Brownlow 2023 Brownlow Medal

[Andre]

Quite a few of our games were like that. Mystery opposition player getting 2 votes in a game we win by 20+ points.

This correlates (causation IMO), with our inability to finish off sides. Our percentage was woeful for the number of wins, so they weren't clear 3-2-1 for Port. Worse is we'd often finish poorly. Whilst in theory a good 1st quarter by a player, followed with 3 meh should be the same as the first 3 meh and last good, as far as votes go, recency bias makes the latter more likely to pull votes. So our poor finishes also work against the votes.

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

 

[Ford Fairlane]

TBT will be blocked

 

[Schulzenfest]

If you look at the games where players got 3 votes from the scumps but no coaches there's some corkers.

Tim English 3 votes for 30 hitouts, 1 goal and 11 touches.
His opponent Ned Reeves had 43 hitouts and 15 touches lol

Lol ****in hell. I watched that game, Reeves dominated him. English wouldn't have been in the top half of players on the ground, let alone BOG.

 

[Sleezy]

Lol *in hell. I watched that game, Reeves dominated him. English wouldn't have been in the top half of players on the ground, let alone BOG.

Is that the one where he took the final kick out, went for a long confused run and turned it over?

 

[Jhodes]

This has probably been mentioned, but the fact Wines didn’t get a Brownlow vote only 2 years after winning one is damning. Put the guy back in the middle!

 

[TazD]

Philips getting 3 Brownlow votes when he teamed up with Draper against Grundy.

Draper kicked 3 goals to Phillips 2.
Draper had more disposals.
Phillips got 21 hitouts to Draper 18. Grundy had 24.

Everyone singling out JHFs 3 votes against Geelong but this one is almost as weird.

Nick Martin agrees

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

 

[silverfingers]

Proof ample that umpires are dead set useless at deciding best players.
They get enough wrong during a game, why is it any surprise they screw that up.
A more rigged, boring and baffling Brownlow I've never seen.
Just frustrating as hell.

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

This graphic is better than 2 individual tweets.

Lots of mids got no votes from coaches but 3 from umps and

Lots of KPDs and a few rucks got 10's from coaches but nada from the umps.

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

FB Sicily 12 Wilkie 2 Stewart 6
HB Sinclair 21 Moore 3 Houston 7

CE Gulden 27 Bontempelli 29 J Daicos 8
RK English 11 Butters 27 N Daicos 28

HF Rozee 21 Walker 16 Petracca 26
FF Cameron 8 Curnow 17 Greene 20

Int Larkey KFP 7 others are mids Dawson 20 Merrett 17 Serong 24

======== Others in top 15

Mids
Neale 31 Viney 24 Cripps 22 Anderson 21 Laird 20

 

[SureBuddy]

This has probably been mentioned, but the fact Wines didn’t get a Brownlow vote only 2 years after winning one is damning. Put the guy back in the middle!

Have you ever looked at it the other way? He isn't getting anywhere near as much centre square time because he has been horrendous?

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

This has probably been mentioned, but the fact Wines didn’t get a Brownlow vote only 2 years after winning one is damning. Put the guy back in the middle!

Remember when we decided to move Boak to a forward position? Its just like that.

Coach has no Frakking idea how to use players in their best position.

 

[Powerade 08]

Put the guy back in the middle!

Here you go. 5 touches and game over in the first half. Watch the first bounce, you wouldn't know hes 100kg

Match Replay: Port Adelaide v GWS

The Power and Giants clash in the second semi final of the 2023 Toyota AFL Premiership Season

www.afl.com.au

 

[afl2004]

 

[edgie]

I don't know why more fuss isn't being made that field umpires kick the other umpires out of the room before doing Brownlow votes. Like getting opinions from different angles from others who spend more time watching the game than having to be involved in it, wouldn't be helpful?

Sent from my Nokia 7.2 using Tapatalk

 

[_VXV]

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

That's what happens when you win a lot of close games. Compare 3 sides.

Port 6 wins by 10pts or less 9 by 22pts or less
Gws 5 wins by 10pts or less 8 by 22pts or less
Coll 5 wins by 10pts or less 9 by 22pts or less.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

Can't even blame the Geelong game - JHF, big game player

 

[Port01]

This graphic is better than 2 individual tweets.

Lots of mids got no votes from coaches but 3 from umps and

Lots of KPDs and a few rucks got 10's from coaches but nada from the umps.

What the **** why is Tom Jonas in there for round 6? surely he didnt get 10 coaches votes.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Can't even blame the Geelong game - JHF, big game player

Where did Butters and Rozee go?

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

What the * why is Tom Jonas in there for round 6? surely he didnt get 10 coaches votes.

Haha Jonas didn't even get a vote in Rd 6 from the coaches.

That's a **** up by the author. Rozee is listed as getting 3 umps votes but no coaches votes in Rd 6 when in fact he got 10 votes.

Rd 6 was the round Neale got 0 from the coaches, 8 players got votes, and the umps gave him 3 votes.

 

[Doctor Feel]

Adds fuel to the "**** we are shit to watch" fire

 

[RussellEbertHandball]

Games that two or all three, of the 3 Amigos polled votes.

Rd 1 v Bris @ AO Win 126 v 72
3 JHF
1 Butters............................ Dixon got 2

Rd 8 v Ess @ AO Win 92 v 87
2 Rozee
1 JHF ............................... Parish got 3

Rd 9 v NM @ Hobart Win 135 v 65
3 Butters
2 Rozee ............................. Finlayson got 1

Rd 10 v Melb @ AO Win 80 v 76
3 Butters
2 Rozee .............................. Petracca got 1

Rd 14 v Gee @ AO Win 110 v 72
3 JHF
2 Butters.............................. SPP got 1

Rd 17 v GC @ AO Win 106 v 73
3 Rozee
1 Butters .............................. Aliir got 2

Rd 22 GWS @AO Win 136 v 85
3 JHF
2 Rozee
1 Butters

Rd 23 Freo @ Perth Stadium Win 74 v 58
3 Butters
2 Rozee ................................ Serong got 1