-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 1
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 1
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Recommitted Andrew Gaff [re-signed]
- Thread starter Obeanie1
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #352
In what world?
His slight drop in last two years (from AA 2015) means pick 8 would absolutely be max.
Both 7&8 is well overs even with 13 coming back.
A top 10 pick would be West Coasts dream and they potentially have it there.
Both 7&8 is well overs even with 13 coming back.
A top 10 pick would be West Coasts dream and they potentially have it there.
I think west coast will be fighting to hang onto him. They're losing mitchell and Priddis from the midfield already - to lose a third senior midfielder in the same off season will set them up for a big fall in 2017.
Agree, they won't want t let him go unless it's a great deal.
Although Terry Wallace, who says he knows the Gaff family very well, said a few days ago that Gaff would be very happy to come home if the right trade could eventuate. That says to me that he's probably asked for a trade.
I just hope our club isn't so desperate for a decent recruit that they sell the farm for him even though he's the type of player we desperately need.
The one in which is he as an All Australian mid literally one year ago?
Gaff for a second rounder, have you started the GD Day drinking already? I don't blame you.
The ball is in WC's court and they will no doubt push a hard bargain.
They will start by asking for 7 & 8 which is clearly overs even with 13 coming back.
Maybe 7 & 8 for Gaff, 13 and 30
In this draft that would probably hurt the Saints a bit as it doesn't run deep. The talent seems to drop off a bit after the top 8 or so and I don't think there's a lot left at 30.
They will start by asking for 7 & 8 which is clearly overs even with 13 coming back.
Maybe 7 & 8 for Gaff, 13 and 30
In this draft that would probably hurt the Saints a bit as it doesn't run deep. The talent seems to drop off a bit after the top 8 or so and I don't think there's a lot left at 30.
- Banned
- #358
Don't think AA has anything to do with Free agency compo.
I was clearly referring to his trade value not the likely FA compo.
- Banned
- #360
Yep. If he were uncontracted this year that's my estimation of what he would fetch in a trade.
FA compo is clearly tied to your ladder position so why would I phrase it like that?
Anyway, misunderstanding, let's move on.
- Banned
- #362
Ok, but FA compo is not tied to ladder position - just saying.
The pick is. Obviously not the Band level.
- Banned
- #364
Nope. Ladder position has no bearing.
If the club receives for instance a compensation pick after their first round pick how is that not tied to ladder position?
- Banned
- #366
CLUBS HAVE BEEN WARNED COMPENSATION IS:
* Not designed to fully compensate a club for the loss of a player
* Designed to reflect the relative values of various players to one another
* Not designed to make concession for the ladder position of a club losing a player, but standardise compensation across five categories of picks.
So how is a first round pick awarded? A team with pick 10 would originally have been awarded pick 11 assuming the player was deemed to be worth a first rounder. Has it changed? And if so, do they just award a pick in the middle of the round or something?
- Jun 2, 2015
- 634
- 1,229
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
You have to be in the top 5% of paid players in the league i think. So someone would need to pay him about a mill per year
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Salary and contract determines what band is awarded then ladder position determines where the pick falls within the band. For eg both brisbane and geelong will probably get band 3 (second round) compensation for rockliff and motlop but for brisbane that would fall at pick 19 but for geelong it would be pick 34.
- Thread starter
- #370
Did he do that going back with flight of the ball when Jonas knocked him out?
And since when is giving a quick handball in close squibing it?
Such a loser Freo supporter type of post.
Okay, thank you. So my understanding that the pick is tied to ladder position is correct.
Sure. I'm not so much arguing that that is Gaffs likely compo more so just trying to clarify that you can be awarded a pick relative to your ladder position.
Let's hope so!
Should definitely be on the table.
Should definitely be on the table.
