Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Laird mate. Piggy can throw out stinker and drop in price. He has the last few years.
I expect Laird to continue his finish to last year and almost be a perma captain.

I didn't start Piggy last year thinking the same thing. He only had one stinker, but rescued his price two weeks later with a 168 and never got below $618k. I am leaning Laird as that's not likely to happen again. It's the risk starting any player at that price I guess - one bad score and everyone gets them cheaper.

Oliver

The quick equaliser makes it 3-3

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I didn't start Piggy last year thinking the same thing. He only had one stinker, but rescued his price two weeks later with a 168 and never got below $618k. I am leaning Laird as that's not likely to happen again. It's the risk starting any player at that price I guess - one bad score and everyone gets them cheaper.


The quick equaliser makes it 3-3

Here is another option "JUST PICK BOTH KENTY"
This might sway you as well both players before the bye rounds Do not have any games that clash so you will always have a VC & C option.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Here is another option "JUST PICK BOTH KENTY"
This might sway you as well both players before the bye rounds Do not have any games that clash so you will always have a VC & C option.

Yeah I'd like to, just canvassing opinions. Still a long way to go until round 1.

Or "SETTLE DOWN KENTIE, IT"S A ****ING INTERNET FORUM"

 

[Makeshift Park]

Oliver has the superior three year average and he’s missed less games through injury over the course of his career (tho that’s only the difference of a few).

I also prefer Oliver from the perspective of diversification as I’ll own Dawson.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Oliver has the superior three year average and he’s missed less games through injury over the course of his career (tho that’s only the difference of a few).

I also prefer Oliver from the perspective of diversification as I’ll own Dawson.

Laird has only been playing midfield two seasons though.

As A Bit Dusty rudely suggested above I think both is the real answer here.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Laird has only been playing midfield two seasons though.

As A Bit Dusty rudely suggested above I think both is the real answer here.

He switched in 2020?

Edit: oh I see, it was at the end of the year

In any case, clarry has the superior two year average too

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

He switched in 2020?

Yeah you're right, part of that season too.

Laird, a two-time All Australian defender and 2018 Club Champion in the role, was thrust into the midfield late last season and thrived, winning 25 possessions or more in eight of the last nine game and finishing second in the best and fairest.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I didn't start Piggy last year thinking the same thing. He only had one stinker, but rescued his price two weeks later with a 168 and never got below $618k. I am leaning Laird as that's not likely to happen again. It's the risk starting any player at that price I guess - one bad score and everyone gets them cheaper.


The quick equaliser makes it 3-3

Ok - I'll go Oliver as I didn't have him all of last year
and you go Laird as you didn't have him last year

Deal?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Ok - I'll go Oliver as I didn't have him all of last year
and you go Laird as you didn't have him last year

Deal?

Lol no deal. I had Laird but not Piggy.

 

[kananooks]

im here for the chaos.

so ill pick whoever makes it an equal vote again (rory)

 

[Me Myself and I]

kananooks

What's the go with "Tradeaholic" in your profile? Would have thought Judd_Magic has the copyright to that.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

I've got Doc & Bont

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

Sicily and Bont

 

[King_Steele]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

Doch & Touk

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

Don't know if I'm picking him or not in SuperCoach in 2023... But huge congrats to the legend that is Doch:

Blues favourite celebrates baby joy after cancer battle​

Carlton star Sam Docherty and wife Natalie have been inundated with congratulations after welcoming their first child into the world.

 

[kananooks]

kananooks

What's the go with "Tradeaholic" in your profile? Would have thought Judd_Magic has the copyright to that.

im definitely giving him a damn good run for it..

 

[King Max]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

I like Sicily & Bont, but think either works with me.
Maybe check what works better with your byes.

 

[Duckworthy]

Sicily & Bont
Vs
Docherty & Touk

Sicily & Touk for me.

Sicily & Bont if you can't save $20k elsewhere

 

[Northernsoul74]

LDU vs Green

I can mount arguments for both, and going around in circles

Green.

 

[King Max]

Green.

Green or Anderson my pick. Just Anderson has the crap bye.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

So looking at a running 2 of the below as M4 and M5. Please rank the below (or pick your favourite two)

Noah Anderson
Bailey Smith
Tom Green
Tom Mitchell
Luke Davies-Uniake

 

[rocker_oz33]

So looking at a running 2 of the below as M4 and M5. Please rank the below (or pick your favourite two)

Noah Anderson
Bailey Smith
Tom Green
Tom Mitchell
Luke Davies-Uniake

PS watch .

But Mitch and green.

Throw in Warner...blondes have more fun...

 

[rocker_oz33]

Who else is in and about Nicky D price down back..

Bray is 550k.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Who else is in and about Nicky D price down back..

Bray is 550k.

I've swapped both of them around a few times. I wouldn't mind both in my team at D2-D3