Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[King Max]

Can any of you campaigners rank these rooks for me in order of who will score most this week? Many thanks.

Baker / Cincotta / Humphrey / Mitchell / Weddle

Could go any way…
Humphrey, Mitchell, Baker, Cincotta, Weddle.
Now that I’ve said this, it will go backwards.

 

[Test Tickle]

Am I mad to consider bringing in Chesser over Sharp? I can see us pumping far more games into Chesser than Sharp will get. Need a cheap rookie this week and already have Drury.

Lol Chesser, he’s never left my team.

 

[JDC!]

N. Anderson vs. C. Serong vs. L. Neale

I'm thinking with the byes in mind. Who would you take out of those three, also noting that cash generation has been an on-going issues to saving money (avoiding Anderson) could be the wise thing to do.

Any advice?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Very very minor in the scheme of things, but warm bodies through the byes is useful

Who's likely to get games between Cowan & Davey?

 

[Sherman41]

Very very minor in the scheme of things, but warm bodies through the byes is useful

Who's likely to get games between Cowan & Davey?

Considering Davey is getting games at the moment I’d say Davey. Cowan looks 10 lengths off the pace at the moment.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Neale vs Jelly vs Walsh vs Serong

Not Neale. Walsh if you can afford him and may get dpp. Kelly going under the radar though.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Very very minor in the scheme of things, but warm bodies through the byes is useful

Who's likely to get games between Cowan & Davey?

Davey but neither have great JS.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Am I mad to consider bringing in Chesser over Sharp? I can see us pumping far more games into Chesser than Sharp will get. Need a cheap rookie this week and already have Drury.

No, I’m thinking about it.

 

[Axly]

Defs not Steele, retuning from injury, might have injured his knee, not scoring that well

Then you need to decide if you want a MID or FWD premo

If FWD, then it's Butters

If MID, then either would be good. Pies have Norf and Eagles after the Blues, should be a couple of big scores for JDG. Just assess the byes and choose? JDG might hurt your rd14 bye.

Didn't get Butters in

 

[SC fish]

Didn't get Butters in

Neither did I. Shoulda, coulda, woulda, didn't

 

[PoopingHindi]

N. Anderson vs. C. Serong vs. L. Neale

I'm thinking with the byes in mind. Who would you take out of those three, also noting that cash generation has been an on-going issues to saving money (avoiding Anderson) could be the wise thing to do.

Any advice?

not Neale. If you’re hunting for value then wait till he’s cheaper.
of the other 2 I’d take Serong. he’s cheaper, more consistent and is less likely to be tagged.

 

[SC fish]

Ryan or Ratugolea on field today? Can't loop them

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Ryan or Ratugolea on field today? Can't loop them

Jack Henry is back Rat will play a lockdown role

 

[PoopingHindi]

Ryan or Ratugolea on field today? Can't loop them

that’s a tough one. Nank is back and Freo have no decent marking forwards so probably Esava.
not confident on it at all though.

 

[TyCrane]

Sharp or Drury?

 

[SC fish]

Sharp or Drury?

I ended up going Sharp.

 

[SC fish]

that’s a tough one. Nank is back and Freo have no decent marking forwards so probably Esava.
not confident on it at all though.

Yep that's my thinking too

 

[YellowAndBlack83]

Degoey v Rowell?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Degoey v Rowell?

Doubt there is much in it. Rowell has the better bye though.

Do you enjoy cheering for dickheads? Or magnificent grass-fed bulls?

 

[Kedford]

Merrett vs Gulden (probably can’t get the other one for a while too)

 

[pieman123]

Is Walsh worth the extra $$ over Merrett?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Merrett vs Gulden (probably can’t get the other one for a while too)

You can't go wrong with either, Merrett is safer but Gulden is more appealing to me

 

[toxic]

Is Walsh worth the extra $$ over Merrett?

Nope

 

[Scythe94]

Is Walsh worth the extra $$ over Merrett?

Not with his role changing from week to week. Merrett's bye is better, too

 

[No eye deer]

Play Atkins in mids and bench Weddle in defense, leaving me no mid cover if there’s a late out, or bench Atkins for cover and play Weddle on the ground?