Teen Wolf
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 5, 2011
- 9,173
- 9,892
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Afghanistan women's cricket team
Regardless of "the metrics", AFLW expands to 12 H&A games per team next year.
The idea of wanting to open and end the women's season without competing with the men's continues to have, I think, strong merit. So too the idea that AFLW venues in spring are more conducive to attendance than the same venues in winter.
Furthermore, trying to schedule 9 men's and 9 women's games on the same weekend is going to result in even worse timeslots for AFLW, and it'll put a strain on club and league resources too.
But with all that said, the current situation of squeezing in matches cannot, and obviously will not, go on for much longer. The players will eventually shoot it down, as they eventually did to matches in February.
So what is the best fixturing solution?
It might be to do the complete opposite and stretch it out: Start AFLW in the middle of the year and, at least while the men's H&A is still going, have each women's round played over two weekends.
Benefits of this would be:
• Greater recovery time between matches = more star players on the field for longer, fewer missed matches due to concussion and short-term injuries
• Still allows for matches in spring when the men's H&A season is finished
• Decent period of alignment with the state league seasons
• Easier to schedule 13-14 matches per weekend (9 men's + 4-5 women's) than 18, for example...
This would give the women's games a stable, dedicated window every week at reasonable hours while allowing for enough flexibility to avoid clashes with the men's fixture.
It also leaves the 2pm FTA slot open for state league matches. And starting mid-year would also mean a good amount of men's AFL early arvo matches are retained.
I guess there is potential there to have some AFLW games played as double-headers with men's games (for instance Sunday 12.35pm women --> 3.20pm men), but that would be among the weakest reasons to do this imo.
The idea of wanting to open and end the women's season without competing with the men's continues to have, I think, strong merit. So too the idea that AFLW venues in spring are more conducive to attendance than the same venues in winter.
Furthermore, trying to schedule 9 men's and 9 women's games on the same weekend is going to result in even worse timeslots for AFLW, and it'll put a strain on club and league resources too.
But with all that said, the current situation of squeezing in matches cannot, and obviously will not, go on for much longer. The players will eventually shoot it down, as they eventually did to matches in February.
So what is the best fixturing solution?
It might be to do the complete opposite and stretch it out: Start AFLW in the middle of the year and, at least while the men's H&A is still going, have each women's round played over two weekends.
Benefits of this would be:
• Greater recovery time between matches = more star players on the field for longer, fewer missed matches due to concussion and short-term injuries
• Still allows for matches in spring when the men's H&A season is finished
• Decent period of alignment with the state league seasons
• Easier to schedule 13-14 matches per weekend (9 men's + 4-5 women's) than 18, for example...
M1: Thu 7.30pm
M2: Fri 7.40pm
W1: Sat 12.05pm
W2: Sat 12.35pm
M3: Sat 2.10pm
M4: Sat 4.50pm
M5: Sat 7.10pm
M6: Sat 7.30pm
W3: Sat 10.05pm (Frem/WCE home game - 8.05pm AWST)
W4: Sun 12.05pm
W5: Sun 12.35pm
M7: Sun 2.10pm
M8: Sun 3.20pm
M9: Sun 4.50pm
This would give the women's games a stable, dedicated window every week at reasonable hours while allowing for enough flexibility to avoid clashes with the men's fixture.
It also leaves the 2pm FTA slot open for state league matches. And starting mid-year would also mean a good amount of men's AFL early arvo matches are retained.
I guess there is potential there to have some AFLW games played as double-headers with men's games (for instance Sunday 12.35pm women --> 3.20pm men), but that would be among the weakest reasons to do this imo.