Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[JyeDye]

Mills BE is still 116 so you can probably afford to wait another week. I'm planning to go Chandler to Mills next week as a pretty easy $150k upgrade.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Steele or A.Brayshaw?

 

[Jiska]

Steele or A.Brayshaw?

Neither

 

[Judd_Magic]

Neither

I'm looking for someone at that price range uncle.

 

[Jiska]

I'm looking for someone at that price range uncle.

Doc. Or Powell for a POD.

 

[toxic]

I'm looking for someone at that price range uncle.

Mills

 

[jdwood]

Steele or A.Brayshaw?

Brayshaw
Mills
Steele

That's how I'm currently viewing them. Going to try to grab the first two.

 

[stevebbb]

Steele or A.Brayshaw?

Steele.
That game against North was a complete outlier. Very low contested, stoppages and ruck contents. Still got 7 tackles and managed a 95.

A few red flags for me for Brayshaw:
-Coach said Brayshaw is still managing his knee.
-Coach said Brayshaw will spend some time forward (to help with their crap forward line)
-Bad fixture: Swans (A), Cats and Dees (A) in their next 3
-A win against witches hats doesn't show us much

 

[Judd_Magic]

Steele.
That game against North was a complete outlier. Very low contested, stoppages and ruck contents. Still got 7 tackles and managed a 95.

A few red flags for me for Brayshaw:
-Coach said Brayshaw is still managing his knee.
-Coach said Brayshaw will spend some time forward (to help with their crap forward line)
-Bad fixture: Swans (A), Cats and Dees (A) in their next 3
-A win against witches hats doesn't show us much

Steele has only toned up once though where as Brayshaw has a few times.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Steele.
That game against North was a complete outlier. Very low contested, stoppages and ruck contents. Still got 7 tackles and managed a 95.

A few red flags for me for Brayshaw:
-Coach said Brayshaw is still managing his knee.
-Coach said Brayshaw will spend some time forward (to help with their crap forward line)
-Bad fixture: Swans (A), Cats and Dees (A) in their next 3
-A win against witches hats doesn't show us much

Steele has only tonned up once though where as Brayshaw has a few times.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Steele has only tonned up once though where as Brayshaw has a few times.

I considered all three and was going brayshaw mate, but with parish now out who bloody knows what I’m going to do now

 

[swindle]

Mills & Sinclair or
Merrett & Gulden

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Mills & Sinclair or
Merrett & Gulden

Merrett & Gulden

 

[Wellsy35]

Mills & Sinclair or
Merrett & Gulden

Merrett & Gulden probably more certainty re: role, but I'd guess Mills & Sinclair collectively have a higher floor and probably a slightly higher ceiling? Both are excellent users as well, where Gulden can be a butcher sometimes (Merrett less so).

Mills & Sinclair both have that Rd 12 bye too.

 

[Wellsy35]

Mills, Zerrett and Weddle (**** all bank, last boost, 3 rooks - Ashcroft, Cincotta, Simpson on field)

vs.

Dawson and Weddle ($138k bank, 1 boost left, 3 rooks plus McKenna on field)

 

[mike262]

N. Anderson or J. Dawson

 

[Wellsy35]

N. Anderson or J. Dawson

Dawson, no question.

If it was last week when Anderson was $550k, then it's a trickier question.

 

[stevebbb]

Steele has only tonned up once though where as Brayshaw has a few times.

Scored 102 and 118 AF in rounds 1 and 2. Looks like CD screwed him.

Back your gut mate.

 

[stevebbb]

Who to play on field? (can't loop)

Wilmot vs Seamus

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Who to play on field? (can't loop)

Wilmot vs Seamus

Wilmot

 

[SC fish]

Who to play on field? (can't loop)

Wilmot vs Seamus

Yeah probably Wilmot

 

[jdwood]

Merrett vs Jelly (Parish replacement)

Leaning Merrett just because Jelly gets injured whenever I go near him. Merrett is also an end of season specialist.

 

[evo]

Steele or A.Brayshaw?

- I m getting Steele purely becuase St Kilda has a lot easier drwa going forward.

- Freo are also playing like dirt, whereas St Kilda are playing out of their skims.

- Also J Lo says he lll probably play Brayshaw forward a bit.

 

[Fisheroo]

who on field (can't loop):
Ginbey (named on ball and coach said he'll try to run with Anderson)
or
Cincotta

 

[AFDogs]

who on field (can't loop):
Ginbey (named on ball and coach said he'll try to run with Anderson)
or
Cincotta

Cinc.

Can't trust any West Coast players on field right now.