Preview 2025 Best 22 Discussion

[bushchook]

If Freddy is over looked because of a quiet 2024, who do you replace him with?

Narkle or Simpson will both be gunning for his spot

 

[go_the_dockers]

Narkle or Simpson will both be gunning for his spot

We said no to Narkle.

If Freddy is over looked because of a quiet 2024, who do you replace him with? set shots and speed on the ball going forward he's pretty elite. His defensive pressure dropped off a bit this year and hes not taking marks or crumbing well but that speed going forward with Shai on the other side is going to scare a lot of teams

I would wait until after the draft.

Someone like Joe Berry would but pressure on him.

 

[FreoRicci]

Given I've been so critical of Freddy's 2024 season, and also acknowledging he's not a high stats player, I thought I might check some anyway.

Ave disposals - 26th in team
Effective disposals - 26th
Disposal efficiency - 31st
Ave tackles - =24th
Ave tackles inside 50 - 10th (behind Voss, Amiss, Tabs, Walters, Treacy and others.
Goal assists Ave - 9th
Score involvements Ave - 13th!
Supercoach - 25th
Dream team - 25th

I'm sticking with my opinion that he's borderline best 22. This is a guy who finished top 10 in the Doig in 2023. Needs to be better in 2025 or find a new position because I think I'd favour Bolton and Sturt.


On Pixel 7 using BigFooty.com mobile app

Losing Schulz was a major blow for the pressure types. Hopefully with Shai in, Frederick can have a career best season

 

[FreoRicci]

We said no to Narkle.



I would wait until after the draft.

Someone like Joe Berry would but pressure on him.

No to Narkle?
That would be dumb when the club has delisted Emmett

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

We said no to Narkle.



I would wait until after the draft.

Someone like Joe Berry would but pressure on him.