Traded Ben Brown [Traded to Melbourne with #28 and Future 4th Round Pick for #26, #33 and Future 4th Round Pick]

[johndemonic]

Not sure it would be a good idea for Big Boner Brown to hang out with Collingwood players off-field.

 

[Go Woods]

Five AFL clubs linked to outgoing Kangaroos forward Ben Brown

The 27-year-old star has no shortage of suitors from right across the country after being told he was unwanted at North Melbourne.

www.google.com.au

Pies, Dockers, Saints, Bombers & Lions......Demons????

 

[GatesOfHell]

Cal Twomey reporting via the AFL website the Dees are a strong chance to land Ben Brown.

Gut feel he’ll be in red and blue in 2021.

 

[pupstar]

Cal Twomey reporting via the AFL website the Dees are a strong chance to land Ben Brown.

Gut feel he’ll be in red and blue in 2021.

And what are you guys going to offer.

 

[GatesOfHell]

And what are you guys going to offer.

23 and Tom McDonald.

 

[Altum Volantes]

23 and Tom McDonald.

Who’s paying Tom McDonald?

 

[pupstar]

23 and Tom McDonald.

You forgot next years 1st.

 

[Prochard123]

23 and Tom McDonald.

So not even one 1st rounder?

 

[Go Woods]

Cal Twomey reporting via the AFL website the Dees are a strong chance to land Ben Brown.

Gut feel he’ll be in red and blue in 2021.

Your kidding yourselves, he ain't going from one minnow club to another...

 

[Taylor]

Your kidding yourselves, he ain't going from one minnow club to another...

He'd stay at North if they wanted him.

 

[johndemonic]

23 and Tom McDonald.

So not even one 1st rounder?

I'd offer 23 and a swap of our future 1st round pick for your future 2nd

 

[GatesOfHell]

You forgot next years 1st.

The best we’ll be able to do is package up 23 with either TMac or Brayshaw to get a mid first round pick from another club, then on trade that to you for Brown. Dogs might bite with pick 13.

Otherwise it’s our 2021 first round pick on its own.

Something along those lines. Pick 13-15 is about right on its own for Brown. Proven key forward but he is 29yo and coming off a pretty poor season.

 

[Robroy22]

I thoroughly enjoyed it thanks for enquiring. It was a real bum spanking
[/QUOTE


Inquiring... c'mon man you're the silvertail remember?
I know....you were probably worrying about your final tonight.....ooops!

 

[the big lebowski]

he is 29yo

Really? Tell us more.

 

[johndemonic]

The best we’ll be able to do is package up 23 with either TMac or Brayshaw to get a mid first round pick from another club, then on trade that to you for Brown. Dogs might bite with pick 13.

Otherwise it’s our 2021 first round pick on its own.

Something along those lines. Pick 13-15 is about right on its own for Brown. Proven key forward but he is 29yo and coming off a pretty poor season.

23 and Brayshaw is a pick 5-10 minimum. In fact, we'd be losing out on selling him at a low point and may as well keep him.

And Tmac with his 800y contract is out. No one wants him. Don't equate him with Gus

 

[GatesOfHell]

23 and Brayshaw is a pick 5-10 minimum. In fact, we'd be losing out on selling him at a low point and may as well keep him.

And Tmac with his 800y contract is out. No one wants him. Don't equate him with Gus

Pick 10, Pick 13 ... splitting hairs. Happy to involve Brayshaw in a deal that nets us Brown.

Disagree re Gus at ‘low point’. He is what he is. B grade inside mid.

 

[GatesOfHell]

Really? Tell us more.

He has red hair. Automatic discount.

 

[johndemonic]

Pick 10, Pick 13 ... splitting hairs. Happy to involve Brayshaw in a deal that nets us Brown.

I'd rate Brown 15-20 given his age, so we'd want to hold onto 23 and trade them Brayshaw and 47 imo. More like splitting dreads

 

[GatesOfHell]

I'd rate Brown 15-20 given his age, so we'd want to hold onto 23 and trade them Brayshaw and 47 imo. More like splitting dreads

That would be the ideal scenario. Not sure it gets it done. 47 is a Hail Mary pick in a normal draft let alone a compromised one.

 

[Robroy22]

This is the real steal of Melbourne's off season....they've secretly landed their next coach!

Adem a Demon again: In-demand assistant leaves Hawks, joins Melbourne

Adem Yze will be part of Simon Goodwin's coaching team next season

www.afl.com.au

 

[johndemonic]

That would be the ideal scenario. Not sure it gets it done.

I like the idea of swapping our future first for their future 2nd. They can death ride us for a top 10 pick, we are aiming to make it 14-18 for what will assuredly be pick 19. Then you add 23 in so they're at least getting a minimum pick 15-20.

Edit we keep brayshsw

 

[GatesOfHell]

I like the idea of swapping our future first for their future 2nd. They can death ride us for a top 10 pick, we are aiming to make it 14-18 for what will assuredly be pick 19. Then you add 23 in so they're at least getting a minimum pick 15-20.

Edit we keep brayshsw

Don’t mind it. There’s a deal there to be done.

I really like the idea of Brown in our 22. Weid and Jackson will get huge benefit from it.

 

[johndemonic]

Don’t mind it. There’s a deal there to be done.

I really like the idea of Brown in our 22. Weid and Jackson will get huge benefit from it.

Might be unpalatable to our fan base though. We might want/need something in this years draft like their 3rd coming back Pick 40ish

 

[GatesOfHell]

Might be unpalatable to our fan base though. We might want/need something in this years draft like their 3rd coming back Pick 40ish

Some won’t like it but we have to roll the dice. Two years now with Weid and TMac as key targets hasn’t worked. A third season of failure with the same set up will cost Goodwin and others their jobs.

 

[Apex36]

Brown has to agree to any trade. If he is determined to get to a particular club then we don't have a huge amount of leverage.

Wow someone who actually understands how it works.