 29
St Kilda in: Schache
St Kilda out: Pick 8 & 43
Bulldogs in: Pick 8 & 63
Bulldogs out: Stringer, Honeychurch & 26
GWS in: Pick 19 & Honeychurch
GWS out: Smith & 63
Gold Coast in: Pick 26
Gold Coast out: Saad
Fremantle in: pick 53
Fremantle out: Balic

That actually looks pretty fair although Adelaide fans would probably want a better return for Lever and Cameron.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Collingwood will get Schache and get return of Picks too

If the Lions are willing to do that then there's a serious issue with the kid IMO, i only know what i read but apparently we've gone stone cold on him, as has Richmond.

 

[marty36]

That actually looks pretty fair although Adelaide fans would probably want a better return for Lever and Cameron.

The only thing we wouldn't have done is give the first for Francis and retained it but then that stuffs the whole proposal


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Underarm]

Have had an attempt at a 12 way trade.
Plz go easy as me as it is very beyond me to juggle fair value for all teams. Tell me what you think and I might change something if it's a constant theme by all supporters.

+ be free to try and make this into an 18 team trade

Brisbane in: Pick 3, Cameron, Hodge & 10
Brisbane out: Schache, Pick 1, 19 & 73
Carlton in: Pick 1, 29 & 45
Carlton out: Pick 3 & Gibbs
Essendon in: Stringer, Saad & Smith
Essendon out: Pick 11, 28 & Francis
Adelaide in: Gibbs, Francis, Pick 11 & 41
Adelaide out: Lever, Cameron, 34 & 53
Hawthorn in: Impey & 34
Hawthorn out: Hodge, Pick 32 & 42
Melbourne in: Lever, Pick 32, 73 & Balic
Melbourne out: Pick 10, 27, 45 & Watts
Port Adelaide in: Pick 43 & Watts
Port Adelaide out: Impey & 29
St Kilda in: Schache
St Kilda out: Pick 8 & 43
Bulldogs in: Pick 8 & 63
Bulldogs out: Stringer, Honeychurch & 26
GWS in: Pick 19 & Honeychurch
GWS out: Smith & 63
Gold Coast in: Pick 26
Gold Coast out: Saad
Fremantle in: pick 53
Fremantle out: Balic

Shacke for 8? Saints getting rorted.

 

[Mitchell54]

Shacke for 8? Saints getting rorted.

Do you have a suggestion to fix it?
Does everyone else think that needs to be fixed and what suggestion do you have to fix it?

 

[philthy05]

Have had an attempt at a 12 way trade.
Plz go easy as me as it is very beyond me to juggle fair value for all teams. Tell me what you think and I might change something if it's a constant theme by all supporters.

+ be free to try and make this into an 18 team trade

Brisbane in: Pick 3, Cameron, Hodge & 10
Brisbane out: Schache, Pick 1, 19 & 73
Carlton in: Pick 1, 29 & 45
Carlton out: Pick 3 & Gibbs
Essendon in: Stringer, Saad & Smith
Essendon out: Pick 11, 28 & Francis
Adelaide in: Gibbs, Francis, Pick 11 & 41
Adelaide out: Lever, Cameron, 34 & 53
Hawthorn in: Impey & 34
Hawthorn out: Hodge, Pick 32 & 42
Melbourne in: Lever, Pick 32, 73 & Balic
Melbourne out: Pick 10, 27, 45 & Watts
Port Adelaide in: Pick 43 & Watts
Port Adelaide out: Impey & 29
St Kilda in: Schache
St Kilda out: Pick 8 & 43
Bulldogs in: Pick 8 & 63
Bulldogs out: Stringer, Honeychurch & 26
GWS in: Pick 19 & Honeychurch
GWS out: Smith & 63
Gold Coast in: Pick 26
Gold Coast out: Saad
Fremantle in: pick 53
Fremantle out: Balic

Why do port get r*ped in your fantasy?

We can trade for watts easily enough on our own we don't need to get fisted by losing impey and getting pick 43 back in a poss weak draft

 

[Mitchell54]

Why do port get r*ped in your fantasy?

We can trade for watts easily enough on our own we don't need to get fisted by losing impey and getting pick 43 back in a poss weak draft

Chill out. It's not supposed to be practical. It's just a fun hypothetical. + your choice of words is poor and may be looked at by mods

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

I'm pretty confident Adelaide wanted to hold on to Gunston, Tippett, Dangerfield and Lever so that's 4 in, what, 6 years? There's probably a couple of lesser profile guys that I can't think of off the top of my head.

Davis and Bock

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

3 way trade
Fremantle In: Travis Coyler
Essendon in: Jake Stringer pick 26
Bulldogs in: Hayden Crozier & pick 11

Pick 26 and pick 28 for Devin Smith

Future 2nd for Adam Saad

Or

Pick 11 for Adam Saad and pick 22

3 way trade
Fremantle in: Travis Coyler
Essendon in: Jake Stringer
Bulldogs in: pick 22 and Hayden Crozier

Pick 28 and future 2nd for Devon Smith





Fire away


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

1st one 26 for Crozier nope
2nd pick 22 and Crozier for Stringer nope

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Have had an attempt at a 12 way trade.
Plz go easy as me as it is very beyond me to juggle fair value for all teams. Tell me what you think and I might change something if it's a constant theme by all supporters.

+ be free to try and make this into an 18 team trade

Brisbane in: Pick 3, Cameron, Hodge & 10
Brisbane out: Schache, Pick 1, 19 & 73
Carlton in: Pick 1, 29 & 45
Carlton out: Pick 3 & Gibbs
Essendon in: Stringer, Saad & Smith
Essendon out: Pick 11, 28 & Francis
Adelaide in: Gibbs, Francis, Pick 11 & 41
Adelaide out: Lever, Cameron, 34 & 53
Hawthorn in: Impey & 34
Hawthorn out: Hodge, Pick 32 & 42
Melbourne in: Lever, Pick 32, 73 & Balic
Melbourne out: Pick 10, 27, 45 & Watts
Port Adelaide in: Pick 43 & Watts
Port Adelaide out: Impey & 29
St Kilda in: Schache
St Kilda out: Pick 8 & 43
Bulldogs in: Pick 8 & 63
Bulldogs out: Stringer, Honeychurch & 26
GWS in: Pick 19 & Honeychurch
GWS out: Smith & 63
Gold Coast in: Pick 26
Gold Coast out: Saad
Fremantle in: pick 53
Fremantle out: Balic

Lol so the Bulldogs move down from 9 to 8 for and gain a pick in the 60's and loose stringer Honey and 26..big NO!!!!!!

 

[Thetrader15]

Davis and Bock

2011 - Bock
2012 - Davis
2012 - Gunston
2013 -Tippett
2016 - Dangerfield
2018 - Lever, Cameron

Just for the record

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Lol so the Bulldogs move down from 9 to 8 for and gain a pick in the 60's and loose stringer Honey and 26..big NO!!!!!!

I didn't see any reference to losing pick 9.

 

[amazingjoshy]

Not sure which side of the fence I sit on this but just out of interest...

WC 2018 first rounder for Saints pick 7?

 

[Mitchell54]

Lol so the Bulldogs move down from 9 to 8 for and gain a pick in the 60's and loose stringer Honey and 26..big NO!!!!!!

Dogs don't lose pick 9