Teams 2020 Rate My Pre-Season Team

[WaynesWorld19]

Spoiler: 2020 Official AFL Fixture

 

[GT619]

View attachment 837008View attachment 837009
thats it
lacking a def premo on what most folks are posting
plan is to loophole picket r1.
assuming most folks play him on field

it seems the best structure to keep gawndy and add stevens to f3

 

[buttox]

I still don't understand the logic if you loop Pickett(Mid) it has nothing to do with fwd/ruck so if he scores poorly round 1 who will be on the field mid?

ahhhhhhhhhhhhh
you wanted to know who i will play over him.
random cheap rookie who plays r1.
eg robertson mcinerney mahoney.
it only comes up if picket goes <60

 

[buttox]

it seems the best structure to keep gawndy and add stevens to f3

ive tried about 500 structures.
i kid not.
every structure has an element of risk.
ive chosen to take that risk in defense.

 

[GT619]

ive tried about 500 structures.
i kid not.
every structure has an element of risk.
ive chosen to take that risk in defense.

yeah true. I tried the similar structure but it doesn’t look right. It’s gonna cost trades if it doesn’t work

 

[stevebbb]

Great stat but i cant see any of the 4 players mentioned breaking out. Youll probably get 75-80 out of them at best which is not enough to justify having them

Had to go up to see the 4 players

Steven was a premium mid for a few years, if he stays fit (soft tissue injuries + mental health issues), he'll go 90+ for sure. But yes, does carry major concerns with health
Wingard has averaged over 90 three times. Same as Steven, just needs to stay fit and he will do well
Petracca won't go backwards if he gets more mid time, he'll go up for sure, but it might just be a few points
ABrayshaw is the biggest unknown of the lot, being very young and not much history to go by

Anyway I get your point, but your 75-80 average is too low for all of them. Even a 80-89 average would be a fail if you're paying $390k to $450k for them

 

[buttox]

yeah true. I tried the similar structure but it doesn’t look right. It’s gonna cost trades if it doesn’t work

yup it sure will.
i like the 200-350k window for players.
can be downgraded to any rookie without the need for a second trade.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

ahhhhhhhhhhhhh
you wanted to know who i will play over him.
random cheap rookie who plays r1.
eg robertson mcinerney mahoney.
it only comes up if picket goes <60

I'm going to be a real pain in the arse now So if pickett scores 120 on the bench emergency your willing to pick a non playing rookie to get his score?
If that is the case then why not start him on the field and have a playing rookie on the bench like most other coaches

 

[buttox]

I'm going to be a real pain in the arse now So if pickett scores 120 on the bench emergency your willing to pick a non playing rookie to get his score?
If that is the case then why not start him on the field and have a playing rookie on the bench

i will be taking a loop hole player yes.
it wont be at r3 as xerri is almost certainly playing with brown injured.
so a m11 with dpp will be my loop.
if pickett goes 120 loop goes on field. obviously
if pickett goes <60 m9 goes onfield (i may buy green for this.) and loophole goes to the forwards for a look at another player.

 

[Andrew Birch]

fu** it. Sicily dumped from D1 for Zerk and Georgiades upgraded to Steven.

Midprice madness makes me very very nervous.

View attachment 837063

So you're going to break Jelly again. Good stuff.

 

[Blackhawk42]

Jarrod Brander
Brandon Starcevich
Brandon Zerk-Thatcher

 

[PoopingHindi]

ahhhhhhhhhhhhh
you wanted to know who i will play over him.
random cheap rookie who plays r1.
eg robertson mcinerney mahoney.
it only comes up if picket goes <60

if Pickett goes sub 60 he still outscores Robertson, McInerney and Mahony

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Jarrod Brander
Brandon Starcevich
Brandon Zerk-Thatcher

And Jiska was going to lock this thread just as it's starting to warm up

 

[buttox]

if Pickett goes sub 60 he still outscores Robertson, McInerney and Mahony

yep probably.
mid bench rookies are poo.
just makes taking a dpp loop in the mids more important.
not less.
if i take a 120k loop player its one less rookie spot i need to find.

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Jarrod Brander
Brandon Starcevich
Brandon Zerk-Thatcher

Disturbing lack of Kaiden Brand.

 

[Blackhawk42]

Disturbing lack of Kaiden Brand.

Imagine if he had set the Marsh community series on fire...

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Imagine if he had set the Marsh community series on fire...

Sorry, I literally can't imagine that.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

yep probably.
mid bench rookies are poo.
just makes taking a dpp loop in the mids more important.
not less.
if i take a 120k loop player its one less rookie spot i need to find.

Also to this you will have used your only chance to use the VC option unless you have more non playing rookies...

 

[buttox]

Also to this you will have used your only chance to use the VC option unless you have more non playing rookies...

disagree.
if i loop pickett chances are he scores good enough
so my sunday playing loop goes onfield.
can be made cap anytime up until sunday.

 

[Jiska]

And Jiska was going to lock this thread just as it's starting to warm up

No I wasn't?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

disagree.
if i loop pickett chances are he scores good enough
so my sunday playing loop goes onfield.
can be made cap anytime up until sunday.

But you can't vc them it would have to be C and being Sunday what if they are a late in?

 

[PoopingHindi]

disagree.
if i loop pickett chances are he scores good enough
so my sunday playing loop goes onfield.
can be made cap anytime up until sunday.

so if you want your VC score then you're forced into taking Pickett no matter how he scores. that makes the loop kinda pointless

 

[buttox]

so if you want your VC score then you're forced into taking Pickett no matter how he scores. that makes the loop kinda pointless

not really.
i have curtis taylor forward.
loop can swap with budarick
and wack the emergency on taylor.
works prefectly

 

[buttox]

so if you want your VC score then you're forced into taking Pickett no matter how he scores. that makes the loop kinda pointless

do you plan on taking a loop rookie?
which one?
i think xerri plays r1 so hes not an option.
i dont believe xerri plays enough to be a forward rookie.
so is it comben then?

 

[PoopingHindi]

not really.
i have curtis taylor forward.
loop can swap with budarick
and wack the emergency on taylor.
works prefectly

thats a lot of ****ing around. good luck with making it work

 

[LuvtheKangas]

not really.
i have curtis taylor forward.
loop can swap with budarick
and wack the emergency on taylor.
works prefectly

Doesn't work if Taylor and Budarick play, though, does it?

I think Taylor is a far better chance of playing Rd 1 than Xerri, by the way. X will get some games, probably, but not many.