Teams 2020 Rate My Pre-Season Team

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
1584172206308.png

Happy with this, just the 13 keepers including cegs, lynch and smith though. Think we'll be okay for rookies during the season just I can't find another decent base rookie to start so have paid up everywhere. Wouldnt mind some feedback as I tend to live in my own bubble.
 
View attachment 839556

Happy with this, just the 13 keepers including cegs, lynch and smith though. Think we'll be okay for rookies during the season just I can't find another decent base rookie to start so have paid up everywhere. Wouldnt mind some feedback as I tend to live in my own bubble.
I was like, oh wow, such a good team, trying to figure out how you were able to get everybody, then I saw Naismith haha

I think Naismith is a bad pick up, with his scoring and injury history, I just don't see the upside. End of the day it's subjective, so I'm not going to try convince you, best of luck

What's the thought process with Lukosius? Stepping stone I assume. What do you think he will average?

Otherwise great team
 
Would 10 points ave more be a realistic expectation at his price though ? ......or are people just seeing him as a reliable playing rookie ....and is that the case that he's :padlock: in the ESS side ?

No.

Keira averaged 74 last year, Howe 79, Hurley 79, Tarrant 82, Harris Andrews 82. Do you really expect Zerk to score at a higher level than those guys?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

No.

Keira averaged 74 last year, Howe 79, Hurley 79, Tarrant 82, Harris Andrews 82. Do you really expect Zerk to score at a higher level than those guys?
I see it more as what you require them to score to be worth having at that price rather than what you expect them to score. For a $123k or less rookie I'm happy with a 60 average but if I'm forking out close to $200k I'd require an average of at least 80. I expect to get at least that from Rowell but far from sure I'd get it from Zerk-Thatcher.
 
I can’t see anything but a Collingwood Premiership this year. Coming off the Spanish Flu in 1919 Collingwood defeated the Tiges by 25 points in the big dance. Surely this shows that Collingwood play the best ‘Virus time’ football.
 
No.

Keira averaged 74 last year, Howe 79, Hurley 79, Tarrant 82, Harris Andrews 82. Do you really expect Zerk to score at a higher level than those guys?

No for me.

But.

It's pretty thin for rookies down back.
Well cheap wookies anyway.
 
I was like, oh wow, such a good team, trying to figure out how you were able to get everybody, then I saw Naismith haha

I think Naismith is a bad pick up, with his scoring and injury history, I just don't see the upside. End of the day it's subjective, so I'm not going to try convince you, best of luck

What's the thought process with Lukosius? Stepping stone I assume. What do you think he will average?

Otherwise great team

Naismith is a disaster waiting to happen, but all I ask for is 7-8 games. He said he wants to play 22 games and feels fit. Had to miss a second year after his acl due to knee pain but looks fine now. Think he can make a bit of money and if I go gawn, I can’t find a rookie alternative. Having cegs helps.

Luko just fits the structure, taking some kick ins and taking intercepts,hoping for 75 average. Might become Tobe Watson if named
 
Naismith is a disaster waiting to happen, but all I ask for is 7-8 games. He said he wants to play 22 games and feels fit. Had to miss a second year after his acl due to knee pain but looks fine now. Think he can make a bit of money and if I go gawn, I can’t find a rookie alternative. Having cegs helps.

Luko just fits the structure, taking some kick ins and taking intercepts,hoping for 75 average. Might become Tobe Watson if named
What about Cumming v Luko ?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I'm seeing Zerk-Thatcher in most teams now & I'm confused .....a 60 in W1 and 100+ in W2 ....which is the more accurate score justifying a $189K Rookie ?

the fact there is no one else is what justifies it.
 
No for me.

But.

It's pretty thin for rookies down back.
Well cheap wookies anyway.

I'm not arguing against picking Zerk. Just being realistic as far as what to expect scoring wise. 70-75 will be a lot better than what any of the cheaper def rooks average if they somehow manage to get selected.
 
I'm not arguing against picking Zerk. Just being realistic as far as what to expect scoring wise. 70-75 will be a lot better than what any of the cheaper def rooks average if they somehow manage to get selected.

I think he will be somewhere between 60-70 myself. Remember he is not playing loose man and will have a opponent to worry about most weeks.
But he is all but gauranteed the first 3 games which is more than we can say for any other rookie defender except for Noble and Maybe brander.
 
the fact there is no one else is what justifies it.
I see in your side you've loaded your FWD line ....whereas I've gone the other way and loaded my DEF ....I'm pretty confident with the FWD rookies / cheapies on offer

So no Zerka for me .....just the one DEF rookie on field
 
I'm not arguing against picking Zerk. Just being realistic as far as what to expect scoring wise. 70-75 will be a lot better than what any of the cheaper def rooks average if they somehow manage to get selected.

I know you weren't.

I reakon McAesy will roughly will go 70 aswell.

Pity about thier prices.
 
I see in your side you've loaded your FWD line ....whereas I've gone the other way and loaded my DEF ....I'm pretty confident with the FWD rookies / cheapies on offer

So no Zerka for me .....just the one DEF rookie on field

how may forward rookies?

and thoughts on McAseys JS? will he play the first 10 games?
 
I can’t see anything but a Collingwood Premiership this year. Coming off the Spanish Flu in 1919 Collingwood defeated the Tiges by 25 points in the big dance. Surely this shows that Collingwood play the best ‘Virus time’ football.
So they should, they are a virus.
Sorry, attempting humour.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top