Opinion 2020 Player X v Y v Z

[samFFC]

English + Heeney vs S. Jacobs + Whitfield?

latter

 

[brentman]

Currently have Tomlinson on the pine in my draft league. I have depth and can carry an injured mid for a while.

Deciding between Tomlinson vs Brodie vs Wines vs Selwood vs Cotchin

 

[Red Syrah]

Noble (rookie risk) v roberton ( injury risk)

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Noble (rookie risk) v roberton ( injury risk)

Roberton definitely

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Noble vs Stephens/Serong

I currently have Noble with Houston in my midfield but i can easily Noble for another mid rookie. Personally i think Noble wont score quite as well as Stephens/
Serong but i think his job security is better. Thoughts?

 

[Jiska]

Noble vs Stephens/Serong

I currently have Noble with Houston in my midfield but i can easily Noble for another mid rookie. Personally i think Noble wont score quite as well as Stephens/
Serong but i think his job security is better. Thoughts?

Noble. J/S rock solid. Played in two finals.

Pick 2 of: J Steven, A Brayshaw, D Smith

 

[Red Syrah]

Pick 3:
Wingard, rozee, lynch, d.smith, j. steven

 

[King_Steele]

Pick 3:
Wingard, rozee, lynch, d.smith, j. steven

Wingard, Smith & Steven

 

[toxic]

Noble. J/S rock solid. Played in two finals.

Pick 2 of: J Steven, A Brayshaw, D Smith

All 3

 

[stevebbb]

Brothers and sisters, would love as many opinions on this as possible!
I think it's an interesting one now that we'll have a few cheap forward rookies to choose from.
Which route do you take, GnR or MPM?

Lachie Whitfield + Rankine/Davis/King/<other $124k rook>
vs
Jack Steven + Andy Brayshaw

 

[Red Syrah]

Brothers and sisters, would love as many opinions on this as possible!
I think it's an interesting one now that we'll have a few cheap forward rookies to choose from.
Which route do you take, GnR or MPM?

Lachie Whitfield + Rankine/Davis/King/<other $124k rook>
vs
Jack Steven + Andy Brayshaw

Depends on whether you think steven and brayshaw will average 90+.
Rankine seems to be a good rookie once playing, but from this board the talk about king is that he may be a slow burn and not grest scoring.
If you think ssteven and brayshaw will be keepers then they ciuld be less risky for points each week but you still need to bring in whitfield somewhere down the track.

 

[Green Eggs]

My brain is melting right now, need help deciding on which 3 of Roberton / Cumming / Noble / Zerk-Thatcher to include in my back-line. Struggling to justify having someone above 180k on the pine.

 

[Green Eggs]

Brothers and sisters, would love as many opinions on this as possible!
I think it's an interesting one now that we'll have a few cheap forward rookies to choose from.
Which route do you take, GnR or MPM?

Lachie Whitfield + Rankine/Davis/King/<other $124k rook>
vs
Jack Steven + Andy Brayshaw

I like the Steven & Brayshaw but heck me, it'd be hard to not have Whitfield.

 

[samFFC]

Sicily D1 + Pickett M8 + Dusty F1

vs

Cumming + Cogs + Ceglar (and Pickett on bench)

 

[samFFC]

Brothers and sisters, would love as many opinions on this as possible!
I think it's an interesting one now that we'll have a few cheap forward rookies to choose from.
Which route do you take, GnR or MPM?

Lachie Whitfield + Rankine/Davis/King/<other $124k rook>
vs
Jack Steven + Andy Brayshaw

Latter.

My brain is melting right now, need help deciding on which 3 of Roberton / Cumming / Noble / Zerk-Thatcher to include in my back-line. Struggling to justify having someone above 180k on the pine.

View attachment 836469

Too much $$ on the DEF bench agreed. Need to dump one of those 4.

 

[Leeroy Brown 15]

Petracca v Steven

MacPherson v Greenwood

 

[kananooks]

Noble. J/S rock solid. Played in two finals.

Pick 2 of: J Steven, A Brayshaw, D Smith

steven and smith

 

[kananooks]

My brain is melting right now, need help deciding on which 3 of Roberton / Cumming / Noble / Zerk-Thatcher to include in my back-line. Struggling to justify having someone above 180k on the pine.

View attachment 836469

no need for zerk thatcher

 

[kananooks]

macrae neal and 125k rookie (not pickett)
vs
danger bont rowell

 

[Suma Magic]

macrae neal and 125k rookie (not pickett)
vs
danger bont rowell

IMO if you don’t pick Rowell you’re insane.

 

[Suma Magic]

Petracca v Steven

MacPherson v Greenwood

I’d rate them:

1. Steven
2. Petracca
3. Macpherson
4. Greenwood

 

[Suma Magic]

Sicily D1 + Pickett M8 + Dusty F1

vs

Cumming + Cogs + Ceglar (and Pickett on bench)

First one by a long way. So much risk in the bottom options and Pickett needs to be onfield IMO.

 

[Jiska]

Pick 2 of: J Steven, A Brayshaw, D Smith

All 3

Can only fit two

 

[JuddgementDay]

Can only fit two

Beayshaw is injured - done!

 

[samFFC]

Beayshaw is injured - done!

is he?