2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Daniel McL]

Some prices have already been released and the whole Team Picker will be out in a few days so it’s time to get this up.

Use this thread to compare two/three/four players from different teams / positions / roles to get other poster’s opinions on certain players.

 

[Daniel McL]

thepacingman has got us started with one.

Alex Witherden v Nic Newman?

Now with the news of Docherty’s injury possibly helping Newman’s prospects.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Barrass v Hurn v Gov v lock in all 3 of those glorious bastards

 

[King_Steele]

thepacingman has got us started with one.

Alex Witherden v Nic Newman?

Now with the news of Docherty’s injury possibly helping Newman’s prospects.

Witherden.

Barrass v Hurn v Gov v lock in all 3 of those glorious bastards

Gov

 

[King_Steele]

Blakely v Williams v Milera

 

[Keg on legs]

thepacingman has got us started with one.

Alex Witherden v Nic Newman?

Now with the news of Docherty’s injury possibly helping Newman’s prospects.

Webster


/close fred

 

[Huttabito]

Blakely v Williams v Milera

Williams

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Gun v paring knife v nude Kathy Bates

This btw is the method to kill Here2tellyouwhy if he keeps up the Hurn shenanigans in 2019.

 

[Me Myself and I]

Webster

/close fred

After having at some stage last season, Billings, Savage or Webster in my team, I've taken the nuclear option and put St. Kilda on my never again list.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Gun v paring knife v nude Kathy Bates

This btw is the method to kill Here2tellyouwhy if he keeps up the Hurn shenanigans in 2019.

Death by Kathy Bates is a wet dream of mine.

Anyway Hurn's a crab.
Tommy Barrass is the future. Has much more hair too.

 

[adammania9]

Blakely v Williams v Milera

Blakely will avg 105

 

[Hai_Newman]

Williams

+1

 

[toxic]

Webster


/close fred

Roberton

 

[toxic]

Blakely v Williams v Milera

Blakeley easily, will be 10 points average higher.

 

[Keg on legs]

Death by Kathy Bates is a wet dream of mine.

Anyway Hurn's a crab.
Tommy Barrass is the future. Has much more hair too.

Barrass hrnnnnggggggg

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Barrass hrnnnnggggggg

 

[Daniel McL]

If you could only pick one:

Cripps v J. Kelly

 

[King_Steele]

If you could only pick one:

Cripps v J. Kelly

Cripps

 

[King_Steele]

B.Crouch v Libba
Gawn v Goldy
Witherden v Whitfield

Oliver & Kelly v Dusty & M.Crouch

 

[toxic]

B.Crouch v Libba
Gawn v Goldy
Witherden v Whitfield

Oliver & Kelly v Dusty & M.Crouch

Brouch
Goldy
Whitfield
Ollie and Jelly

 

[gutsroy]

Hard to say until preseason form known, but:
Hannebery vs Liberatore (+spare cash)?
Liberatore injury concern but 95/100 seems reasonable, Hannebery has wained but might be less banged up and playing more inside again at StK

 

[Goats]

B.Crouch v Libba
Gawn v Goldy
Witherden v Whitfield

Oliver & Kelly v Dusty & M.Crouch

Libba
Gawn
Whitfield
Kelly & Dusty

 

[Seymour Skinner]

B.Crouch v Libba
Gawn v Goldy
Witherden v Whitfield

Oliver & Kelly v Dusty & M.Crouch

Libba. Crouch sporadically misses games with persistent niggles, if Libba misses it's because he's proper cooked and you know to trade him out straight away.

Goldy

Depends who else you've got in the backline, if you already got a Laird or Lloyd, then pick Witho, but if it's for your D1 spot go the surer bet in Whitfield.

Hard to split, I'm going Dusty + MCrouch to spread the coin around a bit more. Piggyboy's shoulder surgery has made me stay away.

 

[gutsroy]

B.Crouch v Libba
Gawn v Goldy
Witherden v Whitfield

Oliver & Kelly v Dusty & M.Crouch

Libba. Similar injury risk, after 6-odd games they’ll be similar in price Libba will be about 60k cheaper than Crouch if he goes 95 and Crouch 100, but he starts 120k cheaper.

Goldy (assumes Preuss action)

Whitfield - like Witherden, but Whitfield could go 15 higher and be top 3 in the position.

Tricky: Crouch plus Dusty. Like Kelly, Oliver has conpetition for points with Brayshaw, fully right Viney etc., think also offseason cleanups(?)

 

[Metapod]

Blakely will avg 105

Any confirmation from coaching staff he will play mid yet or just speculation at this stage?