Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Scythe94]

Merrett vs Jelly (Parish replacement)

Leaning Merrett just because Jelly gets injured whenever I go near him. Merrett is also an end of season specialist.

Merrett. Though wouldn't trade Parish without knowing for sure that he'll be out longer than a week

 

[Scythe94]

who on field (can't loop):
Ginbey (named on ball and coach said he'll try to run with Anderson)
or
Cincotta

Cincotta comfortably

 

[marcmurphy3]

Really struggling with this one.

OptionA: Greene to Atkins & McKenna to Mills

Option B: Greene to Atkins & Chandler / Ashcroft to Dawson

Option C: Greene to Weddle & McKenna to Dawson

Was going option A all week but now tempted to get Dawson in and go option B. Will mean I have all the super premos and can chase value from here to fill M 6-8 and F/D 6. I doubt Dawson goes much lower even with a bad score.

Mills could be good but may not. There are a bunch of guys around that price and it's not really obvious who the right one is.

Would rather not dump Chandler or Ashcroft but am more keen on Atkins then Weddle.

 

[Scythe94]

Really struggling with this one.

OptionA: Greene to Atkins & McKenna to Mills

Option B: Greene to Atkins & Chandler / Ashcroft to Dawson

Option C: Greene to Weddle & McKenna to Dawson

Was going option A all week but now tempted to get Dawson in and go option B. Will mean I have all the super premos and can chase value from here to fill M 6-8 and F/D 6. I doubt Dawson goes much lower even with a bad score.

Mills could be good but may not. There are a bunch of guys around that price and it's not really obvious who the right one is.

Would rather not dump Chandler or Ashcroft but am more keen on Atkins then Weddle.

I'd personally go with C and pocket the extra $70k from Weddle over Atkins, but if you really want Atkins, go with B and keep Chandler over Ashcroft (play the BE game – that 37 will be in the rolling average next week, too).

 

[marcmurphy3]

I'd personally go with C and pocket the extra $70k from Weddle over Atkins, but if you really want Atkins, go with B and keep Chandler over Ashcroft (play the BE game – that 37 will be in the rolling average next week, too).

Thanks mate. Appreciate it.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Really struggling with this one.

OptionA: Greene to Atkins & McKenna to Mills

Option B: Greene to Atkins & Chandler / Ashcroft to Dawson

Option C: Greene to Weddle & McKenna to Dawson

Was going option A all week but now tempted to get Dawson in and go option B. Will mean I have all the super premos and can chase value from here to fill M 6-8 and F/D 6. I doubt Dawson goes much lower even with a bad score.

Mills could be good but may not. There are a bunch of guys around that price and it's not really obvious who the right one is.

Would rather not dump Chandler or Ashcroft but am more keen on Atkins then Weddle.

C - Weddle is as safe as Atkins imo (neither great) better to make a mistake on the cheaper option.

 

[kenneje]

Mills vs Steele?

 

[King Max]

Really struggling with this one.

OptionA: Greene to Atkins & McKenna to Mills

Option B: Greene to Atkins & Chandler / Ashcroft to Dawson

Option C: Greene to Weddle & McKenna to Dawson

Was going option A all week but now tempted to get Dawson in and go option B. Will mean I have all the super premos and can chase value from here to fill M 6-8 and F/D 6. I doubt Dawson goes much lower even with a bad score.

Mills could be good but may not. There are a bunch of guys around that price and it's not really obvious who the right one is.

Would rather not dump Chandler or Ashcroft but am more keen on Atkins then Weddle.

I like Option B.
You get the best 1st or 2nd Def premo by years end. Plus McKenna has next 2 games at the Gabba and hopefully Atkins strings 3 games in a round for a $130k gain.

 

[Mr_Cantaloupe]

Hold O.Baker 42BE v Ashcroft 71BE

Both probably time to go but need to keep one. Ashcroft BE will shoot up next week when the 103 falls out.

 

[SC fish]

Mills vs Steele?

Mills for mine. Unsure on both of them though

 

[Jiska]

Gulden vs Doc?

 

[SC fish]

Gulden vs Doc?

I've taken Doch so probably best to go Gulden

 

[Jiska]

I've taken Doch so probably best to go Gulden

I’ve taken Doc too so far, and happy with that TBH.

But to take Ginbey I have to bench Cincotta or Ashcroft. But if I take Gulden, I can field those two and bench Seamus instead. Plus at least I nullify Gulden in my H2H matchups.

Whatever I do I should do the opposite. But if I do the opposite, I should have made the original call. Can’t win

 

[Hack_Watts]

Baker v Wilmot on field.

I'm leaning to Baker just. Wingers have scored pretty well against the blues. It's a 50/50.

 

[Jiska]

Baker v Wilmot on field.

I'm leaning to Baker just. Wingers have scored pretty well against the blues. It's a 50/50.

Yeah probably Baker, but either way probably only a few points diff

Cincotta or Ashcroft on field?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Yeah probably Baker, but either way probably only a few points diff

Cincotta or Ashcroft on field?

Cincotta - it’s the vibes

 

[Hack_Watts]

Yeah probably Baker, but either way probably only a few points diff

Cincotta or Ashcroft on field?

Hmm. Another 50/50. Ash has the ceiling and is a much better talent.

I traded Ashcroft. Figure Baker and Wilmot are more likely to make money. Could be the difference between grabbing Mills vs a 490k type next week...

Play Ash.

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Yeah probably Baker, but either way probably only a few points diff

Cincotta or Ashcroft on field?

Ashcroft against us easily. Didn't you say he's averaging in the 90 at the Gabba?

 

[Jiska]

Ashcroft against us easily. Didn't you say he's averaging in the 90 at the Gabba?

Yep. Only three games of data tho. Have done that.

Next one; Seamus or Drury?

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Yep. Only three games of data tho. Have done that.

Next one; Seamus or Drury?

Seamus

 

[Jiska]

I've taken Doch so probably best to go Gulden

Sage advice. Whoops

 

[Axly]

Rowell v Butters v Steele v De Goey

 

[swindle]

Mills & Sinclair or
Merrett & Gulden

 

[stevebbb]

Rowell v Butters v Steele v De Goey

Defs not Steele, retuning from injury, might have injured his knee, not scoring that well

Then you need to decide if you want a MID or FWD premo

If FWD, then it's Butters

If MID, then either would be good. Pies have Norf and Eagles after the Blues, should be a couple of big scores for JDG. Just assess the byes and choose? JDG might hurt your rd14 bye.

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Baker vs Redman vs Haynes

Leaning Baker with the DPP as eventual F7/D7 cover if I don't run out of trades lol.