Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
What's not to like about Jelly?
Hardly missed a game the last 2 seasons. A little unlucky prior to that.
Has burned more than a few SC coaches in his time but has the tide turned?
i think hes ripe for the picking. at < 600k hes a steele. get it. because steele is a steal too..

if its not green in my team. its kelly.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Dawson v Docherty
Warner v Green v Titch
Docherty ....I'm afraid Dawson won't have the huge freebie points from kick-ins this season

Green ....although I also have Titch which is worrying me ....not confident
 
Docherty ....I'm afraid Dawson won't have the huge freebie points from kick-ins this season

Green ....although I also have Titch which is worrying me ....not confident
Can you expand on your Dawson thoughts WW19? Who will take the kick-ins from him?

He is one of my few backline locks along with the Sicdawg.
 
Can you expand on your Dawson thoughts WW19? Who will take the kick-ins from him?

He is one of my few backline locks along with the Sicdawg.
When the Crows recruited Dawson, all the talk was around midfield time .....then during games, our KPD's weren't marking the ball & we didn't have an elite user, to bring the ball out of the D50 ....so the Coach kept swinging him back into DEF

So 2023 ...Dawson still talked about being used further up the ground .....Milera is being thrown back to his preferred HB role & he is an elite kick .....also Michaelanney is being talked up a bit

Still very early in the PS .....need to see roles confirmed with Dawson
 
When the Crows recruited Dawson, all the talk was around midfield time .....then during games, our KPD's weren't marking the ball & we didn't have an elite user, to bring the ball out of the D50 ....so the Coach kept swinging him back into DEF

So 2023 ...Dawson still talked about being used further up the ground .....Milera is being thrown back to his preferred HB role & he is an elite kick .....also Michaelanney is being talked up a bit

Still very early in the PS .....need to see roles confirmed with Dawson

Hey a couple of weeks ago you said Michaelanney wouldn't play.....
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Hey a couple of weeks ago you said Michaelanney wouldn't play.....
I'm simply quoting a training report .....what are we, a week into post Christmas PS

I'll still stand by the comments
 
Dawson v Docherty
Warner v Green v Titch
I had Titch at M5 and was tossing up between him, Green or Anderson.
Will any of those 3 become top 10 Mid? Maybe, maybe not.
Then I moved Dunkley to M5 and brought in Coniglio at F1 (nearly same price as 3 above) knowing he will be top 3 forward at years end and move Dunkley forward later. I’m guaranteed 2 Ubers this way.
 
I had Titch at M5 and was tossing up between him, Green or Anderson.
Will any of those 3 become top 10 Mid? Maybe, maybe not.
Then I moved Dunkley to M5 and brought in Coniglio at F1 (nearly same price as 3 above) knowing he will be top 3 forward at years end and move Dunkley forward later. I’m guaranteed 2 Ubers this way.
I like Cogs but cant move titch on from m5. Everything is feeling positive to him getting back to 110 ave.
 
I like Cogs but cant move titch on from m5. Everything is feeling positive to him getting back to 110 ave.
Get the feeling the game has moved past Mitchell. He was good at getting 2 or 3 possessions in slow ball movement game styles. If the Pies go back to being shite he might go ok. Do we think that will happen?
 
Get the feeling the game has moved past Mitchell. He was good at getting 2 or 3 possessions in slow ball movement game styles. If the Pies go back to being shite he might go ok. Do we think that will happen?
According to training reports so far he hasn’t missed a beat, playing purely midfield and linking up well in fast chains of ball movement, its only pre season training but signs are good so far. hopefully The pre season game will show what to expect from him, hope this helps
 
Get the feeling the game has moved past Mitchell. He was good at getting 2 or 3 possessions in slow ball movement game styles. If the Pies go back to being shite he might go ok. Do we think that will happen?
He averaged 90 odd last year after being moved out of his preferred role at the centre bounces. Pies have him earmarked to move back into the middle and get his snout in the trough again. He looks in ripping condition too and i feel like he has a point to prove being at a new club. I like the pies list and what they are building but it wouldn't surprise me if they drop out of the 8.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top