Recruiting AFL Draft Watch 2024 - Check out our haul

[Nuggs Bunny]

All over for this year!

Check out our new picks from the draft:
Pick #13 (matched): Isaac Kako - Small Forward, Calder Cannons
Pick #37: Kayle Gerreyn - Ruck/Forward, West Perth
Pick #39: Angus Clarke - Defender, Glenelg
Pick #61: Rhys Unwin - Small Forward, Greater Western Victoria
Pick #70: Zak Johnson - Midfielder, Northern Knights
Pick #6 RD: Archer Day-Lewis - Forward, Bendigo Pioneers
Cat B Rookie: Jayden Nguyen - Defender, Calder Cannons

 

[Keystone agony]

 

[Keystone agony]

I would be very suprised if Geelong would give up F1 for pick 28 (32 after matches) with only 10 picks off the board. Assuming Kako gets bid by the saints.

Just a plain F2 and maybe some points is a lot less to give up and I think teams would take their chances

Thats why i said F2 or F3 + 28

Cats F1, F2 for 28, F2 and F3

Definitly a combination that works.

Remember the suns traded a F1 for pick 27 to get Jeremy Sharp. If teams really like a group of players/player then they give up a fair bit. Cats have to be close to favs for the flag with Baz imo

 

[Yoda_]

View attachment 2170136

there is a lot of hyperbole in that

 

[year of the cat]

I would be very suprised if Geelong would give up F1 for pick 28 (32 after matches) with only 10 picks off the board. Assuming Kako gets bid by the saints.

Just a plain F2 and maybe some points is a lot less to give up and I think teams would take their chances

If we were to trade with you I’d say we’d be after both 28 and 31. For our FF plus 45 or 57. Hasn’t been any noise in the media about us being involved with Ess but we tend to keep stuff very close to our chests.

 

[TheGreatBarryB]

View attachment 2170136

I find it staggering that Ablett finds it so staggering

 

[Test Tickle]

I find it staggering that Ablett finds it so staggering

I find it staggering that you find it staggering that Ablett finds it staggering.

 

[doug85]

Most of my interest relates to what we do with 28 and 31.

Trading back into the first round sounds like a pipe dream.

 

[katana]

there is a lot of hyperbole in that

matty 'mayo' ablett.

wait til we have two firsts next year and he 'absolutely loves our position'

 

[Keystone agony]

Most of my interest relates to what we do with 28 and 31.

Trading back into the first round sounds like a pipe dream.

Agree, although the first round goes to pick 27

Its going to be F2s or a combo for an F1 unless the Kako bid hasnt come until 15/16 GWS picks and we go hard for a player there with an F1 and 28/31 for one of those

 

[jdstorm]

If we were to trade with you I’d say we’d be after both 28 and 31. For our FF plus 45 or 57. Hasn’t been any noise in the media about us being involved with Ess but we tend to keep stuff very close to our chests.

Yeah. I think in terms of any Geelong trade it would be a combination of things. I think there’s a good working relationship there.

I think the reason it doesn’t happen is because Geelong will want to be sure that they are getting a player they think is worth a F1 and I think that’s unlikely with close to 20 picks between any bid match and pick 32 (28 after bids)

Think it’s more likely you get something like 45 + F2 for one of those picks. Seems a win win for both clubs

Thats why i said F2 or F3 + 28

Cats F1, F2 for 28, F2 and F3

Definitly a combination that works.

Remember the suns traded a F1 for pick 27 to get Jeremy Sharp. If teams really like a group of players/player then they give up a fair bit. Cats have to be close to favs for the flag with Baz imo

Issue is we can’t wait that long to be taking advantage of teams trading for specific players. I suppose we can ask for F1 but with saints bidding at 11 teams would have to have a 22 player long list of guys they think is worth a first to consider it

We also don’t have F3 thanks to the pick 9 trade

Edit

Say we did something like this

28 for North F2 and a 40s pick
Then 32 for 45 and Cats F2

Those picks start to move up as bid matches come in. Then we get chances in that 40s range or could do that same deal of 40s+ F2 to get into the the 30s if we’re just trying to dodge a bid

 

[King Patty]

Adelaides list manager has Kako inside the 4-7 prospect range in this draft. As good as any small forward hes seen come through recently

hope he doesnt bid.

 

[King Patty]

Most of my interest relates to what we do with 28 and 31.

Trading back into the first round sounds like a pipe dream.

First round likely lasts until 27

18 teams
Then you have

Ashcroft
kako
Lombard
Marshall
Saints priorty pick
GWS priority picks

I think we could get back in before pick 27 with Dees first, maybe throw in a third rounder too.

 

[ant555]

there is a lot of hyperbole in that

And Ablett is just looking on . He has no pressure and is also known for talking up drafts a bit.
I think the question about why is fair but in reality we have botched up so much stuff in the last 10 years that the best play is to play the safe game and take the bunch of picks when they where available. Draft the best small forward and see where it goes from there. There will be people here who will lose their minds when the bid comes after 9 but in all honesty I prefer a safe and steady approach right now.
I keep going over this draft and I do not buy super draft. I think it is good and has depth but what made 2001 a super draft was star quality in a variety of different types and sizes. They where not a bunch of very good 180-182 cm midfielders. Hodge 185cm. Judd 189cm. Ball 183cm. Bartell 187cm. Hale as a ruck and there where several really good finds in the second / third / fourth rounds. It was not all the top 20.
The two players this year who have a bit of a point of difference in Lalor and Langford will go in the top 8 so we would not have been in range to get them anyway.
2014 is rated highly and it was not all about the top 20 either. 2018 the same. Some good in the top 20 but also some good further into the draft.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Adelaides list manager has Kako inside the 4-7 prospect range in this draft. As good as any small forward hes seen come through recently

He's just trying to make us match bid with more points. Bastard.

 

[Test Tickle]

Soooo what percentage chance are we getting Kako?
What could go wrong?

 

[doug85]

First round likely lasts until 27

18 teams
Then you have

Ashcroft
kako
Lombard
Marshall
Saints priorty pick
GWS priority pick

I think we could get back in before pick 27 with Dees first, maybe throw in a third rounder too.

The club has stated we’re only trading back in if a player we rate in the top 8 or 9 is available. Hard to believe that’s realistic a player we rate that highly will be available in the 20s

 

[year of the cat]

Yeah. I think in terms of any Geelong trade it would be a combination of things. I think there’s a good working relationship there.

I think the reason it doesn’t happen is because Geelong will want to be sure that they are getting a player they think is worth a F1 and I think that’s unlikely with close to 20 picks between any bid match and pick 32 (28 after bids)

Think it’s more likely you get something like 45 + F2 for one of those picks. Seems a win win for both clubs



Issue is we can’t wait that long to be taking advantage of teams trading for specific players. I suppose we can ask for F1 but with saints bidding at 11 teams would have to have a 22 player long list of guys they think is worth a first to consider it

We also don’t have F3 thanks to the pick 9 trade

Edit

Say we did something like this

28 for North F2 and a 40s pick
Then 32 for 45 and Cats F2

Those picks start to move up as bid matches come in. Then we get chances in that 40s range or could do that same deal of 40s+ F2 to get into the the 30s if we’re just trying to dodge a bid

I think unless we trade with one of the Tigers late picks, you are our most obvious trade option. As you say the relationship or goodwill exists from last year too. We could potentially trade up from 45 - that would be a decent result for both parties. We will know pretty early on in the evening! You will be trading, just about what and who with.

 

[Nifft]

View attachment 2170136

This should be in Delusional Pearlers...

 

[eth-dog]

I think unless we trade with one of the Tigers late picks, you are our most obvious trade option. As you say the relationship or goodwill exists from last year too. We could potentially trade up from 45 - that would be a decent result for both parties. We will know pretty early on in the evening! You will be trading, just about what and who with.

Depending on where a bid lands, 28 and 31 for F1 and 45 is more than good enough for us.

 

[faible]

The club has stated we’re only trading back in if a player we rate in the top 8 or 9 is available. Hard to believe that’s realistic a player we rate that highly will be available in the 20s

It's a pretty even draft, plus quite a few NGA / Father-Son bids to be matched, could easily see a player rated around our top-10 could be there around 20 something. Every club has different list needs.

 

[Keystone agony]

First round likely lasts until 27

18 teams
Then you have

Ashcroft
kako
Lombard
Marshall
Saints priorty pick
GWS priority pick

I think we could get back in before pick 27 with Dees first, maybe throw in a third rounder too.

A F1 of our or dees likely finishing position definitely gets in before 27. Its just im not sure the 22-27 range may be that good for our likely F1s there, its a big price to pay

I actually dont think much of the 18-30 group compared to some other seasons and then list need for us (ie I dont see giving away an early F1 just for Matt Whitlock or Trainor as the way to go)

 

[year of the cat]

Depending on where a bid lands, 28 and 31 for F1 and 45 is more than good enough for us.

That's what I'd do but whether the club think my way is another thing


There a couple of guys in that early to mid/late 30 bracket I like that would likely be gone by our first pick.

 

[Keystone agony]

It's a pretty even draft, plus quite a few NGA / Father-Son bids to be matched, could easily see a player rated around our top-10 could be there around 20 something. Every club has different list needs.

and that is where we cant take that message too clearly

is it 8 on our list of needs

Or 8 on the overall of pure rankings

For me there is no one in the top 8 we shouldnt have on list needs though.....

Twomey also said seems very unlikely now for us, and also that we likely do early trades which implies F2s or Cats F1 for the 28/31

 

[Keystone agony]

What would the club give up to get to one of saints picks for a Bo Allen/Travaglia/Lindsay/Armstrong/Shanahan/J.Whitlock ?

F1, 28 + 31 for 7/8

2 x F1 for 7/8 + F2

 

[Yoda_]

matty 'mayo' ablett.

wait til we have two firsts next year and he 'absolutely loves our position'

this is what I dont get with this whole point of view..

We are buying a first round talent with a combination of later selections, we didn't have 28 before the trade. Furthermore, the later trades are all bankable selections now in a deep draft.

The pov that it was a bad play because of a hypothetical is a tad over the top