Teams 2022 Rate My Preseason Team

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Unless the 0.5 is Caleb Daniel (which I could understand) It wont be will it.
Any chance I could see this team that bats to m5 with keepers and still has 13.5 total across all lines?

I think Wayno needs a tutorial on snipping tool

 

[kananooks]

It changes daily ......only DEF & FWDS though .....MID's and RUCK's are cemented in

I'll put it up ...just a bit premature, because it's changing so much ......F1 - F4 is like a revolving door

same as everyone elses team. d1-d4 seems to be locked. so does r1 and r2. mids is generally a mix of the usual suspects and rookies.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I think Wayno needs a tutorial on snipping tool

The snipping Tool is my 'go to" instrument

 

[kananooks]

The snipping Tool is my 'go to" instrument

am i missing something. did you post your team?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

am i missing something. did you post your team?

Yes ....but it was deleted by "someone" ....such beauty I'm told should not be shared .....apparently it only breeds envy

 

[WaynesWorld19]

same as everyone elses team. d1-d4 seems to be locked. so does r1 and r2. mids is generally a mix of the usual suspects and rookies.

My D1 & D2 are locked ......but D3 yesterday was Sicily & today it's Whitfield .....I'm just not sure how I feel about a "sensitive" Whitfield, albeit Sicily is not without cause for concern on that front either

Just worried, as Whitfield on a run, will easily outscore Sicily .....but on that run, he's likely to have a bad tumble over a dandy-lion

 

[buttox]

Yes ....but it deleted by "someone" ....such beauty I'm told should not be shared .....apparently it only breeds envy

This is my best guess with what you have said.

If you have 3 defenders +2 rucks +4 forwards as you say. That leaves 4 mid for 13 premos.
Not 5.
What is the bet your m4 and m5 are Rowell and Berry?

 

[JDWCE]

Walsh/Tracc over Bray for mine.

Starting both of Taryyn and Butters at F2 & F3 is too much of a risk for unproven Fwd premo-breakout contenders. I would only take a punt on one of them and start a proven premo with the other pick.

Otherwise really solid team.

Thanks boss man. I hate the forwards so much. Not much to choose from without spending big on a Duncan type. Blokes of interest in TT, Butters, JDG, Weller, Heeney all fit that unproven type. If only Marshall was a forward....

 

[WaynesWorld19]

This i my best guess with what you have said.
View attachment 1324124
If you have 3 defenders +2 rucks +4 forwards as you say. That leaves 4 mid for 13 premos.
Not 5.
What is the bet his m4 and m5 are Rowell and Berry?

Well, from the starting 22 field players ...10 players are not in my side .....and no I don't have Berry

 

[VainGlorious]

Well, from the starting 22 field players ...10 players are not in my side .....and no I don't have Berry

You’ve definitely got Roma at R2.

You’re banking on him getting some sexy sexy DPP action.

 

[buttox]

Well, from the starting 22 field players ...10 players are not in my side .....and no I don't have Berry

So your counting Rowell as a keeper?
No wonder you don't want to post your team.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Thanks boss man. I hate the forwards so much. Not much to choose from without spending big on a Duncan type. Blokes of interest in TT, Butters, JDG, Weller, Heeney all fit that unproven type. If only Marshall was a forward....

Heeney is a proven SC Fwd premo.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

So your counting Rowell as a keeper?
No wonder you don't want to post your team.

No Rowell either .....Neale at M5

 

[VainGlorious]

Heeney is a proven SC Fwd premo.

He’s also the cause of more melts on this forum than any other player.

Don’t fact check this - it’s pretty solid.

 

[St Steady]

Well, from the starting 22 field players ...10 players are not in my side .....and no I don't have Berry

threads called rate my preseason team , not guess my preseason team

 

[JDWCE]

Heeney is a proven SC Fwd premo.

True. Can he stay on the park though?

 

[Andrew Birch]

True. Can he stay on the park though?

Hope so. To be fair to him most of his injuries have been due to bad luck than his body being prone to injury.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

View attachment 1324106

Have tinkered with this so many times now. Anything you'd change?

I'm not a fan of your D5 and D6. They are more like bench rookies than starting rookies.

 

[VainGlorious]

Oh look - 5 Collingwood players.

Whelp, it’s as good a time as any to load my account into a cannon and fire it into the sun.

 

[blueiris]

I feel Butters has become a massive overrated player this season won’t touch him myself

 

[JDWCE]

Hope so. To be fair to him most of his injuries have been due to bad luck than his body being prone to injury.

Upon looking more into his history you're bang on. Lots of impact injuries. I always paint him as an injury prone player but weirdly he hasn't actually missed a heap of games outside of 2020.

Year	Games	Average
2015​	12​	70.0​
2016​	20​	79.7​
2017​	18​	97.6​
2018​	21​	97.5​
2019​	22​	94.0​
2020​	6​	94.0​
2021​	20​	83.5​

 

[VainGlorious]

I feel Butters has become a massive overrated player this season won’t touch him myself

His missus will be happy with that


Locked and loaded at F3 for me, until tomorrow when I change it for the thirteen-thousandth time.

 

[morningbrown]

I'm not a fan of your D5 and D6. They are more like bench rookies than starting rookies.

Thanks for the feedback, I always struggle with my defence outside of the premos. Any suggestions on who to swap in?

 

[weltschmerz]

Thanks for the feedback, I always struggle with my defence outside of the premos. Any suggestions on who to swap in?

You could afford to bring in Kiedean Coleman for one of them, he's apparently lighting it up in training. There are good things being said about Mitch Hinge for a bargain. Sinn or Chesser might be options.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Thanks for the feedback, I always struggle with my defence outside of the premos. Any suggestions on who to swap in?

Just my opinion but there looks to be a lot of value this year in rookie mids so i'd drop one of your mid premos and use that money in defense. Most on here seem to be running with only 3 - 4 mid premos for this reason.

Good rookie options have already been mentioned. If you are going to run with Milera, then he needs to be at least D5.