Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[toxic]

Sicily vs Zerrett?

Sicily

 

[jdwood]

Sicily vs Zerrett?

Zerrett is currently in career best form and typically finishes seasons strongly. Probably only second to Bont in terms of must have mids at the moment.

I'd go with him if that works from a positional sense.

 

[Sketi]

Butters vs Touk?

 

[ubeaut]

Butters. Touk might be playing fwd

Butters vs Touk?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Butters vs Touk?

Touk still has a lot of value to drop.

 

[Vallace96]

Steele vs Cripps vs Mills for M8?

 

[PoopingHindi]

Steele vs Cripps vs Mills for M8?

Steele I think but it’s a crapshoot.
it’s easier to find reasons not to pick them than it is to find the positives.

 

[Jiska]

Butters vs Touk?

Butters. Would want to see more from Touk first.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Butters or Rozee?

 

[toxic]

Butters or Rozee?

Rozee

 

[Gresham2King]

Butters v Nic Martin

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Butters v Nic Martin

Butters for the ceiling, Martin for the absolute PODness

 

[Sketi]

Continuing the theme of Butters vs _______

Butters vs Parish?

Similar price. Parish with the far superior 3 and 5 round average.

 

[King Max]

Continuing the theme of Butters vs _______

Butters vs Parish?

Similar price. Parish with the far superior 3 and 5 round average.

Parish has nice games over the SC finals if playing for cash leagues.

 

[Sketi]

Parish has nice games over the SC finals if playing for cash leagues.

I noticed that. His last game is against Collingwood at the G which isn't as cruisy but could still go well.

 

[toxic]

Continuing the theme of Butters vs _______

Butters vs Parish?

Similar price. Parish with the far superior 3 and 5 round average.

Parish by a MILE

 

[Sketi]

Parish by a MILE

Yeah Butters' drop off concerns me as a potential owner. Parish seems a pretty reliable ball magnet when fit.

 

[King Max]

I noticed that. His last game is against Collingwood at the G which isn't as cruisy but could still go well.

Pies don’t tag which helps out.

 

[EA100]

Seamus M. 23rd player & Sicily

or

Sheezel 23 player & Sinclair/Docherty/Houston/Ryan

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Seamus M. 23rd player & Sicily

or

Sheezel 23 player & Sinclair/Docherty/Houston/Ryan

Tough one, are you using 2 trades for both scenario's?

Sicily hasn't scored as well with Blanck out.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Seamus M. 23rd player & Sicily

or

Sheezel 23 player & Sinclair/Docherty/Houston/Ryan

prioritise on field points and pick the best defender.
I think that’s Sicily.

 

[Axly]

Rozee v Nic Martin (POD)

 

[Faz 2000]

Rozee v Nic Martin (POD)

Gee, not two guys I thought we’d be comparing this year.

Rozee is proper consistent promo now, but Martin’s recent form and huge scoring is seriously hard to ignore. POD, and some soft targets coming up. Might have to go that way!


Mine is Laird vs Parish

 

[Axly]

Gee, not two guys I thought we’d be comparing this year.

Rozee is proper consistent promo now, but Martin’s recent form and huge scoring is seriously hard to ignore. POD, and some soft targets coming up. Might have to go that way!


Mine is Laird vs Parish

Cheers!

Oooh hard one too!

I think I'd have to go the consistency option in Laird.

 

[EA100]

Docherty v Daniel v Ryan v Sinclair