Brownlow 2024 Brownlow Medal Count - Congrats Patrick Cripps!

Who wins the 24 Chas?


  • Total voters
    70
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

One day I’d like them to be honest

“When did you think you were a chance to win the Brownlow”
“Well about mid year. Walshy was playing like crap, Cerra couldn’t kick the ball more then 30m and McKay/Curnlw were showing they had the consistency of burnt custard”


If they were honest they would say , Hamish can you get out of the way this is boring, I want to say a few words and get on the piss.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Just bite the bullet, rename the Brownlow to the Midfielders award, come up with an award for defenders, and be done with it

Going to be issues with any system but have the coaches votes decide it. Would be better than this shit show
 
It’s turned into such a terrible award now. I remember growing up and any position player could win it from any side. Now there are probably 20 players who have a realistic chance of winning a Brownlow at the start of each season.
AA is also losing its meaning. small defenders (who can actually defend) are overlooked for the best unaccountable back flanker with 25+ touches a game and forward flankers are left out for mids not good enough for mid spots. Small forwards get maybe 1 spot to accommodate a 3rd key forward and ALL bench spots are also mids not good enough for mid spots.

Wingmen are rarely recognised too.
 
Not sure the result can be questioned, vote tallies ****ed all around, but Cripps had a great year

Feels like all the guns were scaled up 150%. Guys getting mid/high 20s and we’re never in it!
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Well done Crippa. Grim reading for the rest of Carlton's list.

Big time. He 100% carried us this year. He wanted success so badly.
 
lol now Sam Walsh?

Yeah that’s more than enough for tonight.
 
Feels like all the guns were scaled up 150%. Guys getting mid/high 20s and we’re never in it!


not as many randoms polling a vote or two here and there
 
Anyone think of another pointless interview we can squeeze in?

Ooh, ooh! How about Sam Walsh.
 
Good reflection of where things are at.

Cripps is the best player in the league and it is not even close.
Bont has Libba and Treloar taking votes off him. Guys like Dale and Richards can take votes off him too Cripps has Walsh and who else? Curnow?. It's not even close to a reflection of the best player in the league. Cripps is very very good but he's not 26 votes better than Bont. Dogs were much more even across the board bit like us. We had votes spread out a bit too.
 
We all know the format is cooked, the reality is if this event wasn’t televised nobody would really care.

They need to come up with another system that doesn’t become so focussed on a narrative.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Brownlow 2024 Brownlow Medal Count - Congrats Patrick Cripps!

Back
Top