Position 2023 Rookies

[Makeshift Park]

Because Charlie Comben will be struggling to get selected next week and has poor JS.

At this point you have to be related to him to think otherwise as he was absolute garbage on Saturday putting Goldy forward ahead of him and Zurhaar back in the week later giving him at best 1 maybe 2 weeks

At the moment you’re professing to have some expertise over Norths forward line arrangements because you watched Comben have a single bad game. That’s the single point of reference you’ve cited repeatedly.

How about you go and find me a north supporter who thinks Comben is likely to lose his spot in the first month. Go on, I’ll wait.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

At the moment you’re professing to have some expertise over Norths forward line arrangements because you watched Comben have a single bad game. That’s the single point of reference you’ve cited repeatedly.

How about you go and find me a north supporter who thinks Comben is likely to lose his spot in the first month. Go on, I’ll wait.

North supporters don't pick the team though do they?

Comben isn't going to be SC relevant anyway, regardless of how good his JS (and I'm happy to say he has good JS).

More interested in Sheezel. Is Clarko going to put him around the ball like on the weekend if he's catching a cold up forward? Makes him a much better SC prospect in that case.

 

[faible]

At the moment you’re professing to have some expertise over Norths forward line arrangements because you watched Comben have a single bad game. That’s the single point of reference you’ve cited repeatedly.

How about you go and find me a north supporter who thinks Comben is likely to lose his spot in the first month. Go on, I’ll wait.

Given the way he scores he'll need more than 4 games to justify being in our SC sides. He'd had to have job security for at least half a season to be a chance of making any worthwhile cash.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Given the way he scores he'll need more than 4 games to justify being in our SC sides. He'd had to have job security for at least half a season to be a chance of making any worthwhile cash.

You don't have to tell me, I haven't selected him.

I've just been talking about his job security.

More interested in Sheezel. Is Clarko going to put him around the ball like on the weekend if he's catching a cold up forward? Makes him a much better SC prospect in that case.

Its a bit of a hot topic on the North forum atm.

Who knows. If the PS games are anything to go by, he'll be split around 50/50 between forward and back.

Suffice to say our ball movement was a hell of a lot better when he was doing distribution from the back half.

 

[faible]

You don't have to tell me, I haven't selected him.

I've just been talking about his job security.



Its a bit of a hot topic on the North forum atm.

Who knows. If the PS games are anything to go by, he'll be split around 50/50 between forward and back.

Suffice to say our ball movement was a hell of a lot better when he was doing distribution from the back half.

Hopefully Clarko gives the crowd what we want, Sheezel seagulling off a HBF.

 

[Foxman98]

At the moment you’re professing to have some expertise over Norths forward line arrangements because you watched Comben have a single bad game. That’s the single point of reference you’ve cited repeatedly.

How about you go and find me a north supporter who thinks Comben is likely to lose his spot in the first month. Go on, I’ll wait.

Go find me a Bulldogs supporter who thinks West shouldn't be be in the team then go look at the teams selected Fans opinions are irrelevant

 

[Makeshift Park]

Go find me a Bulldogs supporter who thinks West shouldn't be be in the team then go look at the teams selected Fans opinions are irrelevant

Its not that hard for the average supporter to separate their own preferences from their expectations of what the selection panel will do.

Look at Ziebell. There are SFA North supporters who think he's best 22. But just about everyone acknowledges he's going to be selected round 1 anyway.

You're basically saying there's no point in sourcing supporters' knowledge of their own clubs to inform these discussions, and that leads me to think you're just being vexatious at this point.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Its not that hard for the average supporter to separate their own preferences from their expectations of what the selection panel will do.

Look at Ziebell. There are SFA North supporters who think he's best 22. But just about everyone acknowledges he's going to be selected round 1 anyway.

You're basically saying there's no point in sourcing supporters' knowledge of their own clubs to inform these discussions, and that leads me to think you're just being vexatious at this point.

Guys (Foxman98 ) think we've laboured enough on this discussion point ....it's venturing off to areas, not SuperCoach related

Can we please move on and discuss the merits of Lukey Pedlar

 

[Petrify]

Bloody rookies are stressing me out. Really comfortable with my team but only $300 cash spare and not confident we get enough 124k or less rookies round 1

 

[Mofra]

Because Charlie Comben will be struggling to get selected next week and has poor JS.

Disagree - who else is there?
He kicked a couple of goals the week before too. I suspect he gets a bit of time to gel with Larkey, while a resting ruck provides tall support too.

I think the kid has talent but isn't SC relevant this year as being a young no 2 KPD in a developing side doesn't bode well for making much cash.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I think the kid has talent but isn't SC relevant this year as being a young no 2 KPD in a developing side doesn't bode well for making much cash.

This summarizes the story with Comben perfectly

 

[pincrusher]

Guys (Foxman98 ) think we've laboured enough on this discussion point ....it's venturing off to areas, not SuperCoach related

Can we please move on and discuss the merits of Lukey (Relton MkII) Pedlar

Much better.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Go find me a Bulldogs supporter who thinks West shouldn't be be in the team then go look at the teams selected Fans opinions are irrelevant

 

[TempletonTheRat]

cant believe we just had 2 pages discussing a Norfie Spud

perhaps I should have listened to Uncle Jiska and created a separate category for SC irrelevant players

 

[Exambolor]

This raises Tylar Young’s chances of playing next week. We might have another $102ker

 

[blackshadow]

This raises Tylar Young’s chances of playing next week. We might have another $102ker


View attachment 1624279

How many weeks is sort term?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

How many weeks is sort term?

Probably enough for one price rise then dropped forever.

Richmond's oldies do seem to get a few injuries though, so fingers crossed.

 

[Suma Magic]

An update to the table I posted a few pages back. Again, any feedback on my guesses of average and JS are welcome.



Please note: this post does not constitute financial advice. All numbers are made up and are likely to be wildly inaccurate.

 

[MrChristo]

I'd love to believe a couple of those!

I really want to move Green to D4, but have very little faith in anyone (bar G&T-bey) sub $200k in defence to make it work.

Fwiw, I don't think Cole can top 60, and I think you've overrated McKenna's js.

(Not a knock on you, I love the table as a whole).

 

[Significant]

Can't wait for Comben to knock out two 70s and everyone to jump on :/

 

[Suma Magic]

I did increase Comben’s JS…

 

[Rayzorwire]

Probably enough for one price rise then dropped forever.

Richmond's oldies do seem to get a few injuries though, so fingers crossed.

Between the question mark over Tarrant and also how Miller will get used with him out - KPD, back-up ruck or not at all - it's pretty difficult to predict Young's even short term JS.

Biggie will be in that selection mix over the season too you'd suspect.

All up, low JS beyond short term barring injuries to key players.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Between the question mark over Tarrant and also how Miller will get used with him out - KPD, back-up ruck or not at all - it's pretty difficult to predict Young's even short term JS.

Biggie will be in that selection mix over the season too you'd suspect.

All up, low JS beyond short term barring injuries to key players.

Yeah he's one you wait for the bubble and assess it then.

 

[Biggie]

Biggie will be in that selection mix over the season too you'd suspect.

 

[Rayzorwire]

Set to be the live televised debutant phone call of the season!