- Moderator
- #801
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mega Thread Best 22/2013 Predictions and all that
- Thread starter SE_Blue
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I knew that. However if I didn't write something stupid, it wouldn't be me.Walker is a handy player aswell. Has to be to hold down 2 positions. Surely one of those could go to Betts
pepalenko
rolling with my cronies
- May 4, 2011
- 3,564
- 3,217
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, SanFransisco 49s, Yankees
Pep tides are working.No Betts? Stop sniffing glue pep.
- May 29, 2009
- 29,823
- 14,883
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
Tuohy Jamison Laidler
Yarran Henderson Lucas/McInnes
Simpson Gibbs Carrazzo
Walker Waite Garlett
Betts Casboult Hampson
Kreuzer Judd Murphy
Scotland Robinson McLean SUB: Bell
EMG: Warnock Duigan Curnow Lucas/McInnes Armfield
Still have Watson, McCarthy, Graham, Bootsma, Menzel developing.
Yarran Henderson Lucas/McInnes
Simpson Gibbs Carrazzo
Walker Waite Garlett
Betts Casboult Hampson
Kreuzer Judd Murphy
Scotland Robinson McLean SUB: Bell
EMG: Warnock Duigan Curnow Lucas/McInnes Armfield
Still have Watson, McCarthy, Graham, Bootsma, Menzel developing.
pepalenko
rolling with my cronies
- May 4, 2011
- 3,564
- 3,217
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, SanFransisco 49s, Yankees
No Army?
- May 29, 2009
- 29,823
- 14,883
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
Sorry, should've had him with the emergencies.
It's pretty obvious that Duigan is severely underrated by those of us outside the club walls.
He works incredibly well with Laidler, our most important defender. He is intelligent and probably understands the structures better than anyone else on the field. He is courageous, and a highly capable defender.
I know it's a different code, but it's a team game and it's probably more relevant in our code than any other - a champion team beats a team of champions, any day of the week.
Case in point: the old Brazilian world cup winning squad was built around Pele - it was not always the best players that were chosen in this team, but the players that enhanced Pele's strengths and worked best with him.
We have a team of champions. Pound for pound we have probably more talent across every line than any other team in the competition, barring the expansion clubs. It's time to galvanise our talent into a champion team.
Look back to that North Melbourne game when Duigan was consistently 3rd man up, putting his body on the line in an attempt to slow the rampaging Petrie, closing the space and giving it his all. Now tell me he doesn't deserve to be playing Round 1!
He works incredibly well with Laidler, our most important defender. He is intelligent and probably understands the structures better than anyone else on the field. He is courageous, and a highly capable defender.
I know it's a different code, but it's a team game and it's probably more relevant in our code than any other - a champion team beats a team of champions, any day of the week.
Case in point: the old Brazilian world cup winning squad was built around Pele - it was not always the best players that were chosen in this team, but the players that enhanced Pele's strengths and worked best with him.
We have a team of champions. Pound for pound we have probably more talent across every line than any other team in the competition, barring the expansion clubs. It's time to galvanise our talent into a champion team.
Look back to that North Melbourne game when Duigan was consistently 3rd man up, putting his body on the line in an attempt to slow the rampaging Petrie, closing the space and giving it his all. Now tell me he doesn't deserve to be playing Round 1!
BluesBagger
Senior List
- Jul 28, 2012
- 155
- 122
- AFL Club
- Carlton
B :....Yarran......Jamison.....Laidler
HB:...Armfield...Henderson...Scotland*
C :....Gibbs........McLean.....Simpson
HF:...Robinson.....Waite*.....Betts
F :....Garlett......Casboult....Walker
R :....Judd..........Kruezer.....Murphy
IC: Carrazzo, Hampson, ?????
S: ?????
*For round 1:
Scotland replaced with Lucas
Waite (assuming he's not good to go) replaced with Rowe or Mitchell - who has had a good first hit out in the NB praccy match, hopefully he gets a chance next week.
The last interchange is still up for grabs with Lucas, Ellard, Bell, White, Curnow and 2E all a chance.
I'd like the sub to be used for one of the younger players as a taste at AFL footy, either Menzel, Temay, Buckley or Dale.
HB:...Armfield...Henderson...Scotland*
C :....Gibbs........McLean.....Simpson
HF:...Robinson.....Waite*.....Betts
F :....Garlett......Casboult....Walker
R :....Judd..........Kruezer.....Murphy
IC: Carrazzo, Hampson, ?????
S: ?????
*For round 1:
Scotland replaced with Lucas
Waite (assuming he's not good to go) replaced with Rowe or Mitchell - who has had a good first hit out in the NB praccy match, hopefully he gets a chance next week.
The last interchange is still up for grabs with Lucas, Ellard, Bell, White, Curnow and 2E all a chance.
I'd like the sub to be used for one of the younger players as a taste at AFL footy, either Menzel, Temay, Buckley or Dale.
B :Simpson Jamison White
HB:Laidler Henderson Tuohy
C :Gibbs McClean Yarran
HF:Walker Casboult Garlett
F :Betts Waite Kruezer
R: Hampson Judd Murphy
INT : Carrazzo Scotland Robinson SUB: Armfield
Pretty happy with last nights hitout minus Judd Waite Gibbs Casboult .
Seeing is believing and for mine Kruezer and Hampson have locked away the 2 big man spots , they work well as a team , can both go forward , and importantly are very competitive and just get 2 so many contests .
Really want 3 big defenders in the team , for too long weve been undersized and out muscled in defence and last night there it was again !! Jacobs resting forward and being manned up by Laidler !! Laidler is my favorite defender but doesnt play big and its a waste of his many talents !!
Was hoping Watson or even McCarthy would be the 3rd big defender but it looks as if Mick just doesnt think there ready yet , so , even though i like what White has shown forward ive got him starting as the 3rd big defender .
Really want the ball in the hands of Gibbs and Yarran going forward of centre ... bet Waite and Casboult do too !!
HB:Laidler Henderson Tuohy
C :Gibbs McClean Yarran
HF:Walker Casboult Garlett
F :Betts Waite Kruezer
R: Hampson Judd Murphy
INT : Carrazzo Scotland Robinson SUB: Armfield
Pretty happy with last nights hitout minus Judd Waite Gibbs Casboult .
Seeing is believing and for mine Kruezer and Hampson have locked away the 2 big man spots , they work well as a team , can both go forward , and importantly are very competitive and just get 2 so many contests .
Really want 3 big defenders in the team , for too long weve been undersized and out muscled in defence and last night there it was again !! Jacobs resting forward and being manned up by Laidler !! Laidler is my favorite defender but doesnt play big and its a waste of his many talents !!
Was hoping Watson or even McCarthy would be the 3rd big defender but it looks as if Mick just doesnt think there ready yet , so , even though i like what White has shown forward ive got him starting as the 3rd big defender .
Really want the ball in the hands of Gibbs and Yarran going forward of centre ... bet Waite and Casboult do too !!
fully fit list
B: Ladiler--Jamison--Armfield
HB: Scotland--Henderson--McInnes
C: Yarran--Gibbs--Mclean
HF: Walker--Waite--Robinson
F: Betts--Casboult--Garlett
R: Kreuzer--Judd--Murphy
INT: Simpson--Carrazzo--Hampson Sub: Tuohy/Bell
EMG: White--Lucas--Duigan--Curnow
A midfield of Judd ,Murphy ,Gibbs ,Kreuzer ,Carrazzo ,Simpson and Mclean with Yarran, Scottland ,Armfield ,Hampson ,Robinson ,Betts ,Garlett and Walker rotating through there starts to look pretty bloody good!!
Only concern is jammo and hendo seeming a little fresh atm need them to find form as quick as possible.
B: Ladiler--Jamison--Armfield
HB: Scotland--Henderson--McInnes
C: Yarran--Gibbs--Mclean
HF: Walker--Waite--Robinson
F: Betts--Casboult--Garlett
R: Kreuzer--Judd--Murphy
INT: Simpson--Carrazzo--Hampson Sub: Tuohy/Bell
EMG: White--Lucas--Duigan--Curnow
A midfield of Judd ,Murphy ,Gibbs ,Kreuzer ,Carrazzo ,Simpson and Mclean with Yarran, Scottland ,Armfield ,Hampson ,Robinson ,Betts ,Garlett and Walker rotating through there starts to look pretty bloody good!!
Only concern is jammo and hendo seeming a little fresh atm need them to find form as quick as possible.
McLean as sub isn't what we want/need. I like Lucas or Bell for sub at this point.
Even a tall like Hampson maybe.
Even a tall like Hampson maybe.
I can see White getting a game for round 1 as the swingman, quickish, tall, strong & mobile.
Murphy - Is like a springed coil for the season proper. Looks in super nick. The guy is a powerhouse like little Gaz. Back to 2011 MVP contention form for mine in 2013.
Armfield a sure starter every week. Pencil it in. Important player.
Boots - Where for art thou. I have faith.
Armfield a sure starter every week. Pencil it in. Important player.
Boots - Where for art thou. I have faith.
Agree with this , we need 3 big defenders which in turn free's up Laidler to fully utilize all his talents .
For all Duigans reported leadership qualities , at the end of the day if Carlton are to push into the top 4 his actual playing ability doesnt warrant a spot in the side and he shouldnt be keeping better players out !!
thylacine60
Post-Human
- Banned
- #818
Never, ever forget:
"McLean's marked but he can't kick the journey".
"McLean's marked but he can't kick the journey".
Here's my round one match ups prediction...
Morris, Griffiths, Chaplin
Betts, Casboult, Hampson
Ellis, Rance, Houli
Garlett, Walker, Armfield
Grigg, Deledio, Newman
Gibbs, Judd, Simpson
S Edwards, Vickery, Martin
Yarran, Henderson, Laidler
King, Riewoldt, McGuane
Tuohy, Jamison, White
Maric, Cotchin, Tuck
Kreuzer, Carrazzo, Murphy
White, Conca, Nahas, Vlastuin (s)
McLean, Robinson, Lucas, Bell (s)
Morris, Griffiths, Chaplin
Betts, Casboult, Hampson
Ellis, Rance, Houli
Garlett, Walker, Armfield
Grigg, Deledio, Newman
Gibbs, Judd, Simpson
S Edwards, Vickery, Martin
Yarran, Henderson, Laidler
King, Riewoldt, McGuane
Tuohy, Jamison, White
Maric, Cotchin, Tuck
Kreuzer, Carrazzo, Murphy
White, Conca, Nahas, Vlastuin (s)
McLean, Robinson, Lucas, Bell (s)
Jellycup_84
Senior List
dont think you are two far of the mark there zee
That's the team I'd go with, however I think Mick will pick Duigan ahead of Bell.
- Jun 25, 2011
- 2,738
- 4,944
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
I have that feeling too Stamos - especially with him promoted to the leadership group. I love Duigan, but he has given us ZIP (in my humble opinion) in the pre-season so far. And I can't see anyone from Zee's team that deserves to be in the magoos instead of him.
- Jun 25, 2011
- 2,738
- 4,944
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
Also - just something I heard....apparently Simon White is training the house down.
Similar threads
