Toast 2024 Doig Medal - 18/09/2024 @7pm AWST - Live Stream Available.

Remove this Banner Ad

Can someone explain something
The voting system is 4 coaches award each player a mark out of 5 for how they performed their role. Maximum of 20 per game

Serong got 240 votes which is just above 10 votes per game
coaches must be hard markers
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Can someone explain something
The voting system is 4 coaches award each player a mark out of 5 for how they performed their role. Maximum of 20 per game

Serong got 240 votes which is just above 10 votes per game
coaches must be hard markers
They are. The scale is insane. 1 is adequately performing your role, and 2 is something like a strong performance, with 3 already requiring a dominant performance. The next two levels are above dominant!! Think there's only been 2 games over the last 6 or so years that have got perfect votes. One of them was Fyfe, the other was Walters getting 30+ and kicking 6.
 
They are. The scale is insane. 1 is adequately performing your role, and 2 is something like a strong performance, with 3 already requiring a dominant performance. The next two levels are above dominant!! Think there's only been 2 games over the last 6 or so years that have got perfect votes. One of them was Fyfe, the other was Walters getting 30+ and kicking 6.
Okay, I maybe slightly overstated it, but anything above 3 votes from a coach is pretty rare. This is how it was explained in 2015 (when they had 5 coaches voting):

Doig Medal voting criteria:

Following each match, the five club coaches give each player a vote from zero to five based on the player’s performance.

5 votes – Outstanding – elite performance
4 votes – Excellent – exceptional influence on the match
3 votes – Very good – strong contribution that influenced the match
2 votes – Good – fulfilled the role and made a solid contribution
1 vote – Fair – fulfilled the role asked
0 votes
 
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #86

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad

Toast 2024 Doig Medal - 18/09/2024 @7pm AWST - Live Stream Available.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top