dirtycat23
Debutant
- Apr 29, 2005
- 56
- 0
- Other Teams
- cats
who should be in it. have to be a good few from scoth hail and xav
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
aps dream team
- Thread starter dirtycat23
- Start date
- Tagged users None
headovathepill
Debutant
Tom Foster, Tim Boston and Billy "Nugget" Stoughton
from the backline help me out? and what u think so far?
Darvell (xav) Kennedy (xav) Paule (mgs)
Plymin (Hail) Jack Watts (wes) Ellis (mgs)
Newman (cgs) Eddy (cgs) Dawes (bgs)
Mcguinnes (bgs) Laidlaw (carey) Rockerfella (GC)
Salter (Hail) Moosey (skevs) Rioli (scotch)
Ruck : Wolkow (cgs) Int: White (bgs)
Rover: Werzberger (cgs) Townsend (cgs)
R/R: Caine (skevs)
Darvell (xav) Kennedy (xav) Paule (mgs)
Plymin (Hail) Jack Watts (wes) Ellis (mgs)
Newman (cgs) Eddy (cgs) Dawes (bgs)
Mcguinnes (bgs) Laidlaw (carey) Rockerfella (GC)
Salter (Hail) Moosey (skevs) Rioli (scotch)
Ruck : Wolkow (cgs) Int: White (bgs)
Rover: Werzberger (cgs) Townsend (cgs)
R/R: Caine (skevs)
Whats Scotchs other little aboriginal. When I saw him he was better than rioli.
By the way Cody should be in that team. Won the Xavs Bnf last year.
By the way Cody should be in that team. Won the Xavs Bnf last year.
Nathan Djerrkura (I think that's how you spell it).
Rioli and him probably have the best skills of the lot.
Rioli and him probably have the best skills of the lot.
jimmy12 said:
Ainger, scotch would be at full-forward,CHF or CHB. One of Oakleigh Charger's best. Nick Smith, also scotch, would slot into the side as centre,wing,rover,half forward flank; wherever you want. Nathan Djerkurra easily in the team. That's just 3 of the multi talented scotch outfit.
Bit too many Caufield there.
Nah i haven't seen Caulfield yet, and will be able to give a better reasoning in 3 weeks when i do see them.
But, aside from the old saying a champion team beats a team of champions, why are Caulfield struggling this year with, so called, 4 of the best 22 players in the APS?
But, aside from the old saying a champion team beats a team of champions, why are Caulfield struggling this year with, so called, 4 of the best 22 players in the APS?
roger merret
Draftee
- Nov 5, 2004
- 15
- 0
- Other Teams
- Essendon
I agree that there are too many Caulfield players in there and i'm very surprised not to see Hawkins from melbourne and the blonde haired ruckman from Geelong College getting a run. Oh and Moosey would not be in my side.
footy11111
Draftee
- Mar 9, 2005
- 6
- 0
- Other Teams
- richmond
jimmy12 said:
from the backline, darvell(xav), kennedy(xav) and paule(mgs) have all been outstanding this year for their respective schools. each have racked up huge stats each round, but all 3 strike me as more attacking players than backliners and could all be used onball or up foreward aswell. plymin and ellis are quality players on the halfback, plymin with the build and ellis with the smarts. dawes on the wing is a big call, ive seen him play and i dont rate him all the much apart from being a big body around stopages. mcguinnes and rioli are definates in the foreward line but i'd like to see hawkins and ainger up there aswell. wolkow lacks in the ruck and would surely be replaced by by the geelong ruckman who also rucks for the falcons. just some thoughts...
yeah i agree that hawkins deserves a gurnz, and yes, there a are alot of cgs's and i see where u guys a re coming from but would anyone be prepared to remove werzberger or eddy from the midfield who can also swap into the forward or half backline with an ellis or kennedy proving to be an excellent choice. opinions? Dawes needs to get off the wing.
headovathepill
Debutant
The 2 Geelong teams have the best ruckman in the APS for what I have seen this year. Banjannin (GC) and Boston (GGS). Banjannin rucked in tandom last year for the falcons with Meeson and should continue this form. Raso would have to play CHB. His foot skills today were exellent.
Cody Sibasado, put him out on the wing.
dirtycat23
Debutant
- Apr 29, 2005
- 56
- 0
- Other Teams
- cats
- Thread starter
- #20
FB darvell(xav) (vc)kennedy(xav) ellis(mgs)
HB plymin(hail) (vc)raso(hail) watts(wes)
W townsend(cgs) caine(stkev) Cody(xav)
HF laidlaw(carey) (c)murray(hail) dawes(cgs)
FF dickson(hail) ainger(scotch) rioli(scotch)
R wolkow(cgs) fleming(hail) eddy(cgs)
I Werzberger (cgs) mguiness(bgs) magner(hail)
best i could do, reckon forward line is a treat
HB plymin(hail) (vc)raso(hail) watts(wes)
W townsend(cgs) caine(stkev) Cody(xav)
HF laidlaw(carey) (c)murray(hail) dawes(cgs)
FF dickson(hail) ainger(scotch) rioli(scotch)
R wolkow(cgs) fleming(hail) eddy(cgs)
I Werzberger (cgs) mguiness(bgs) magner(hail)
best i could do, reckon forward line is a treat
headovathepill
Debutant
I don't think BAnjannin has played much this year cause of injury.
Boston had a ******** day if he lost to Walkow cause that guy isn't special at all!
The T-Man has so much bloody talent iys not funny
Boston had a ******** day if he lost to Walkow cause that guy isn't special at all!
The T-Man has so much bloody talent iys not funny
wolkows rucking is something special. and should not be underestimated in anysense. last as a yr 11 he dominated the rucking. this year he has improved dramatically as a player and as a ruckman. last year he focused souly on the taps but this year he is a major asset around the ground. hasnt kicked many goals but has sure contributed to them. gives robert wallnock a run for him money.
meat cleaver
Debutant
- Jun 4, 2005
- 59
- 0
- Other Teams
- wisconsin albatros
meat cleaver wonders if he is seeing properly- can this be right, tommy hawkins not listed despite some best afield performances to date. i have to say id also envisage seeing this bloke from GGS in there, saw him play last year and on sat. small fella, runs all day, longish black hair puts it in a head band, give him a run off the bench at least.
