Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Hack_Watts]

Parish v Merrett v Walsh

Leaning towards Parish for the ceiling and and the interesting VC option. Can go on massive tears and the 70k will be handy to upgrade a Setterfield type in the weeks ahead.

Does Walsh have role certainty? A fair few blokes run through there and Voss doesn't appear to have his mix consistent yet. I fear that Walsh could end up on the wing at any moment without notice.

The only real reason I'm avoiding Parish is a dislike for him for reasons I can't explain. Hardly a reason not to pick a bloke surely?

 

[toxic]

Sinc. I feel like I'm the only one on here not even remotely interested in Day.

+1

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Parish v Merrett v Walsh

Leaning towards Parish for the ceiling and and the interesting VC option. Can go on massive tears and the 70k will be handy to upgrade a Setterfield type in the weeks ahead.

Does Walsh have role certainty? A fair few blokes run through there and Voss doesn't appear to have his mix consistent yet. I fear that Walsh could end up on the wing at any moment without notice.

The only real reason I'm avoiding Parish is a dislike for him for reasons I can't explain. Hardly a reason not to pick a bloke surely?

Yeah, I prefer Walsh ....maybe consider your Bye Structure in making a choice

For me, it's Merrett v Walsh

 

[HTPunter]

Walsh & Day

V

De Goey & Sicily

 

[swindle]

Stewart v Merrett

 

[vic_LION]

Stewart v Merrett

Stewart for me

 

[HEYTRUEROO]

Stewart for me

+1

 

[marcmurphy3]

Parish v Merrett v Walsh

Leaning towards Parish for the ceiling and and the interesting VC option. Can go on massive tears and the 70k will be handy to upgrade a Setterfield type in the weeks ahead.

Does Walsh have role certainty? A fair few blokes run through there and Voss doesn't appear to have his mix consistent yet. I fear that Walsh could end up on the wing at any moment without notice.

The only real reason I'm avoiding Parish is a dislike for him for reasons I can't explain. Hardly a reason not to pick a bloke surely?

Walsh is no chance to end up on a wing. We are terribly one dimensional without him on ball. He will average somewhere from 110-120 and be pretty consistent

 

[Hack_Watts]

Stewart v Merrett

Merrett. Stewart will break your heart.

 

[toxic]

Stewart v Merrett

Merrett

 

[shockmaster]

Parish v Sinclair v Coniglio

Things to consider are I'm most in need of a premo in the mids, and I've already got 6 keepers with the rd 15 bye.

 

[Wellsy35]

Walsh & Day

V

De Goey & Sicily

Walsh and Day for mine.

 

[Mr_Cantaloupe]

Merrett v Walsh

 

[swindle]

Merrett v Walsh

Which ever has the better bye

 

[stevebbb]

Merrett v Walsh

Walsh by a long way.

His CBAs are up. I reckon he'll go 120+ and we'll all be trying to get him in around the byes, and he'll be close to $700k.

Those who can get him now, should get him now.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Walsh by a long way.

His CBAs are up. I reckon he'll go 120+ and we'll all be trying to get him in around the byes, and he'll be close to $700k.

Those who can get him now, should get him now.

 

[Mr_Cantaloupe]

View attachment 1672353

Nothing worse than being short by a couple hundred bucks

 

[Axly]

Zerrett v Serong v Stewart

 

[JuddgementDay]

Mills vs Parish

 

[stevebbb]

Zerrett v Serong v Stewart

Can't go wrong with either

Stewart will be the 3rd ranked DEF (behind Dawson and Daics), you probably need all 3 eventually
Can Serong keep it up? Who knows... As long as Brayshaw is playing, he'll probably always be tagged first.
Zerrett is solid, but meh. He'll score well, but also get tagged and have shockers.

I'd go Stewart

 

[stevebbb]

Mills vs Parish

Mills has 120 potential if he finally goes back into the middle
I think Parish is a boring ~110 average

I think they're both solid value at their price
If Mills keeps playing defence though, he won't be scoring big

Flip a coin?

I'd go Parish, but will keep an eye of Mills in the next few weeks

 

[Agent_99]

Merrett vs Macrae? Both similar price..

I believe Macrae has been playing with a bit of a niggle and his scores are consistently around 100 a week..

Or, spend the extra amount and get Walsh?

 

[Test Tickle]

Walsh v Dawson? (next week)

 

[stevebbb]

Walsh v Dawson? (next week)

Too soon to answer that, just gotta wait until they play.

Walsh should dominate against the Eagles and go 120+.
Dawson should keep dropping in price.

 

[Lord De Goey]

Ash and English (200k bank)
V
Grundy and Walsh

I currently have ash and Grundy and they probably both need to be traded over the next few weeks. Just can’t decide on what to do this week