List Mgmt. 2024 Draft - Post Trade Period Edition

[djspank]

North Melbourne won't be trading its F1st.

Please stop asking.

Thank you.

Keep your Fist to yourself you deviant

 

[sydney_gws]

Next time tag Dan the delusional kangaroos man

Perhaps if you trade 11,f2 for 15,16 with gws, then trade 10,15,16 for 2,f2 with North.
That is effectively 2 for 10,11 for tigers.

 

[tiger_tough]

Perhaps if you trade 11,f2 for 15,16 with gws, then trade 10,15,16 for 2,f2 with North.
That is effectively 2 for 10,11 for tigers.

I dont see us giving up 10 and 11. We'll want to keep one of them (to go with 1, 2 and 6).

If we can't get it done without keeping 6 and one of 10 and 11, I doubt we do any deal at all for 2.

 

[prodigy]

Perhaps if you trade 11,f2 for 15,16 with gws, then trade 10,15,16 for 2,f2 with North.
That is effectively 2 for 10,11 for tigers.

If you said 10, 15, 16 for 2 and F1 from North you might be onto something.

However, like tiger_tough said, I'm not sure if we are willing to let go of both 10 and 11 as I think we want at least one pick between 10 and 15.

On the other hand, having 1, 2 and 6 plus North's F1 is compelling.
I'd rather lose 18 and 23 instead of 10.
It's all quite complicated though.

 

[Mr Magic]

How can you say this? Shai went at pick 29.
No one knows what Hotton will develop into. Stop writing off or putting a ceiling on kids before they've even set foot in an AFL environment.

I am not talking about his prospects, I am just saying he does not play like Shai.

How can he he has different physique?

that is not even going into personality and other aspects of his footy performance

 

[Smoocher]

Saints give 8 to GWS
GWS give 15,16 to Saints.
Saints give 7 & 16 to North.
North give pick 2 to Saints.
Rich give North pick 11 &20 for F1 and 16.

Tigers get to keep the Valued pick 6 as well as gain a F1 and 16 for giving up 11,20
Tigers still have 23 and 24 to trade out for more F1 if they like.

Saints have 2,15.
GWS have 8,21
North have 7,11,20
Tigers end up with 1,6,10,16,18,23,24 and a F1 (likely top 4 pick).

North happy as they get Tauru as Tigers will definitely go for Mid at 6.



Sent from my CPH2197 using Tapatalk

 

[Mr Magic]

Saints give 8 to GWS
GWS give 15,16 to Saints.
Saints give 7 & 16 to North.
North give pick 2 to Saints.
Rich give North pick 11 &20 for F1 and 16.

Tigers get to keep the Valued pick 6 as well as gain a F1 and 16 for giving up 11,20
Tigers still have 23 and 24 to trade out for more F1 if they like.

Saints have 2,15.
GWS have 8,21
North have 7,11,20
Tigers end up with 1,6,10,16,18,23,24 and a F1 (likely top 4 pick).

North happy as they get Tauru as Tigers will definitely go for Mid at 6.



Sent from my CPH2197 using Tapatalk

why are RFC trading 11 and 20 for 16 and a future first again??? I did not ask for it again

 

[KrispyKreme]

Saints give 8 to GWS
GWS give 15,16 to Saints.
Saints give 7 & 16 to North.
North give pick 2 to Saints.
Rich give North pick 11 &20 for F1 and 16.

Tigers get to keep the Valued pick 6 as well as gain a F1 and 16 for giving up 11,20
Tigers still have 23 and 24 to trade out for more F1 if they like.

Saints have 2,15.
GWS have 8,21
North have 7,11,20
Tigers end up with 1,6,10,16,18,23,24 and a F1 (likely top 4 pick).

North happy as they get Tauru as Tigers will definitely go for Mid at 6.



Sent from my CPH2197 using Tapatalk

That’s enough Bigfooty for me today

 

[Azzleberry]

Same as pick 2, right? Your club is bloody desperate to get back into the first round of this draft, Rawlings has put your club in a horrendous position. Watch and cringe bud, you’ll sell the farm to buy back in

The difference between Rawlings and Blair's skillsets are huge.

Rawlings a much better footballer than a list manager and that's not a compliment

 

[richoatthedisco]

Saints give 8 to GWS
GWS give 15,16 to Saints.
Saints give 7 & 16 to North.
North give pick 2 to Saints.
Rich give North pick 11 &20 for F1 and 16.

Tigers get to keep the Valued pick 6 as well as gain a F1 and 16 for giving up 11,20
Tigers still have 23 and 24 to trade out for more F1 if they like.

Saints have 2,15.
GWS have 8,21
North have 7,11,20
Tigers end up with 1,6,10,16,18,23,24 and a F1 (likely top 4 pick).

North happy as they get Tauru as Tigers will definitely go for Mid at 6.



Sent from my CPH2197 using Tapatalk

Hahahahahahahahaha****off!

 

[THE_GUN]

.

Saints give 8 to GWS
GWS give 15,16 to Saints.
Saints give 7 & 16 to North.
North give pick 2 to Saints.
Rich give North pick 11 &20 for F1 and 16.

Or Richmond just say - Nah
Here is #20 for your F1

 

[Lord of the Wings]

North Melbourne won't be trading its F1st.

Please stop asking.

Thank you.

Can someone ban this dhead

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Perhaps if you trade 11,f2 for 15,16 with gws, then trade 10,15,16 for 2,f2 with North.
That is effectively 2 for 10,11 for tigers.

Stick to rugby

 

[sregit]

BS. They gave up a F1+. Don't be a points nuff.

Talk that points don’t count is rubbish. Obviously to trade up you need to give up picks, which equate to points. Yes you need to pay overs but Richmond gave away more picks/points deficit ever recorded for that pick. I know Richmond had many late picks but they still have value. Pick 32 included in that trade was unnecessary. Brisbane had no other team that would give them anywhere near the points they needed. If Richmond does not bid on Ashcroft the Lions save 600 points + we gave them picks that amount to 1800. So in all likelihood we have given them 2400 points for 900.

As for late picks not being used that’s crap and you’re the nuffy if you think that was a good deal. I’m not just a points person but the value we gave up was ridiculous. Brisbane would have been forced into deficit in 2025 and not had the points for Marshall but we’ve gifted it to them.

All the work trading back for late future picks in 2023 was Flushed down the toilet. Just because we are loaded with draft capital doesn’t mean we should be careless and take the attitude that we don’t really need it.

 

[richoatthedisco]

Shut the **** up

 

[THE_GUN]

Talk that points don’t count is rubbish. Obviously to trade up you need to give up picks, which equate to points. Yes you need to pay overs but Richmond gave away more picks/points deficit ever recorded for that pick. I know Richmond had many late picks but they still have value. Pick 32 included in that trade was unnecessary. Brisbane had no other team that would give them anywhere near the points they needed.cause we are loaded with draft capital doesn’t mean we should be careless and take the attitude that we don’t really need it.

You are really making things up here
Melbourne were also in the race to get pick #20 with the points they gave up 1657 points for the St Kilda trade but without the F1.

The only thing we could offer was the extra pick to beat the points Melbourne offered
And the " Threat of the bid" which is a dream BF members think is real

 

[tigerdan]

What's weird is talking of giving 10 to Port as part of the trade for 2.

When you slice and dice it, 11 presumably has to go to North so why not just give 10 & 11 to them and be done with it.

It's not like we need pick 29, and North are hardly going to agree to 11 and 13 when it could be 10 and 11. I mean it would be a hard enough sell to convince Port to swap 13, & 29 for 10 on its own anyway.

 

[Bird Man]

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Regardless…shifter loves then all equally

Shifter doesn't like Richmond.

 

[BAFLD]

I dont see us giving up 10 and 11. We'll want to keep one of them (to go with 1, 2 and 6).

If we can't get it done without keeping 6 and one of 10 and 11, I doubt we do any deal at all for 2.

I agree. Ideally if we move upto 2 we are trying to keep 6 as well.

 

[dean33]

Trade our 1 pick for Stkilda's 7 and 8 or Melbourne's 5 and 9 , Trade our picks 10 , 11 and to North for pick 2.
Then we have picks 2, 6, 7, 8 , 18, 20, 23, 24 or
Picks 2, 5, 6 ,9, 18, 20, 23 ,24

And watch Melbourne or saints pick Lalor or FOS with 1?

 

[dean33]

I agree. Ideally if we move upto 2 we are trying to keep 6 as well.

North won’t trade 2 unless 6 is involved unfortunately.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Long time listener, first time caller and big Lalor fan

For those more educated than myself does Lalors hammy injury cool the jets on wanting to take the punt on him or is his ceiling that high it’s just worth taking the stab with pick 1

Wouldn’t taking FOS who also looks to have a very heigh ceiling be the better option for pick one that still carry’s a degree of risk but without that soft tissue storm cloud lingering

 

[dean33]

Long time listener, first time caller and big Lalor fan

For those more educated than myself does Lalors hammy injury cool the jets on wanting to take the punt on him or is his ceiling that high it’s just worth taking the stab with pick 1

Wouldn’t taking FOS who also looks to have a very heigh ceiling be the better option for pick one that still carry’s a degree of risk but without that soft tissue storm cloud lingering

I remember Judd didn’t go 1 due to concerns on his shoulder. I think you pick your highest rated player regardless of any injury concerns. They are 18, plenty of time to sort their bodies out in a good high performance program.

 

[Nostradumbass]

Shifter doesn't like Richmond.