Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Me Myself and I]

Touk v Steele

The final decision that is killing me !

Just a toss of the coin. Should end up with both anyway.

Thing is for those with Miller & Rowell, will they catch COVID while in Perth?

 

[Axly]

Just a toss of the coin. Should end up with both anyway.

Thing is for those with Miller & Rowell, will they catch COVID while in Perth?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Lloyd and Berry vs Hewett and Cripps

Cripps & Hewett- hoping for two keepers

 

[TBellicious]

Crisp & Josh Kelly vs Whitfield & Bontempelli

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Just a toss of the coin. Should end up with both anyway.

Thing is for those with Miller & Rowell, will they catch COVID while in Perth?

Not sure about those two specifically, but I think most of the sun's have had it. The CEO was quoted about a month ago saying over 2/3 of the list had had it.

 

[stevebbb]

Cripps + JHF/Ward
vs
Rowell + JBerry


Pick 2: Hinge, Gibcus and Sinn*


Steele vs Oliver


Soligo vs CStephens*




*obviously as long as they're picked in the starting 22

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Cripps + JHF/Ward
vs
Rowell + JBerry

Rowell + JBerry

 

[Battlepants]

Darcy & Crisp
Vs
Gawn & Ridley

 

[JuddgementDay]

I was done with my team, but now I have to trade Sicily out

So Dusty vs JDG

 

[T4P]

M.Crouch v Neale

 

[Significant]

Cripps + JHF/Ward
vs
Rowell + JBerry


Pick 2: Hinge, Gibcus and Sinn*


Steele vs Oliver


Soligo vs CStephens*




*obviously as long as they're picked in the starting 22

Rowell and Berry
Hinge and Sinn, if not named, Gibcus
Steele (have him behind only Macrae, Touk)
Soligo, but I wouldn't be picking him, likely out for Laird

Darcy & Crisp
Vs
Gawn & Ridley

Gawn and Ridley

I was done with my team, but now I have to trade Sicily out

So Dusty vs JDG

Dusty

M.Crouch v Neale

Neale by the length of the Flemington

 

[T4P]

Neale is 100k more, priced at a 99 avg, would say target is 120 avg
Crouch is priced at an 88 avg, would say target is 110 avg
Is Neale really that less risky?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Neale is 100k more, priced at a 99 avg, would say target is 120 avg
Crouch is priced at an 88 avg, would say target is 110 avg
Is Neale really that less risky?

Neale is in 53% of teams.
Crouch is in 5%

That's where the risk is. If he goes well you're behind all those teams.

110+ is the goal for Neale imo. More is a bonus, but it doesn't really matter as all the top teams will have him.

 

[Significant]

Treloar (F2) & Gibcus (D7) vs Xerri (F4) & Sicily (D4)

 

[keithrichards]

Anyone able to make a solid case to leave Macrae out?

EDIT: Would still likely have Steele/Touk/Oliver

 

[AFDogs]

Anyone able to make a solid case to leave Macrae out?

No. But I'm leaving him out.

 

[Bjchan13]

Treloar (F2) & Gibcus (D7) vs Xerri (F4) & Sicily (D4)

If Sherry gets named and plays the amount of ruck he did in the wizard cup then i think the 2nd option probably scores the highest.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Anyone able to make a solid case to leave Macrae out?

Yes leave him out if you want zero chance of winning the $50k

 

[Northernsoul74]

Anyone able to make a solid case to leave Macrae out?

 

[T4P]

Neale is in 53% of teams.
Crouch is in 5%

That's where the risk is. If he goes well you're behind all those teams.

110+ is the goal for Neale imo. More is a bonus, but it doesn't really matter as all the top teams will have him.

Okay so 110+ is the goal for both, but Crouch is 100k cheaper. From a cash gen perspective, Crouch avging 10ppg less than Neale is breakeven relatively (and roughly) speaking, given they are priced 10ppg apart.

From a keeper perspective, they arguably have a similar risk reward profile if their goals are 110+ avg, albeit Neale has a historically higher ceiling and 2021 games behind him, but POD is an advantage in this case imo

 

[brentman]

Treloar (F2) & Gibcus (D7) vs Xerri (F4) & Sicily (D4)

Option 1 - Treloar more likely to be a top 6 forward than Sicily a top 6 defender IMO.

Jamie Elliott vs Sonny Walters in a draft league?

 

[Significant]

Okay so 110+ is the goal for both, but Crouch is 100k cheaper. From a cash gen perspective, Crouch avging 10ppg less than Neale is breakeven relatively (and roughly) speaking, given they are priced 10ppg apart.

From a keeper perspective, they arguably have a similar risk reward profile if their goals are 110+ avg, albeit Neale has a historically higher ceiling and 2021 games behind him, but POD is an advantage in this case imo

Being a POD in not having Neale is definitely not an advantage

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Okay so 110+ is the goal for both, but Crouch is 100k cheaper. From a cash gen perspective, Crouch avging 10ppg less than Neale is breakeven relatively (and roughly) speaking, given they are priced 10ppg apart.

From a keeper perspective, they arguably have a similar risk reward profile if their goals are 110+ avg, albeit Neale has a historically higher ceiling and 2021 games behind him, but POD is an advantage in this case imo

Both are keepers so cash gen is not important.

Neale has gone 110+ 4 times (and 109) Crouch twice (both 110).

Crouch is a much bigger injury risk.

Neale is a captain option, Crouch is not.

Each to their own though, stick to your guns if you are sure

 

[TBellicious]

Bump

Crisp & Josh Kelly vs Whitfield & Bontempelli

 

[stevebbb]

Crisp & Josh Kelly vs Whitfield & Bontempelli

Both great options, don't think you can go wrong, unless injury screws you over

Whitfield and Bont for me, higher ceiling I reckon

Whitfield and Parish or Jelly and use the cash elsewhere?