Yeah i noticed this the day after i posted it haha, was a piss wrecked mess that night. I assume my drunk fingers were trying to type Macrae but god only knows what was going on in my head.McLean so good hes stealing points from himself
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)
- Thread starter WaynesWorld19
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
Was it lock Hurn at D1?
He wasn't that clint eyed.
Way, way too many risky/iffy players. I have Wilson, I like the Curnow pick. But then you throw in Rocky, JOM, Burton, Smith, McDonald, Sandilands. How many of those 8 risky & mid pricers do you think will turn into keepers? How many are just going to stall your cash generation?
Simpkin is just too much for what he'll deliver in terms of cash OR points. Setterfield is in a similar position but slightly more attractive at below $200k. Throw Brodie & LDU into the mix and you've got $830k in 4 rookies. If you're lucky, 250 points. Put a Premium in with 3 rookies and you're going to get a lot closer to 300 plus generate a lot more cash.
That's before you start thinking about how many trades you're going to burn and trying to find rookies in rounds 5, 6 & 7
St BKD
Club Legend
I'm just not sure about anything yet. Some feedback on this side would be much appreciated.
On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app
On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app
Interesting team.
Forward line is too light on for mine. Not sure on Florent, don’t think you’ll get much value out of him.
Defense is a huge risk with both Shaw and Pittard. Would take Wilson or Sicily over Pittard. You’d want Hannebery to return to his best.
First team I've seen with Pittard. Don't hate it.
I don't think Shaw will go back to the rebound role he's had previously.
Zorko gets tagged out way to easily and opposition are right onto it now. Rocky gone only makes sure that's going to happen.
Hanners will play rd.1 but I won't be taking in an underdone player.
I like Grundy. I don't think Cox will be as big an impact on his scoring as many people are saying. Cox is going to play predominantly fwd.
Florent will be a gun but not a great SC player at this stage. Too pricey and the return just isn't there in points or cash. Not convinced on Raynor. Seems too pricey for a first year player. Especially when there's so many rookie options fwd.
Is Brayshaw a keeper? If he's not, get a rookie.
I don't see any value in Lycett at all. Unless NicNat is gone for the season, he's a dead set liability in your SC team.
Strong midfield.
I'd have one of Christensen or Setterfield.
Rookie defenders though? Such a lack of options. Not confident any of them will get a continuous run of games.
That’s my main concern.
Conca Cuddle
Team Captain
- Oct 19, 2017
- 359
- 1,038
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I think Jacobs is top priced and about 7th ranked ruck. Reasonably consistent but no upside and if NicNat, Grundy, Martin, Ryder, Kruezer or even Goldy start going on a big run, it will hurt.
Pendles is cooked. Gun but I think he'll fall out of top 10 mids this year.
I like that fwd line. Pretty risky but I like it.
Huttabito
Premiership Player
- Jan 13, 2017
- 3,696
- 9,452
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
They will crop up, they always do. Just have a plan for a stronger D4 if need be, don't need to bat as deep as you have IMO.
Conca Cuddle
Team Captain
- Oct 19, 2017
- 359
- 1,038
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Yeah I've been swapping rucks between Jacobs and Ryder, haven't really thought about those other options so that's food for thought.
I'm hoping for a bounce back for Pendles. I think he'll still score 100+ consistently.
Forward line is a risk but I think a lot of people are preparing to take the risk on that line.
Thanks!
Brayshaw to Keefe
Ellis to Wilson
Setterfield to Higgins
Then
Lycett to Ryder?
Lot of downgrading but it gives me Gawn and Ryder in The rucks
Squiba
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 17, 2015
- 5,122
- 7,755
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
First Crack.
Thinking of going J. Kelly to an Oliver or T Mitch; alternatively downgrade to Cogs and upgrade a few rookie or a premo. Lobb and a few other campaigners pending JLT/round 1 selection. Not liking Laird this year as he may get a lot of work put into him.
Don’t take KPP’s in super coach. Especially defenders.
***unless their Franklin or Rance
Huttabito
Premiership Player
- Jan 13, 2017
- 3,696
- 9,452
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Ease up on that forward line (lots of value/rookies) and beef up the midfield a tad. I'd punt on one of Wilson/Sicily, not both.
Lynchy04
Cancelled
- Apr 20, 2017
- 2,532
- 3,150
- AFL Club
- Richmond
DEF: Rance, Hurley, Yeo, Mirra, Bonner, O Shea, Perryman, Cole
M: Dusty, Dangerfield, Fyfe, Trelor, JOM, J.Graham, T.Kelly, Davies-Unikia, Dow, Worpel, Garlett
R: Nic Nat, Gawn, English
F: Wingard, Walters, J.Higgins, Varcoe, Petracca, Christensen, Ahern, Ryan
Backline and Forwards need a bit of work
M: Dusty, Dangerfield, Fyfe, Trelor, JOM, J.Graham, T.Kelly, Davies-Unikia, Dow, Worpel, Garlett
R: Nic Nat, Gawn, English
F: Wingard, Walters, J.Higgins, Varcoe, Petracca, Christensen, Ahern, Ryan
Backline and Forwards need a bit of work
Bit light in the mids, I'd switch Varcoe to a rookie and upgrade Jaeger. Would go Hibberd instead of Hurley. Not sure if Bonner is a lock in Port's 22. Otherwise pretty solid
A premium mid short.
I like the McGovern pick.
Hate Jacobs & Lobb. If Lobb was R/F I'd be onto him with Mummy gone but he's not going to be a top scoring ruck.
Gone to hard in the fwd line.
That backline could go massive, but more likely blow up in your face. There's no value with any of those picks and plenty of scope for them to fail. I'd be a little more safety conscious.
Don't start me on Treloar.
Im hoping most coaches go in with this mindset this year. He is still an absolute gun. Tore apart their practice matches recently
Not interested until I hear he's training down the house and has set a new PB in a time trial.......
- Status
