![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/sydney.png)
JackHiscoxWasFast
Club Legend
- Nov 30, 2023
- 2,251
- 3,457
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Love your optimism and hope you’re right.Jmac Back running
Good signs
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Love your optimism and hope you’re right.Jmac Back running
Good signs
He was favouring a leg pre match SaturdayLove your optimism and hope you’re right.
Yeah - I heard the same and that he was a remote chance of returning this year. But I heard Paps for sure would be back. Is that your mail ?He was favouring a leg pre match Saturday
Yes ive been consistent about it , if we win this week he's back for the finalsYeah - I heard the same and that he was a remote chance of returning this year. But I heard Paps for sure would be back. Is that your mail ?
Have You also heard that Jmac is a remote chance of returning this year ?Yes ive been consistent about it , if we win this week he's back for the finals
PLAYER | INJURY | ESTIMATED RETURN | LAST WEEK'S UPDATE |
---|---|---|---|
Jacob Konstanty | Foot | 2-3 weeks | TBC |
Justin McInerney | Knee | 2-3 weeks | 3-4 weeks |
Tom Papley | Ankle | 1-2 weeks | 2-3 weeks |
Broke his leg in the reserves game on Friday.Will Edwards "leg" season. You'd think they could at least give some idea of what's wrong.
Sent from my Pixel 8 Pro using Tapatalk
If he's fit enough, we will play him - whether that's right or wrong remains to be seen - but based on historical evidence, if Horse think he's good to go, he will pick him.As much as i love JMac if hes not back for the QF, he doesn't get to play any further finals games
Horse has to stick with known quantities
It's an interesting one because generally speaking I agree with this, but McInerney isn't really comparable to a Mills or Reid, because of how damaging he can be on the outside.No doubt Jmac is an A grader but we’ve been bitten playing injured or underdone players in finals
And hes recovering from a pcl
Anyone know anything more about this injury? Rotten luck for the lad.Broke his leg in the reserves game on Friday.
Only what the club released in Tuesday's report: Will suffered a broken leg against Collingwood in the VFL. He will have surgery this week and will miss the remainder of the season.Anyone know anything more about this injury? Rotten luck for the lad.
Sent from my Pixel 8 Pro using Tapatalk
No doubt Jmac is an A grader but we’ve been bitten playing injured or underdone players in finals
And hes recovering from a pcl
It's a 23 round season and players go into the finals with all sorts of niggles. Rarely is anyone at 100%. It's a matter of assessing how far from 100% they are, how valuable they are to the team and how they compare to the player who'd be coming into the team for them.
We've definitely made some bad calls in the past, but it's not realistic to think we're only going to be picking players who are cherry ripe.
The only problem with that thinking is that we nearly won the 2016 GF... some iffy decisions go our way and we romp that in! Mills and Macca did not cause that loss...Getting Mills and Macca 2016 GF vibes with rushing JMac back and I htink Jmac is >>>> than both of them
Didn't help thoughThe only problem with that thinking is that we nearly won the 2016 GF... some iffy decisions go our way and we romp that in! Mills and Macca did not cause that loss...
The only problem with that thinking is that we nearly won the 2016 GF... some iffy decisions go our way and we romp that in! Mills and Macca did not cause that loss...
Add Chad (calf) and Robbie (kidney) to the injury list
Touch wood Chad is OK for Adelaide next week, Robbie for 1st final![]()
Horses words were out this week. Hopefully it's just a precautionary week offSo it was kidney blow - I saw him struggling with what I thought was a lower back injury - I hope its not ruptured.
Too many loose fukn knees in todays footy
A knee between the shoulder blades is a WORLD away from a knee at L5. Those ***** at the AFL need to wake up to this.
So it was kidney blow - I saw him struggling with what I thought was a lower back injury - I hope its not ruptured.
Too many loose fukn knees in todays footy
A knee between the shoulder blades is a WORLD away from a knee at L5. Those ***** at the AFL need to wake up to this.