Pick 34 I believe.
2019 Trade thread
- Thread starter dlanod
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Pick 34 I believe.
Yep, 34, thanks, I found it in our Trade ‘no news’ Compendium.
Last edited:
Depends who you ask. I was always happy with the trades personally but there were a few outraged posters on here after a few of them.
Nunez
Premium Platinum
If we spend pick 21 on Ah Chee and he plays every game for the season and turns into a gun half back I doubt people will complain.
In the Suns' shoes, he was a pick 8 who has shown his elite talent but been bogged by injuries in the past year or so - he is part of their future and is still valuable to them. He's also worth 4 years to us.
In the Suns' shoes, he was a pick 8 who has shown his elite talent but been bogged by injuries in the past year or so - he is part of their future and is still valuable to them. He's also worth 4 years to us.
POBT
Brownlow Medallist
I agree Nunez. Pick 34 is unders IMO. Great if we can make that happen but I always thought he was worth more. I don’t think his value has dropped that much.
Yeah I don't disagree. Currently we have picks 16, 21, 34, 52, 55, & 64 (do the picks after this even matter?). We also have Taylor going to Sydney & Cutler going to Essendon (more likely than not). Given our range of picks & the players heading out I'm hoping we will get to keep our first two to take to the draft & still manage to provide sufficient value to the Suns for the Ah Chee trade.
We pulled a risky move by trading out our 2019 first rounder. It could have gone really pear shaped if we had a few injuries and ended up in the bottom four again. Thankfully we had some ridiculous luck and came 2nd. There is no point risking our hand again by trading out our 2020 first rounder. We just need to consolidate our list and back our year 2-4 players to continue to improve.
- Aug 21, 2013
- 4,425
- 4,140
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
problem is the Suns have no picks from 20 to 58 to swap back.
Not sure I want to do 21 for Ah Chee and 58.
Unless we think we can package up the three picks in the 50s. I say we counting on those for academy kids.
34 unders 21 overs.
Unless we do 34 and a player for Ah Chee. Not sure maybe Keays or Walker be good for the Suns.
Edit: Expect Cutler prob 57 and Taylor 54. Not sure we get higher so 5 picks in the 50's be way too much.
You hope 44 for Taylor from Sydney
Bombers 33 we have to give back something like 52. They prob ask for 34 back
Not sure I want to do 21 for Ah Chee and 58.
Unless we think we can package up the three picks in the 50s. I say we counting on those for academy kids.
34 unders 21 overs.
Unless we do 34 and a player for Ah Chee. Not sure maybe Keays or Walker be good for the Suns.
Edit: Expect Cutler prob 57 and Taylor 54. Not sure we get higher so 5 picks in the 50's be way too much.
You hope 44 for Taylor from Sydney
Bombers 33 we have to give back something like 52. They prob ask for 34 back
Last edited:
iBeng
Intentionally left blank
- Apr 3, 2012
- 58,781
- 67,941
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
True but value in trade = need, a thing is worth what it is to others. With Birch in is Chee worth 21 to us?
POBT
Brownlow Medallist
We’ve signed Birchall for a year. I don’t think he has any influence either way on our need for Ah Chee.
I have no interest in going to the draft this year. I just want us to add talent. We clearly like Ah Chee and everyone accepts that he has talent. It is a no brainer just to get the deal done IMO.
- Dec 11, 2010
- 10,699
- 12,434
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Birch is now Archie is the future..well worth 21 IMO. Depends I suppose if 21 can be used to get a top 10 pick
I was hoping we could turn Lewis Taylor & something into Sydney's pick 25 & use that for Ah Chee. Taylor & 34 seems too much though, or is that just me?
On the points system that would value Lewy at pick 55.
- Oct 13, 2015
- 10,078
- 25,797
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
I think it is closeish to be honest. His true worth is in the 40s imo so getting a pick upgrade is the best we can hope for.
Could maybe do a future pick swap with the swans (e.g our future second + Lewy for 25 plus their future third). I’ve read in the Age that they may need points for academy prospects next year so that could interest them. But that’s just an off the top of my head suggestion.
- Apr 12, 2015
- 3,549
- 5,863
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
If it’s true Lewy is happy to stay at the club if a decent trade cannot be worked out, say’s that man is a legend and the club is in a seriously good place. 
If we can trade Cutler and a pick in the 50’s for either of Bombers picks in the 30’s, then we could try and package the two picks in the 30’s we would have to Fremantle for their pick 22.
Freo have a NGA kid that is likely to receive a bid in the 12 to 18 range. The two picks in the 30’s would allow Freo to match a bid from about 11 and back without incurring a draft deficit.
Freo have a NGA kid that is likely to receive a bid in the 12 to 18 range. The two picks in the 30’s would allow Freo to match a bid from about 11 and back without incurring a draft deficit.
POBT
Brownlow Medallist
^^^^
Essendon is the fly in that ointment.
Essendon is the fly in that ointment.
- Feb 22, 2016
- 6,070
- 12,319
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
21 is overs, we of all teams know this. We got pick 25 and 40 for Schache who was a rarer comodity, higher pick and in contract.
Look what happened to us with the go home 5.
Young players lose their draft currency pretty quickly if they don't have decent exposed form, plus he is OOC and we arn't deperate.
34 is what he is worth to us, we shouldn't be looking to meet GC on a good deal for them.
Maybe 34 and a late pick shuffle gets it done?
Josh Bruce is worth a pick the 30s.
If 13 was over for Charlie Cameron in people's eyes, a kid who had just kicked 5 goals in a winning prelim side, then 21 for AChee is overs - he has injury issues and hasn't even fired a shot yet.
34.
Last edited:
- Feb 22, 2016
- 6,070
- 12,319
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
If it’s true Lewy is happy to stay at the club if a decent trade cannot be worked out, say’s that man is a legend and the club is in a seriously good place.
Hope he stays.
And Josh Bruce is contracted.
- Sep 9, 2014
- 951
- 1,182
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Ah Chee uncontracted, balls in our court, don't give them 21.
- Jun 14, 2017
- 643
- 872
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
So Gold Coast happy to pay 3rd and 4th rounder for greenwood yet wont accept 34 for ah chee . Seems like our offer way more generous then what they Paid for greenwood. Noble needs to hold firm here .
- Aug 21, 2013
- 4,425
- 4,140
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Yes seeing we get something in the 40's or higher for Squizzy. Who played a lot more games.
Or Cutler.
He has X factor although also a long injury list. only 5 NEAFL games and 1 senior this year.
irel
Norm Smith Medallist
This has restraint of trade smell about it.
