Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Exactly. It's little things like the announcement they're being signed and guernsey presentations that have a big impact. However, the club is good in this regard so they'll have a plan. There may be merit holding off on any signatures until after the intraclub.You would imagine so.
Surely they have a decent idea by now, and shouldn't deprive the players from recieving their new jumpers in front of family.
We'll find out one way another in the next 48hrs imoExactly. It's little things like the announcement they're being signed and guernsey presentations that have a big impact. However, the club is good in this regard so they'll have a plan. There may be merit holding off on any signatures until after the intraclub.
Aka schmiddi18Alas, it's kindasmok
He was ready at the end of last year. Very end. If you put in three or four goal performances and have more than fifteen disposals, you're a strong contender.
AJ's game needs to improve around the ball and Reef can do that.
My bold call is that AJ asks for a trade at the end of the season to Melbourne (before the ridiculous calls, I don't think we Taylor leaving for Sydney on our bingo cards).
Why should Reef become a mid? He is clearly excelling as a forward. Play him there, let him star. Not everyone can be a mid, even if they want to be one. We have ample of star young midfielders who are better than Reef in Macrae, Allan, likely an SSP.Given Reef is allegedly still pencilled in to eventually become a mid, I think Ash can still stake a claim.
They're both very different forwards and pre-season form doesn't always translate to season proper form.
Ash at least has some runs on the board in that sense. Reef may earn a Round 1 call up based on pre-season form, but that doesn't mean he holds his spot because if I recall correctly, Reef played a few really solid games as the sub (even with Ash in the side) but just couldn't get it going on the few occasions he played full games.
So we'll see I guess. Given Ash just re-signed fairly recently, I'm assuming he's gonna stick it out
I don’t think I wrote off Hogan so much as stated that there’s no way in hell he’d ever return to a football state. Being out of the limelight at GWS has done wonders for him and I don’t think we’d have got that from him at Collingwood.Did I really talk Callow up that much? I must have been desperate for a KF back them. Don't forget though because you wrote off Hogan, coniglio, Ben Brown and a host of others that have gone on and played some brilliant football but you had them cooked. There are others that you wrote off and have since become regular AFL playes but that would just be mean by me if I dug up all your write offs.
Reef has traits that suit both forward and midfield and he’s being trained accordingly, he’s definitely spent some time training with mids this preseason in addition to his forward work. He also had a few really dominant games playing mid as a junior in the very small window of opportunities he had.Why should Reef become a mid? He is clearly excelling as a forward. Play him there, let him star. Not everyone can be a mid, even if they want to be one. We have ample of star young midfielders who are better than Reef in Macrae, Allan, likely an SSP.
You're right that the sides may change but I still see Reef holding and if Kreuger stays on the park, even could be considered. When not on the pine, he is a strong forward.
Yeah you did but we all make mistakes. Don't stress, I still value your footy knowledgeI don’t think I wrote off Hogan so much as stated that there’s no way in hell he’d ever return to a football state. Being out of the limelight at GWS has done wonders for him and I don’t think we’d have got that from him at Collingwood.
Brown had 1 ok year at Melbourne and since then has been injured or playing VFL, so not sure how I was wrong there. Did I write off Coniglio or say he wasn’t worth the horrendous contract? Can’t remember.
That’s a good shout and for some it’s worth remembering that JDG was the same age when he broke out in 2018. We also aren’t that far removed from some calling for JDG to remain a full time forward (we were still getting it late in Buckley’s tenure). None of that is to say Reef can hold a candle to JDG as a player at any point of their respective careers, but rather on that specific career path the comparison stacks up.Reef has traits that suit both forward and midfield and he’s being trained accordingly, he’s definitely spent some time training with mids this preseason in addition to his forward work. He also had a few really dominant games playing mid as a junior in the very small window of opportunities he had.
It’s likely at this point he follows a JDG trajectory of forward>forward mid>mid forward. Whether he ever gets to the full time mid point that Jordy has reached is up for debate, but I don’t think there’s much doubt that the club sees him as a dual positional player in the long term.
No point in Murph playing any praccy games or anything where he could get hit again. Better off giving dean a crack to show us what he can do.I wonder if with Murphy they're treating his incident at training like a concussion and taking precautions given his history?
Why should Reef become a mid? He is clearly excelling as a forward. Play him there, let him star. Not everyone can be a mid, even if they want to be one. We have ample of star young midfielders who are better than Reef in Macrae, Allan, likely an SSP.
You're right that the sides may change but I still see Reef holding and if Kreuger stays on the park, even could be considered. When not on the pine, he is a strong forward.
Bucks said so himself on SEN the other day. Pretty much those words.Unless I'm misremembering, Reef was recruited as a tall mid and was being worked on to end up there at some point.
A lot of people talked up Callow and he didn't go undrafted for talent reasons. His final few games for Norwood were good and if keeps that up, he could return to the AFL system.Did I really talk Callow up that much? I must have been desperate for a KF back them. Don't forget though because you wrote off Hogan, coniglio, Ben Brown and a host of others that have gone on and played some brilliant football but you had them cooked. There are others that you wrote off and have since become regular AFL playes but that would just be mean by me if I dug up all your write offs.
Darcy was drafted as a forward, Howe was recruited as a forward, Mihcoek a defender.Unless I'm misremembering, Reef was recruited as a tall mid and was being worked on to end up there at some point.
Yeah, I don't know about Moore anymore...I could be Eyre and Moore the way it's going
So there WERE two texters...The message "you're not being listed" came from some guy up on the grassy knoll, was hard to spot because he sent it via text message.
Balconygate set to the be the topic of the next club statement. Eyre caught speaking with two sus guys.So there WERE two texters...
I think I'm misreadingUnless I'm misremembering.......
Hmmmmm...Balconygate set to the be the topic of the next club statement. Eyre caught speaking with two sus guys.
It will have its own thread - Nathan Freeman look outBalconygate set to the be the topic of the next club statement. Eyre caught speaking with two sus guys.
What's promising about being out for 6-8 weeks?On Harry, I have some promising news - he'll be out for about six to eight weeks but complete substantial running in this time. Should be a positive for us.
He was up there with different people. Leppa. Some guy in this cap. Not sure who that is. And dekka was there too. Also, if that bent knee is the hammy he injured, wouldn’t bending it like that cause pain?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk