Review 2020 Draft General Discussion

[Watchfromadistance]

my prediction of the top 30 for 2020 AFL Draft, no order:

Bruhn (Geel)
Durdin (SA)
O'Driscoll (WA)
Carroll (WA)
Gulden (Syd A)
Davies (GCS A)
Western (WA) Frem NGA
Ford (West)
Phillips (Oak)
Thilthorpe (SA)
Hollands (Murr)
Davis (TAS)
Collins (TAS)
Edwards (SA) Adel F/S
Ugle-Hagan (Oak) WB NGA
Crozier (Bris A)
McInness (Oak) Coll NGA
N.Stevens (GWV) WB NGA
McDonald (WA)
Grainger-Barrass (WA)
Downie (East) Haw NGA
Campbell (Syd A)
Lazzaro (Geel)
Ginnivan (Bend)
Clarke (East)
Macrae (Oak)
Callow (TAS)
Bowey (Sand)
Perkins (Sand)
Schofield (SA) Port F/S

just outside the top group: Gay, Henry, Baldwin, Cox

I would have Trew and Baldwin in there somewhere Davo.

On SM-G930F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bruce0912]

Is there a standout for no.1 at this point? If so, who? If not, who are those that will be around the mark? Hearing lots of good things about that Ugle-Hagan kid tied to the dogs

Hollands , Ugle- Hagan , Thilthorpe , Bruhn, Gulden, Campbell, O’driscoll and Phillips I believe will all be up there but I don’t think there is one standout just yet

 

[Cadillac]

Hollands , Ugle- Hagan , Thilthorpe , Bruhn, Gulden, Campbell, O’driscoll and Phillips I believe will all be up there but I don’t think there is one standout just yet

You don’t think that SA KPF is a #1 contender ? I noticed he’s 192 and 90kgs. He’s a man child. Could have already I wish there was some way to watch the under 16’s carnival that he played in last year

 

[andleanback]

You don’t think Bruce is a #1 contender ? I noticed he’s 192 and 90kgs. He’s a man child. Could have already I wish there was some way to watch the under 16’s carnival that he played in last year

Its quite frustrating how hard it is to get footage. Impossible to u16 carnival footage and a lot of the u18s aren't televised either. Both should at least have replays uploaded on youtube.

 

[Davo-27]

I would have Trew and Baldwin in there somewhere Davo.

On SM-G930F using BigFooty.com mobile app

ill make it a top 40:

Allies: Gulden, Davies, Davis, Collins, Crozier, Campbell, Callow, Byrne, Green, Jeffrey (10)

Vic Country: Bruhn, Hollands, Ugle-Hagan, Stevens, Lazzaro, Ginnivan, Gay, Henry, Berry (9)

Vic Metro: Ford, Phillips, McInness, Downie, Clarke, Macrae, Bowey, Perkins, Cox (9)

SA: Durdin, Thilthorpe, Edwards, Schofield, Baldwin (5)

WA: O'Driscoll, Carroll, Western, McDonald, Grainger-Barrass, Trew, Morris (7)

its a rough top 40 and very early prediction, but imagine the Allies winning the Championships? btw 13/40 are F/S or Academy aligned players

 

[the big lebowski]

ill make it a top 40:

Allies: Gulden, Davies, Davis, Collins, Crozier, Campbell, Callow, Byrne, Green, Jeffrey (10)

Vic Country: Bruhn, Hollands, Ugle-Hagan, Stevens, Lazzaro, Ginnivan, Gay, Henry, Berry (9)

Vic Metro: Ford, Phillips, McInness, Downie, Clarke, Macrae, Bowey, Perkins, Cox (9)

SA: Durdin, Thilthorpe, Edwards, Schofield, Baldwin (5)

WA: O'Driscoll, Carroll, Western, McDonald, Grainger-Barrass, Trew, Morris (7)

its a rough top 40 and very early prediction, but imagine the Allies winning the Championships? btw 13/40 are F/S or Academy aligned players

Thanks

How do you rate the top 40 a year out compared to previous years? Top end? Depth? Etc.

 

[Bruce0912]

my prediction of the top 30 for 2020 AFL Draft, no order:

Bruhn (Geel)
Durdin (SA)
O'Driscoll (WA)
Carroll (WA)
Gulden (Syd A)
Davies (GCS A)
Western (WA) Frem NGA
Ford (West)
Phillips (Oak)
Thilthorpe (SA)
Hollands (Murr)
Davis (TAS)
Collins (TAS)
Edwards (SA) Adel F/S
Ugle-Hagan (Oak) WB NGA
Crozier (Bris A)
McInness (Oak) Coll NGA
N.Stevens (GWV) WB NGA
McDonald (WA)
Grainger-Barrass (WA)
Downie (East) Haw NGA
Campbell (Syd A)
Lazzaro (Geel)
Ginnivan (Bend)
Clarke (East)
Macrae (Oak)
Callow (TAS)
Bowey (Sand)
Perkins (Sand)
Schofield (SA) Port F/S

just outside the top group: Gay, Henry, Baldwin, Cox

Henry and Baldwin should definitely be in there not sure how you can have Lazzaro in there he wasn’t in any major squad as bottom ager , I would have Sam Berry in the mix also .

 

[Davo-27]

Thanks

How do you rate the top 40 a year out compared to previous years? Top end? Depth? Etc.

thats too hard to answer at this stage, but i can say that there hasnt been many years where 1/3rd of the top group is attached to a club prior to the draft.

 

[Davo-27]

Henry and Baldwin should definitely be in there not sure how you can have Lazzaro in there he wasn’t in any major squad as bottom ager , I would have Sam Berry in the mix also .

then you'll like my top 40 i posted

 

[Watchfromadistance]

then you'll like my top 40 i posted

Good on you Davo. Giving everyone something to think and talk about.

On SM-G930F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bruce0912]

then you'll like my top 40 i posted

Apologies Davo

 

[draftprodigy99]

heath ramshaw (northern) any chance?

 

[Watchfromadistance]

Question: Who do people think are most likely to captain each U/18 side for the National Champs in 2020?

On SM-G930F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bruce0912]

Question: Who do people think are most likely to captain each U/18 side for the National Champs in 2020?

On SM-G930F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Durdin SA
Phillips VM
Bruhn VC
Guldin ALLIES
O’driscoll WA

 

[andleanback]

Durdin SA
Phillips VM
Bruhn VC
Guldin ALLIES
O’driscoll WA

Holland’s a lock to captain VC

 

[eDPS]

Holland’s a lock to captain VC

Sam Berry will be a strong chance, it’s pretty hard to say this far out

 

[Bruce0912]

Holland’s a lock to captain VC

I beg to differ but maybe that’s because of the inside mail, at the end of the day it doesn’t matter who is captain anyway

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

ill make it a top 40:

Allies: Gulden, Davies, Davis, Collins, Crozier, Campbell, Callow, Byrne, Green, Jeffrey (10)

Vic Country: Bruhn, Hollands, Ugle-Hagan, Stevens, Lazzaro, Ginnivan, Gay, Henry, Berry (9)

Vic Metro: Ford, Phillips, McInness, Downie, Clarke, Macrae, Bowey, Perkins, Cox (9)

SA: Durdin, Thilthorpe, Edwards, Schofield, Baldwin (5)

WA: O'Driscoll, Carroll, Western, McDonald, Grainger-Barrass, Trew, Morris (7)

its a rough top 40 and very early prediction, but imagine the Allies winning the Championships? btw 13/40 are F/S or Academy aligned players

Hi Davo,

where would you place Luke Edwards at this stage? Is he top 20, 10 or even potentially 5?

Am wondering if Adelaide would look at trading its 2020 1sr rounder which is very likely a top 10 and potentially top 5 year rather than having to use it to match a bid for Edwards.

 

[Davo-27]

Hi Davo,

where would you place Luke Edwards at this stage? Is he top 20, 10 or even potentially 5?

Am wondering if Adelaide would look at trading its 2020 1sr rounder which is very likely a top 10 and potentially top 5 year rather than having to use it to match a bid for Edwards.

probably top 10 as he was the best player from the 2020 draft pool at the u18 championships this year (very unlucky not to be all-australian from the champs as well i thought), that would be my early prediction, whereas the top 5 will probably be more KPP's and mids, he has a small chance of being top 5 if things go right for him though, its too early to be certain on any prediction.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

probably top 10 as he was the best player from the 2020 draft pool at the u18 championships this year (very unlucky not to be all-australian from the champs as well i thought), that would be my early prediction, whereas the top 5 will probably be more KPP's and mids, he has a small chance of being top 5 if things go right for him though, its too early to be certain on any prediction.

Thanks David. I understand there is a lot of water to pass under the bridge but appreciate the early indication.

 

[kickthething]

What is the read on Ewan McPherson? Are the Bulldogs likely to take him F/S at this early stage?

 

[JennyTalia]

ill make it a top 40:

Allies: Gulden, Davies, Davis, Collins, Crozier, Campbell, Callow, Byrne, Green, Jeffrey (10)

Vic Country: Bruhn, Hollands, Ugle-Hagan, Stevens, Lazzaro, Ginnivan, Gay, Henry, Berry (9)

Vic Metro: Ford, Phillips, McInness, Downie, Clarke, Macrae, Bowey, Perkins, Cox (9)

SA: Durdin, Thilthorpe, Edwards, Schofield, Baldwin (5)

WA: O'Driscoll, Carroll, Western, McDonald, Grainger-Barrass, Trew, Morris (7)

its a rough top 40 and very early prediction, but imagine the Allies winning the Championships? btw 13/40 are F/S or Academy aligned players

Is Baldwin tied to the crows NGA academy?
I noticed he was listed previously.

Academy kicks off for second season

The second instalment of the Crows Next Generation Academy has commenced this week

m.afc.com.au

 

[briztoon]

Genuinely worth a listen.

Google Podcasts is no longer available

podcasts.google.com

Google Podcasts is no longer available

podcasts.google.com

 

[Northernsoul74]

What is the read on Ewan McPherson? Are the Bulldogs likely to take him F/S at this early stage?

Most Dogs fans are assuming we will but we have JUH and Nick Stevens ahead of him. Points for matching all three could be a major challenge for us.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Genuinely worth a listen.

Google Podcasts is no longer available

podcasts.google.com

Google Podcasts is no longer available

podcasts.google.com

They’re big on Grainger-Barass.