Preview AFL Round 22 - Collingwood vs West Coast Eagles - Pattersons Stadium - Saturday 25/8 at 7.40 pm

[TradeDraft]

In: Krakouer Ceglar Johnson Swan

Out: Sinclair Cloke Sinclair Sidebottom

 

[GibboPAL]

Swan has got to come in, too, don't forget.

 

[TradeDraft]

Swan has got to come in, too, don't forget.

Oh Yeah Thank I just Change that then. Though with the Crap he did with Drinking does he deserve to come back in?

 

[Temploar]

LOL The weekly IN: Ceglar from Dave.

B: O'Brien - Tarrant - Toovey
HB: Maxwell - Reid - Shaw
C: Thomas - Beams - Sidebottom
HF: Didak - Cloke - Goldsack
F: Wellingham - Dawes - Krakouer
Foll: Jolly - Pendlebury - Swan
Int: Johnson, Fasolo, Blair SUB: Seedsman
Emerg: Wood, Clarke, Sinclair

OUT: Sinclair, Elliott, Brown, Clarke
IN: Goldsack(if fit, else leave sinclair in), Johnson, Krakouer, Swan

 

[TradeDraft]

LOL The weekly IN: Ceglar from Dave.

B: O'Brien - Tarrant - Toovey
HB: Maxwell - Reid - Shaw
C: Thomas - Beams - Sidebottom
HF: Didak - Cloke - Goldsack
F: Wellingham - Dawes - Krakouer
Foll: Jolly - Pendlebury - Swan
Int: Johnson, Fasolo, Blair SUB: Seedsman
Emerg: Wood, Clarke, Sinclair

OUT: Sinclair, Elliott, Brown, Clarke
IN: Goldsack(if fit, else leave sinclair in), Johnson, Krakouer, Swan

Well Ceglar might Actually want to play for Collingwood which I have Doubts on Cloke

 

[el toado]

Oh Yeah Thank I just Change that then. Though with the Crap he did with Drinking does he deserve to come back in?

Try and think before you post

 

[standingroomonly]

Out: Maxwell (inj) Mooney (inj) Elliot (omit) Clarke (omit)
In: Toovey, Swan, Krakouer, Johnson

Assuming the injuries will keep the players out.

Edit: forgot about Toovey!

 

[Bay Pie]

In: Krakouer Ceglar Johnson Swan

Out: Sinclair Cloke Sinclair Sidebottom

No Ugle?

 

[Temploar]

How longs maxwell out for, anyone know?

 

[SuperSub17]

How bad is Maxwell? I turend the TV off halfway through the last so I have no idea.

 

[TradeDraft]

No Ugle?

Well if we go by Best we could bring in Josh Thomas

 

[standingroomonly]

No Ugle?

Was poor today in the VFL and it would be more likely that they'd test Krak for the small forward role.

 

[100volt1]

how's it possible to drop swan for drinking 6 DAYS out from a game and plays well every week, but when 2 forwards do the same crap week after week, and dont contribute how do they not get dropped!? poor form collingwood.

 

[Jelly Bean]

In: Krakouer Ceglar Johnson Swan

Out: Sinclair Cloke Sinclair Sidebottom

Settle down Dave - Sidebottom wouldn't get dropped, and Dawes will go before Cloke. Cloke wasn't served well with poor delivery from the likes of Blair, Sidebottom, and even Pendles (although he was smashed anyway by Thompson).

In: Toovey, Krakouer, Johnson, Swan.
Out: Seedsman, Mooney, Elliott, Clarke.

I'd be tempted to send Dawes to the VFL for confidence (as I have been calling for for weeks) but I think we have run out of time to do this.

 

[Bay Pie]

Was poor today in the VFL and it would be more likely that they'd test Krak for the small forward role.

Well if we go by Best we could bring in Josh Thomas

Hehe. It was a poor attempt at sarcasm. Dave, you normally plump for Ceglar & Ugle most weeks.

 

[carnthepies19]

IN: Swan, Johnson, Toovey (if fit?) Krakouer - sub

OUT: Clarke, Maxwell (if injured), Mooney (if injured, or Toovey's fit), Elliott

 

[biggiemediums]

In: Swan.

Out: Everyone but Beams.

Beams & Swan vs West Coast.

 

[Big Bryza]

Out- Elliot, Clarke, Sinclair
In- Swan, Johnson, Krakeour

Far out I wish we had something to bring in for Cloke and Dawes. I know the delivery was average at times but it's the attitude of Cloke that annoys me. He's too worried about wrestling with his opponent, sooking to the umpire. Just play like you did last year Trav and all this contract shit wouldn't be an issue. He has no one but himself to blame for his current form. It's frustrating because we know how good he can be. As for Dawes, the less said the better.

 

[Big Bryza]

Make that Mooney out and Sinclair remains.

 

[NT.Thunder]

In: Krakouer Ceglar Johnson Swan

Out: Sinclair Cloke Sinclair Sidebottom

why have you got Sidey as an out?

 

[Go_Brad_Dick]

In: Toovey, Krakouer, Johnson, Swan, Wood, Goldsack(if fit)
Out: Seedsman, Mooney, Elliott, Dawes, Sinclair, Clarke(for goldy)

I'm sorry but Wood is 5x more useful than Dawes at the moment, and will meed a proper 2nd ruck next week.
Sinclair is not composed enough he injects a messy panic in the team. His forward pressure is good but too messy and has to go.
Elliot shone bright in his first couple of games but has been a liability since, nearly lost us the game last week. try again next year.
Kindest thing you could say about Marty Clarke year is that he has been disappointing

 

[sr36]

Far out I wish we had something to bring in for Cloke and Dawes. I know the delivery was average at times but it's the attitude of Cloke that annoys me. He's too worried about wrestling with his opponent, sooking to the umpire. Just play like you did last year Trav and all this contract shit wouldn't be an issue. He has no one but himself to blame for his current form. It's frustrating because we know how good he can be. As for Dawes, the less said the better.

I'm pretty confident that the coach has changed his role significantly. He barely ever leaves the 50 anymore. He's no longer running his opponent into the ground like he did last year. It's clearly not worked all year. Bux has turned a gun centre half forward into a mediocre full forward.

 

[BVIB]

Sidebottom out? Are you delusional?
Elliot out before Sinclair.

 

[Krueger]

Oh Yeah Thank I just Change that then. Though with the Crap he did with Drinking does he deserve to come back in?

Two weeks was out was more than enough.

 

[SuperSub17]

In: Toovey, Krakouer, Johnson, Swan, Wood, Goldsack(if fit)
Out: Seedsman, Mooney, Elliott, Dawes, Sinclair, Clarke(for goldy)

I'm sorry but Wood is 5x more useful than Dawes at the moment, and will meed a proper 2nd ruck next week.
Sinclair is not composed enough he injects a messy panic in the team. His forward pressure is good but too messy and has to go.
Elliot shone bright in his first couple of games but has been a liability since, nearly lost us the game last week. try again next year.
Kindest thing you could say about Marty Clarke year is that he has been disappointing

You could put a statue at full forward and it would have more impact than Dawes atm