Teams 2022 Rate My Preseason Team

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Duckworthy]

I would appreciate some help with my team please
View attachment 1343896


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Looks pretty good. Maybe switch McCartin with SDK, put Paddy on field for Gibcus and put Martin on field for SDK. Your projected score will probably go down but your actual Rd1 score should be a bit better

 

[T4P]

Notes
1. I've chosen Kennedy over Cripps, deal with it
2. I have been flip-flopping on the following

Ryan v Rich​

McInerny v Blakey​

Chapman v Richards v Rioli​

Caldwell v JHF​

Grundy v Gawn​

Treloar v English​

Butters v Rozee​

Rayner v Perkins​

3. Hesitantly have Rowell, McCartin, McEntee, Soligo, Kelly

 

[buttox]

View attachment 1343898

Notes
1. I've chosen Kennedy over Cripps, deal with it
2. I have been flip-flopping on the following

Ryan v Rich​

McInerny v Blakey​

Chapman v Richards v Rioli​

Caldwell v JHF​

Grundy v Gawn​

Treloar v English​

Butters v Rozee​

Rayner v Perkins​

3. Hesitantly have Rowell, McCartin, McEntee, Soligo, Kelly

Too many pods IMO.
1 or 2 is great over a whole team.
Not 1-2 on every line.
If one crabs it up your the only person with them.

 

[buttox]

$11,000 left over .


View attachment 1343815

Bowey the only pick I would question.
Pretty nice team mate.

 

[kool kangas]

View attachment 1343898

Notes
1. I've chosen Kennedy over Cripps, deal with it
2. I have been flip-flopping on the following

Ryan v Rich​

McInerny v Blakey​

Chapman v Richards v Rioli​

Caldwell v JHF​

Grundy v Gawn​

Treloar v English​

Butters v Rozee​

Rayner v Perkins​

3. Hesitantly have Rowell, McCartin, McEntee, Soligo, Kelly

l have JHF but l'm also thinking of Caldwell for him. l even replaced Thomas for Rozee and kept Butters..Looks good

 

[Stixx]

The more I check in this thread the more stressed I am about what changes I should make.
I'm thinking changing Dunkley for Dusty but he's usually a slow starter to the season.

 

[T4P]

Too many pods IMO.
1 or 2 is great over a whole team.
Not 1-2 on every line.
If one crabs it up your the only person with them.

Yeah understand that convention, I think it's a risk I'm willing to take in the circumstances of this year, particularly towards the start of the season where performance is less predictable, and more trades somewhat lessens the penalty for getting it wrong.

The biggest risks I'm taking are betting against Whitfield, Sicily, Hewett, Neale, Cripps (c.f. Kennedy), Berry (cf. Rayner), Gawn, Dunkley (c.f. Treloar), and most I have simple like-for-like swaps available.

 

[T4P]

l have JHF but l'm also thinking of Caldwell for him. l even replaced Thomas for Rozee and kept Butters..Looks good

Yeah I also started with the Butters - Rozee combo. General sentiment around here against Rozee put me off somewhat, but still reckon he's a good pick

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Bowey the only pick I would question.
Pretty nice team mate.

Are you starting any mid-priced defenders? I really didn't want to but I felt I had to to ensure bodies on the ground.
I like Chapman but Bowey is a supercoach friendly player and I'd be happy with a 70 average from him tbh.
One head knock and McCartin is gone, Gibcus has questionable js and so does DeKoning imo.

 

[Nelso]

WaynesWorld19

Can you open the round one discussion thread.

Best to open it now so we can have one resource for everything in the lead up to round one.

 

[balmainforever]

not sure i'm heading in the right direction here

 

[Significant]

Two trains of thought here - a team I'm pretty content with, although with a few more midpricers than I would ideally like, vs a riskier side that tries to find value and flexibility in the ruck line to play Preuss from R2 (who should score better than most rookies).

Version 1 - SETnFORGET SAFE ($50K remaining)



Version 2 - RUCK RISK ($90k remaining)



Effectively, the changes come down to:

Gawn v English
McGovern v Baldwin
Hinge v Sicily

I'd swing English forward for Hayes, bench Baldwin, and play Preuss in the rucks.

Not the biggest fan of Sicily, but I'll cop it.

What do people think - Option 1 or Option 2?

 

[weltschmerz]

Very cookie cutter, except for Weller. Considering dropping Durdin for a cheaper rookie and upgrading Boyd to Sinn, reckon that could lead to a bit more cash generation.

 

[kool kangas]

Two trains of thought here - a team I'm pretty content with, although with a few more midpricers than I would ideally like, vs a riskier side that tries to find value and flexibility in the ruck line to play Preuss from R2 (who should score better than most rookies).

Version 1 - SETnFORGET SAFE ($50K remaining)

View attachment 1343945

Version 2 - RUCK RISK ($90k remaining)

View attachment 1343950

Effectively, the changes come down to:

Gawn v English
McGovern v Baldwin
Hinge v Sicily

I'd swing English forward for Hayes, bench Baldwin, and play Preuss in the rucks.

Not the biggest fan of Sicily, but I'll cop it.

What do people think - Option 1 or Option 2?

Opiton 2 but replace Preuss with Comden...If English performs he will be more of a cash cow than Gawn and you could use the Comben/ Hayes as your loophole.

 

[Dark Sharks]

This thread needs to be deleted because every time i scroll down i want to change my team completely with each post.

 

[Deliverance]

Thoughts?

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

not sure i'm heading in the right direction here
View attachment 1343933

I think you can shore up your backline more with another premo.

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

Thoughts?

View attachment 1343966

Backline needs more stability imo but i like it

 

[buttox]

Are you starting any mid-priced defenders? I really didn't want to but I felt I had to to ensure bodies on the ground.
I like Chapman but Bowey is a supercoach friendly player and I'd be happy with a 70 average from him tbh.
One head knock and McCartin is gone, Gibcus has questionable js and so does DeKoning imo.

No one has shown enough as a midprice defender.
Im starting the season with some cash banked in the hope that one shows up the first 2 rounds.

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

This thread needs to be deleted because every time i scroll down i want to change my team completely with each post.

Will Willy Rioli and/or Naish play midfield time with all your injuries in your opinion?

 

[MacStradbroke]

I would appreciate some help with my team please
View attachment 1343896


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

pretty good to me, no help required. McInerney is a ballsy pick if it pays off, don’t mind it.

 

[MacStradbroke]

View attachment 1343898

Notes
1. I've chosen Kennedy over Cripps, deal with it
2. I have been flip-flopping on the following

Ryan v Rich​

McInerny v Blakey​

Chapman v Richards v Rioli​

Caldwell v JHF​

Grundy v Gawn​

Treloar v English​

Butters v Rozee​

Rayner v Perkins​

3. Hesitantly have Rowell, McCartin, McEntee, Soligo, Kelly

We won’t have to deal with Kennedy, none of of us. You will though, in a month or two.

 

[MacStradbroke]

View attachment 1343962

Very cookie cutter, except for Weller. Considering dropping Durdin for a cheaper rookie and upgrading Boyd to Sinn, reckon that could lead to a bit more cash generation.

I love the Weller pick. Had him all pre season up until the weekend, reason, I’m weak as piss and will regret it.

 

[weltschmerz]

I love the Weller pick. Had him all pre season up until the weekend, reason, I’m weak as piss and will regret it.

I figure I need one POD in there.

 

[MacStradbroke]

I figure I need one POD in there.

I really want to pick Weller due to role, but I think he reminds me too much of an Ed Langdon type than a Hall or Lloyd.