Game Day 2024 Fantasy Round 18 Discussion - Carnage !!

[Jay-Z]

Was tossing up between J Cameron and Mannagh pre match, ended up stuck on Cameron because I lost track of time.

I paid 420k for 2 points!

 

[Tso1967]

HELP needed.

I've got Humphries as my mid emergency. I'll take the 105 but not sure which mid to take out. Dawson/Serong/Butters/T.Green. which one!

Serong or Green

 

[danster168]

Serong or Green

Dawson playing forward annoys me. But yeah. thanks for your vote, I'll factor it in.

 

[Balsam]

Not that it matters much as both are spuds but Harrison or Krueger for emergency?

Harrison has a higher ceiling if he can kick a bag. Krueger has a higher floor with his role as 2nd ruck.

I had Harrison, Richards and Kreuger last week... chose to field Richards for 34 vs 73 and 60 for the other two.

This week I fielded Kreuger vs 36 and 54, so only missed out on 8 points...

 

[One Dimensional]

Bench Young, Ryan, Clark or Martin for Humphries?

 

[Tso1967]

190/2
Naicos and Humphries E

SAT-
Moore, Ryan, Clark, Young, Serong, Jackson
Gulden, Papley, Sheezel, Xerri
Bont VC
Schoenmaker
Zerrett, Martin, Caldwell

 

[danster168]

Can loop Humphries 105 onfield but only in the mids...

Like who am i meant to choose.. Could as easily just lose points.

View attachment 2046368

Serong or Green I reckon. I'm leaning towards Dawson though

 

[danster168]

Bench Young, Ryan, Clark or Martin for Humphries?

Young or Ryan. I'd probably bench Ryan. He's not getting the switch kicks anymore.

 

[DukeX]

I can loop Humphries' score by benching Day and putting Garcia on field.
Considering Day's 110 BE, am I better off trading him out this week instead of Sexton (for no loss), and trading him for a replacement mid next week?

 

[Shaunn]

Serong or Green I reckon. I'm leaning towards Dawson though

Yeah was leaning Serong, but its just as likely he punishes us and goes massive haha.

 

[JADED]

Easy call benching the erratic Oliver to take LawTOn Humphries.

 

[Pure Grunt]

I can loop Humphries' score by benching Day and putting Garcia on field.
Considering Day's 110 BE, am I better off trading him out this week instead of Sexton (for no loss), and trading him for a replacement mid next week?

Trade Day and take the loop if you can.

 

[Shaunn]

Easy call benching the erratic Oliver to take LawTOn Humphries.

Kissed for having a shit mid (i wish i had Oliver now)

 

[Pure Grunt]

Humphrey @ D6 in loop with Shoenmaker is easy decision

 

[Pure Grunt]

Super Saturday
Bont, Clark, Martin
Gulden, Merrett, Young
Rozee, Xerri, English
Flanders, Simpkin, Caldwell, McKay
Graham, Freijah, Reville, Tholstrup all looped.

 

[Penski]

Kissed for having a shit mid (i wish i had Oliver now)

I have to take Humphries' 105 for someone in the mids. I'm thinking it has to be Dawson.

I have Gulden, Bont, Walsh, Zerrett, Dawson, Serong, Steele, Rozee as my mids.

 

[Nunez]

Thinking I'll bench LDU and take Humphies' 105. Any argument to bench Green over LDU or is it as straightforward as it feels?

 

[bettingonbetts]

HELP needed.

I've got Humphries as my mid emergency. I'll take the 105 but not sure which mid to take out. Dawson/Serong/Butters/T.Green. which one!

Green with the potential of Graham going to him perhaps?
I think Dawson bounces back

 

[bettingonbetts]

Are we fielding Dowling or Tholstrop? I feel like Dowling enjoys it at home and showed more signs last week, but Tholstrop seems to get it done every week

 

[mockingbeat]

Good lad Dempsey.

 

[One Dimensional]

Tossing up between bringing in Whitfield, benching Young and taking Humphries score (which also means starting Dowling)

Other option is fading Whitfield for one more week which means I play Young (take Humphries score) and trade Dowling to Moore.

Essentially who scores more:

Dowling and Whitfield
Or
Moore and Young?

 

[Exambolor]

1/85

Went Naicos VC, first time in a while and unfortunate its a burnt one lol, so makes a C pick a tough one as there's a heap of options

Super Saturday of course and a nice even player count in each

Clark, Young, Connor Mac
Errol, Chad, Lizard
Treloar, English, McKay
Dawson, RoMa, Wood
Rivers, Koltyn, Kozzy

 

[Yellow Feathers]

Your mother walking in mid fap is nowhere near as awkward as having Lawson as mid E, benching Serong to take it, and having to keep Crisp’s score on field.

 

[happyCrowie]

Are we fielding Dowling or Tholstrop? I feel like Dowling enjoys it at home and showed more signs last week, but Tholstrop seems to get it done every week

.... why not both!

 

[kozi]

Got Evans, Schoenmaker, Dowling and Mannagh..

Humphries the one I had to miss and he’s the best one ffs