Preview 2nd Elimination Final, 2023: St.Kilda v GWS - MCG, Saturday 9th September, 3:20PM AEST *WEBSTER 150TH* *BATTLE 100TH*

Who Wins?

  • Saints

    Votes: 85 86.7%
  • Giants

    Votes: 13 13.3%

  • Total voters
    98

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
If we could find a way to get this done, we likely face Port. We would go into the Port game 5-3 the last 2 months v their 3-5.

The Power are very gettable IMO. Form is ordinary. Also, they only had the 6th best % for the year. They are overrated.

Would love a chance to have a crack against them with zero expectations.
And it will be at AO in I live in the Adelaide Hills ❤️ And then if they beat port they won't leave Melbourne all the way to the GF.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Mason Wood on the precipice of his first finals campaign.

Drafted in 2012 didn’t play in any of Norths finals in 14, 15 and 16.

It’s been a long and arduous road for him to get to this point. He’s been super consistent this year and very unlucky not to be in All Australian contention, in my opinion.

Mason has made a very strong contribution to our journey to finals and I reckon he’s going to seize as many moments as possible in this game.
 
Hope you're right but the media (SEN & Fox) all think it's a disgrace and he'll get off.
If it was genuinely a disgrace he would have already gotten off.

I think hes a bit stiff but if there is any consistency then he stays suspended. Plus the appeals process needs to show an error in "law" or a gross under or over sentence. Cant really argue any of those things has happened. I just cant see based on the appeals process how it would change.
 
they all also give brownlow votes. If bedford doesn't get off its criminal.
View attachment 1795991
This is truly one of the great anomolies. Error in process. Unless Bedford has something similar (which he almost certainly wont) theres no logical reason to clear him.
 
This is truly one of the great anomolies. Error in process. Unless Bedford has something similar (which he almost certainly wont) theres no logical reason to clear him.
AFL Tribunal and logic are not synonymous
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

AFL Tribunal and logic are not synonymous
This is true but this also isnt the regular tribunal.

MRO/MRP/Tribunal is a crap shoot, appeals board is very much legal precedent shit.

You only have to look at the Cripps thing. Any form of reasonable person would have taken that his position was implied or inferred but following the procedure it wasnt explicitly asked for and stated. As such he got off on a technicality. Unless Bedford has something similar he wont have any case to put forward.

The appeals board wont hear "but he didnt mean it and it wasnt that hard" thats already been determined.
 
Last edited:
Wilkie to Toby
I'd put Wilke on Riccardi/Cadman.

I don't see why ( at the beginning) we'd try and lock up the league's best interceptor on Toby. That's why I went the way I did.
That's a good looking team. Best team of the year.

I think Seb may be sub, if the the midfield is getting beaten then Seb gets put in.
Brisbane team really
King for Hayes
Ross/Byrnes is the only real decision to be made, experience vs. Byrnes run

Cordy stays over Dougal, loved his composure and ground positioning the last few weeks
 
Mason Wood on the precipice of his first finals campaign.

Drafted in 2012 didn’t play in any of Norths finals in 14, 15 and 16.

It’s been a long and arduous road for him to get to this point. He’s been super consistent this year and very unlucky not to be in All Australian contention, in my opinion.

Mason has made a very strong contribution to our journey to finals and I reckon he’s going to seize as many moments as possible in this game.

Quality person too.

Think he has won Clubman of the Year twice.

I'm hearing he is mentoring the young kids too.... must be doing a good job,
 
Quality person too.

Think he has won Clubman of the Year twice.

I'm hearing he is mentoring the young kids too.... must be doing a good job,
I think its on Insta but Nas is living with him and they did an odd couple style interview about it (Mase is studying nutrition and dietetics i think).

Was really heartwarming.
 
I'd put Wilke on Riccardi/Cadman.

I don't see why ( at the beginning) we'd try and lock up the league's best interceptor on Toby. That's why I went the way I did.

Brisbane team really
King for Hayes
Ross/Byrnes is the only real decision to be made, experience vs. Byrnes run

Cordy stays over Dougal, loved his composure and ground positioning the last few weeks
I would put our best on their best

Toby gets away they win
Stop Toby we win
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top