Phantom Draft eDPS Rankings & Draft Discussion 2024

[Mutineer]

He is good but I don’t have him in the top 5 for it

I think he could go a fair bit higher than some predict, I think he's being very underrated personally with his dash, ball use and potential upside and not too far behind Tobie Travaglia in that regard.

 

[eDPS]

I think he could go a fair bit higher than some predict, I think he's being very underrated personally with his dash, ball use and potential upside and not too far behind Tobie Travaglia in that regard.

I feel he is below Travaglia as he hasn’t shown as much versatility and high end impact in games. I feel he plays a bit different though despite playing a similar role.

 

[Ysaye]

We are really keen on Jobe from everything that I have heard Snuffaluphagus and he will probably still be available at pick 14

 

[TylerDurden]

Hey Ed. You still got Anderson top 30?

 

[eDPS]

Hey Ed. You still got Anderson top 30?

Yep he sits just inside for me

 

[Cleric]

Richmond go Jagga Smith, North go Lalor in my eyes. North have plenty of mids, and so they can take a risk on Lalor as he is far more than just a mid. He is also a forward, which they need, and he has the potential biggest upside of all the others.
That leaves Finn for Carlton, and Draper for the Crows.

 

[eDPS]

These are my current tiers of the draft

1-3

4-9

10-20

20-40

40-55

55-Late

Rookie

Some players I have in the 40-55 range I feel are pretty decent and could have pushed for top 30 in other drafts. I’ll put the players in my top 55 on here after the Bigfooty Phantom Draft is concluded.

 

[LB2Snake]

These are my current tiers of the draft

1-3

4-9

10-20

20-40

40-55

55-Late

Rookie

Some players I have in the 40-55 range I feel are pretty decent and could have pushed for top 30 in other drafts. I’ll put the players in my top 55 on here after the Bigfooty Phantom Draft is concluded.

Is this recent list posted on here eDPS ? Interested to have a read. Your early list in June/Sep be quite different I’d think

 

[eDPS]

My top 55, I would pay more attention to the tiers and not the set order per-say as its neck and neck with those tiers.

1-3
Jagga Smith 181cm
Levi Ashcroft 179cm
Finn O’Sullivan 182cm

4-9
Sid Draper 182cm
Sam Lalor 188cm
Bo Allan 191cm
Xavier Lindsay 183cm
Josh Smillie 195cm
Tobie Travaglia 187cm

10-20
Taj Hotton 182cm
Isaac Kako 176cm
Leo Lombard 179cm
Alix Tauru 193cm
Harvey Langford 190cm
Luke Trainor 194cm
Murphy Reid 180cm
Joe Berry 181cm
Harry Armstrong 195cm
Tom Gross 181cm
Jesse Dattoli 179cm

21-41
Jasper Alger 183cm
Jonty Faull 195cm
Jack Whitlock 200cm
Jobe Shanahan 195cm
Alex Dodson 201cm
James Barrat 194cm
Oliver Hannaford 180cm
Cody Anderson 183cm
Sam Marshall 185cm
Matt Whitlock 198cm
William Hayes 180cm
Harrison Oliver 181cm
Christian Moraes 183cm
Lennox Hofmann 190cm
Angus Clarke 188cm
Thomas Sims 199cm
Noah Mraz 198cm
Jack Ough 194cm
Cooper Hynes 190cm
Lachie Jacques 185cm
Kayle Gerreyn 199cm

42-55
Sam Davidson 190cm
Pheonix Hargrave 181cm
Floyd Burmeister 199cm
Jayden Nguyen 178cm
Charlie West 194cm
Rhys Unwin 179cm
Jacob Newton 179cm
Luke Urquhart 190cm
Ben Camporeale 185cm
Charlie Nicholls 197cm
Luke Kennedy 181cm
Harry O’Farrell 197cm
Hamish Davis 190cm
Hugh Boxshall 188cm

 

[LemmingMaster]

My top 55, I would pay more attention to the tiers and not the set order per-say as its neck and neck with those tiers.

1-3
Jagga Smith 181cm
Levi Ashcroft 179cm
Finn O’Sullivan 182cm

4-9
Sid Draper 182cm
Sam Lalor 188cm
Bo Allan 191cm
Xavier Lindsay 183cm
Josh Smillie 195cm
Tobie Travaglia 187cm

10-20
Taj Hotton 182cm
Isaac Kako 176cm
Leo Lombard 179cm
Alix Tauru 193cm
Harvey Langford 190cm
Luke Trainor 194cm
Murphy Reid 180cm
Joe Berry 181cm
Harry Armstrong 195cm
Tom Gross 181cm
Jesse Dattoli 179cm

21-41
Jasper Alger 183cm
Jonty Faull 195cm
Jack Whitlock 200cm
Jobe Shanahan 195cm
Alex Dodson 201cm
James Barrat 194cm
Oliver Hannaford 180cm
Cody Anderson 183cm
Sam Marshall 185cm
Matt Whitlock 198cm
William Hayes 180cm
Harrison Oliver 181cm
Christian Moraes 183cm
Lennox Hofmann 190cm
Angus Clarke 188cm
Thomas Sims 199cm
Noah Mraz 198cm
Jack Ough 194cm
Cooper Hynes 190cm
Lachie Jacques 185cm
Kayle Gerreyn 199cm

42-55
Sam Davidson 190cm
Pheonix Hargrave 181cm
Floyd Burmeister 199cm
Jayden Nguyen 178cm
Charlie West 194cm
Rhys Unwin 179cm
Jacob Newton 179cm
Luke Urquhart 190cm
Ben Camporeale 185cm
Charlie Nicholls 197cm
Luke Kennedy 181cm
Harry O’Farrell 197cm
Hamish Davis 190cm
Hugh Boxshall 188cm

Davis, Boxshall, Kennedy, Urquhart.... some good players in that group that I love for different reason's

 

[eDPS]

My night 1 Phantom Draft

 

[WilloTree]

My night 1 Phantom Draft
View attachment 2169742

Love the back to back Whitlock picks. Reid has really slid it seems. I still rate him very high and if he goes in the 20s I feel someone's getting the bargain of the draft.

Great work.

 

[LemmingMaster]

Love the back to back Whitlock picks. Reid has really slid it seems. I still rate him very high and if he goes in the 20s I feel someone's getting the bargain of the draft.

Great work.

If Reid is anywhere near that pick, I hope to GOD Carlton are trading away whatever possible to get that pick.

 

[theGav56]

Reid has really slid it seems. I still rate him very high and if he goes in the 20s I feel someone's getting the bargain of the draft.

Great work.

If Reid is anywhere near that pick, I hope to GOD Carlton are trading away whatever possible to get that pick.

Hope he does well.

 

[LemmingMaster]

Hope he does well.

Great value, top tier midfield/forward option.

 

[eDPS]

Night 2 Phantom until end of 3rd round, sorry to Giants fans I buggered up your pick under the assumption Cats trade up but I didn’t factor in how Giants traded up from their original pick so are unlikely to trade down with Cats. I’d have Will Hayes

Multiple players found. Use birthday to differentiate. eg [PLAYERCARD="23/11/1962"]Joe Smith[/PLAYERCARD]

or Rhys Unwin likely at this Giants pick instead.

 

[M Malice]

Night 2 Phantom until end of 3rd round, sorry to Giants fans I buggered up your pick under the assumption Cats trade up but I didn’t factor in how Giants traded up from their original pick so are unlikely to trade down with Cats. I’d have Will Hayes or Rhys Unwin likely at this Giants pick instead.

View attachment 2171281

Pretty sure the Lions will only make 1 more selection tonight as they have committed to re drafting Darragh Joyce and Darcy Craven.... I am hoping the player we take tonight is academy KPF Ty Gallop.

 

[eDPS]

Pretty sure the Lions will only make 1 more selection tonight as they have committed to re drafting Darragh Joyce and Darcy Craven.... I am hoping the player we take tonight is academy KPF Ty Gallop.

Can you not tell that I kind of rushed this out The more I look at it the more I wish I never posted it on the socials lol

 

[M Malice]

Can you not tell that I kind of rushed this out The more I look at it the more I wish I never posted it on the socials lol

Not a criticism e.

 

[mattyc75]

Whats the go with the shanahan talk for the eagles. Some phantom drafters have us married to him with every pick
Can he make it as a KPD? If not it's serious plagiarism from Twomey im guessing.Davis lasting to our 2nd pick of the night would be awesome tho

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[eDPS]

Whats the go with the shanahan talk for the eagles. Some phantom drafters have us married to him with every pick
Can he make it as a KPD? If not it's serious plagiarism from Twomey im guessing.Davis lasting to our 2nd pick of the night would be awesome tho

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Bendigo boy to help try and keep Harley at the club

 

[PMBangers]

My night 1 Phantom Draft
View attachment 2169742

I felt as if these GWS picks were purely to upset me

 

[mattyc75]

Bendigo boy to help try and keep Harley at the club

Seems kinda flimsy. But if he's available at 60 sure

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[theGav56]

Great value, top tier midfield/forward option.

Any thoughts on his forward capacity?

 

[theGav56]

Night 2 Phantom until end of 3rd round, sorry to Giants fans I buggered up your pick under the assumption Cats trade up but I didn’t factor in how Giants traded up from their original pick so are unlikely to trade down with Cats. I’d have Will Hayes or Rhys Unwin likely at this Giants pick instead.

View attachment 2171281

I know Fremantle's season ended in disarray with Pearce, Treacy and Darcy all going down, and Cox not playing to capacity. But we got to see some of what Draper can bring and also have Murphy and Davies in the bank as emerging defenders.

For me, a better selection might be Gerreyn to provide some cover for both Treacy and Darcy.

Whadyareckon?