what will the lineups look like?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Aps Vs Ags
- Thread starter THE BRICKMAN
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- May 22, 2007
- 125
- 2
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Barcelona, Melbourne Storm
- Banned
- #2
FB: Lynch(HAIL) Kennedy(SK) Cumbrae-Stewart(MGS)
HB: Croft(WC) Sandilands(CGS) Smith(HAIL)
C: Martin(HAIL) Sargent(BGS) Hill(SCOTCH)
HF: Wynne(XAV) Henderson(GC) J.Rioli(SCOTCH)
FF: Yaman(CGS) Smith(XAV) Shaw(MGS)
ON: Jones(CAREY) Sundberg(CGS) O'Keefe(GGS)
INT: Noonan(XAV) Lloyd(GGS) Lisle(CAREY) Pickering(BGS)
I'm pretty sure i missed a few guns, sorry about taht but that's the beast i could do off the top of my head... Thoughts???
HB: Croft(WC) Sandilands(CGS) Smith(HAIL)
C: Martin(HAIL) Sargent(BGS) Hill(SCOTCH)
HF: Wynne(XAV) Henderson(GC) J.Rioli(SCOTCH)
FF: Yaman(CGS) Smith(XAV) Shaw(MGS)
ON: Jones(CAREY) Sundberg(CGS) O'Keefe(GGS)
INT: Noonan(XAV) Lloyd(GGS) Lisle(CAREY) Pickering(BGS)
I'm pretty sure i missed a few guns, sorry about taht but that's the beast i could do off the top of my head... Thoughts???
Curnow is a shoe in for a spot in the team. I dont think Lloyd will get a game, maybe next year. Weddell would have to be considered, seeing he tried out last year, Captains GC and has played 1st's since yr9.
- Apr 16, 2007
- 75
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Banned
- #4
cumbrae stewart - no (mcclardy instead from grammar)
sargent - definetly not the best centremen in aps
lisle and pickering - no
sanfilipo - unlucky
sands ???
cachia???
lynch and kennedy both injured
u really are struggling mate
highflyer123
Debutant
- Apr 2, 2007
- 80
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Kennedy is playing this week so he isnt injured, sands injured all year, cachia didnt make the initial squad, Shaw from MGS before cumbrae or mclardy, Chivers from SKC also would have to be considered...
lynch at BP? you've got to be joking.
chivers
newman
cachia
???
how is sundberg starting on the ball?
rioli on a half forward flank?
kennedy from xavs?
a few things u needa fix up
- Apr 16, 2007
- 75
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Banned
- #7
wat happened to sands?
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
Here's my take on things,
FB:...Lisle(CA)......Kennedy(SKC)....Ziebell(CGS)
HB:...Newman(SKC)....Sandilands(CGS).Sargent(BGS)
C:....Martin(HC).....Curnow(GC)......Croft(WC)
HF:...Wynne(XC)......Henderson(GC)...Hill(SC)
FF:...Yaman(CGS).....Smith(XC).......J.Rioli(SC)
Foll:.Cordy(GC)......Sundberg(CGS)...O'Keefe(GGS)
INT:..Jones(CA)......Shaw(MGS).......Breen(CGS)
......Sanfillipo(XC)
Stiff: ..Chivers, McLardy, Noonan, Smith, Cumbrae-Stewart, Kennedy.
Injured: Sands, Lynch.
FB:...Lisle(CA)......Kennedy(SKC)....Ziebell(CGS)
HB:...Newman(SKC)....Sandilands(CGS).Sargent(BGS)
C:....Martin(HC).....Curnow(GC)......Croft(WC)
HF:...Wynne(XC)......Henderson(GC)...Hill(SC)
FF:...Yaman(CGS).....Smith(XC).......J.Rioli(SC)
Foll:.Cordy(GC)......Sundberg(CGS)...O'Keefe(GGS)
INT:..Jones(CA)......Shaw(MGS).......Breen(CGS)
......Sanfillipo(XC)
Stiff: ..Chivers, McLardy, Noonan, Smith, Cumbrae-Stewart, Kennedy.
Injured: Sands, Lynch.
- Oct 17, 2006
- 1,142
- 1
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #10
Corp (Wesley) has been our 2nd best by a mile and should be a shoe in for a spot
- Mar 29, 2005
- 8,407
- 944
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, Liverpool, Celtics
Pity there's only 1 Wesley bloke (apart from the injured Sands) really at the level of the top 30 odd players.
- May 22, 2007
- 125
- 2
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Barcelona, Melbourne Storm
- Banned
- #12
- Lisle plays CHF for CAREY
- Sargent has never played in backline
- Jones is better than Cordy
- Breen doesn't deserve to be in there...
- Sanfillipo neither as he has only been in their best once... (overrated)
Jones is not better than Cordy, we will see when Cordy gets drafted next year. Weddel should be in. One of the most under rated players in APS.
u say sands is injured? that mean he's out for the game? if thats the case heres my team
FB: Lisle(Carey)Kennedy(SKC)Kennedy (XC)
HB: Newman(SKC)....Chivers (SKC) . Sargent(BGS)
C:.... Martin(HC)..... Curnow(GC)..... Croft(WC)
HF:...Wynne(XC)...... Henderson(GC).. Hill(SC)
FF:... Yaman(CGS)..... Smith(XC)....... J.Rioli(SC)
Foll:.Cordy(GC)...... Sundberg(CGS)... O'Keefe(GGS)
INT:..Jones(CA)......Shaw(MGS).......Scully(HC)
...... Ziebell (CGS)
How can u leave out Hugh Sandilands?
Mine would be the same except:
Lisle ruck
Sargent back pocket
Sandilands half back
Cordy stiff
gormanisahack
Team Captain
Cordy is a lot better than Jones.
lol, if u read my post, it says if sandilands was OUT. if sandilands was in sandilands to a HBF, seargent to a BP, lisle ruck, cordy bench, shaw out. mite drop jones for cachia too.
FB: Sargent(BGS) Kennedy(SKC) Kennedy (XC)
HB: Newman(SKC)....Chivers (SKC) . Sandilands (CGS)
C:.... Martin(HC)..... Curnow(GC)..... Croft(WC)
HF:...Wynne(XC)...... Henderson(GC).. Hill(SC)
FF:... Yaman(CGS)..... Smith(XC)....... J.Rioli(SC)
Foll:.Lisle (Carey)...... Sundberg(CGS)... O'Keefe(GGS)
INT:..Jones(CA)/Cachia(SKC)......Cordy(GC).......Scully(HC)
...... Ziebell (CGS)
danharris#4
Debutant
mate you have got to be joking and you obviously havent seen a lot of aps footy this year...jones is an allround better player than cordy in basically every department..he takes more marks especially contested, kicks better and has a better engine, does cordy play TAC cup? Jones easily wins that battle and should be the aps ruckman.
I'd hate to burst your bubble buddy but you are very wrong. Cordy does play TAC cup and kicked 3 goals in their most recent win against eastern. He is 200cm tall and dominates all over the ground every week and ill leading GC is goals this year. He is to tall and skilled for any backman to match up on. He will play AFL through father/son with the Bulldogs but would've got drafted anyway. He also has another year of APS ahead of him. He will dominate the comp even more so next year.
Jordan Lisle from Carey is the best CHF in the comp. He hasnt been beaten all year and gets the worst delivery in the APS. He has hands like a magician and foot skills like ronaldo. Surely he should be CHF for the aps side.
Cordy=spud who has foot skills barely as good as mark blake for a 200cm ruckmen he cant jump and was protected when Jones was in the ruck from a shalacking
CORDY = SPUD
Cordy=spud who has foot skills barely as good as mark blake for a 200cm ruckmen he cant jump and was protected when Jones was in the ruck from a shalacking
CORDY = SPUD
- Apr 16, 2007
- 75
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Banned
- #21
lisle only looks good coz he plays in a team of *******s. its like chucking kepler bradley in a team of ******s of course he is going to look like a superstar. lisle = overrated spud
Henderson is so much better than Lisle its not funny. Clearly he's the best CHF in the comp and he'll go top 10 in the draft. Lisle won't even get drafted, he'll be playing amatuers in 3 years.
totally agree.. henderson is a gun and will get drafted top 10, lisle is so overrated and plays with total spuds. Lisle is an individual and probably wont even play amatures in 3ys. id say he would be pushing 4-5.
You said if SANDS was injured...
Sands and Sandilands are two different players.
Pretty sure Cachia didnt make the squad either.
It is hard not to stand out in the Carey team with the amount of low quality players going around. Players in other schools seconds teams would stand out in Careys 1stXV111
